Best QB Of All-Time #1 Poll #1

I have another threat with a poll, please go there to vote

thanks guys

peace
 
The best there ever was, the best there ever will be.

#12

Not even an argument.
 
cowboys19;1252989 said:
ill be back tomorrow with a real poll, i got to go gamble

peace

I guess he lost his car?
 
It would be hard to really prove anything between Montana, Graham, Elway, Roger, Aikman. Brady will possibly be added to that. Actually the next few years will tell a lot about Brady- his team is not as good now as it was a few years ago. Roger and Montana and Elway really were able to take teams farther then they should have gone other wise; to me that is the last great test of a QB after winning championships.
By the way on Graham- his team his first 4-5 years was absolutely the best in football at that time- but after that they started to lose people and were not quite as good.
 
Montana..and it isn't even close. Brady may catch him but he's still 2 SB's short. Montana was the best..he had the quick release and the ability to find the open guy. Like Brady, but Brady is still a distant second or third at this point.
 
sf49rh8r;1253558 said:
I'll explain it to you plain and simple....


Mr. Unitas...great leader..great passer and tough as nails

Mr. Staubach....just imagine if he'd come to the NFL straight out of college and if he hadn't had all of the concussions.

Mr. Marino......Did the most with the least.

Mr. Elway.......Finallly got the help Marino never got...

Mr. Montana....Most over rated over exposed over hyped QB...the precursor to Brady Quinn.


That's Gospel....

Hmmmm...sounds like jealousy to me. Montana was the best leader with the best knack for finding the open man, it isnt even close with the others.
 
rcaldw;1253915 said:
Yes, and all those perceptions have valid answers to them, but a message board doesn't afford the face to face time to answer and refute. Which is why, after stating an opinion, it is just better to let everyone run on about it.

For example, all those times that Emmitt didn't play and when we had trouble. When were those times?

Primarily TWO GAMES. (He didn't miss many games you know) Opening of 93 season. Why did we have so much trouble? It wasn't just football, it was a divided team as well, upset over contracts and money.

I can point you to PLAYOFF games, where Smith left very early in the game, due to injury, and we blew people out. But no one remembers those games and some don't want to. When we won the Super Bowl in 1995, Emmitt scored 2 gimme TD's, both set up by passes down to around the 2 or 1 yard line, but he made a VERY minimal impact in that game.

Nor do they want to remember 1990 when the Cowboys went on a winning streak to climb back into playoff contention with 2 games to go. Aikman went down to an injury at Philly. Babe Laufenburg came in.

EMMITT WAS STILL THERE.

Result? 2 straight losses.

People don't remember that, they remember 1991 when Aikman went down and Dallas went on a win streak with Beureline (sp?)

It is all about people creating the scenarios in their mind that they like.

Same with Roger. I was a HUGE Staubach fan. My favorite player ever. But I can point you to games I have on tape of him playing, at his height, when he stunk it up.

Roger WASN'T a better passer than Aikman. Just wasn't. Didn't win as many games. Didn't win as many SB's. But some will continue to think that Roger did nothing but win.

So, again, we all have our opinions, state them, have fun with them. But they are all (including mine), just that, opinions, and many of them based on superficial standards.

Excellent post. I notice some have an opinion, others opinions based on fact, and others who state they are subjectively making an opinion. That's where I usually am. I look at the sum experience thru my eyes then make an educated guess. No better or less than anyone else.

Again well stated. Post more!
 
My vote goes
1.Elway
2.Roger
3.Marino

I wish I could put Aikman in my top three but think he would probably be in that 7-10 range for me. Although, I think there were a few years where he played at an all time great level. Had Aikman not had the concussions and back issues that ended his career early, he would be right there in that top 5 at least.

Maybe it's my bias, but I always thought the system in SF made Montana. I think he would have been good but not an all time great had he gone to a different team. Young too, he was a journeyman QB until he got in SF's system and even Garcia looked awesome at one point in Bill Walsh's QB friendly system.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
464,992
Messages
13,841,602
Members
23,783
Latest member
Dstar69
Back
Top