Bledsoe or Roethlisberger?

juck · Apr 11, 2006

For 2006,so dont consider age.just for this upcoming year who would u want on this team?I pick by a landslide Bledsoe.He is going to have a stellar year.Hes a slinger and has the ultimate arsenal now.

clayman · Apr 11, 2006

wow just wow

Dayton Cowboy · Apr 11, 2006

Sorry Drew, but I would rather have Big Ben

Eddie · Apr 11, 2006

Only a blind fan would take Bledsoe over Rothlesberger.

Why is this thread even here???

CrazyCowboy · Apr 11, 2006

They both have a Super Bowl ring........I say Bledsoe since he is already signed

Gibbs II · Apr 11, 2006

I would pick ben because i have a brain.

theogt · Apr 11, 2006

This is actually kind of tough if you don't consider age. Bledsoe is clearly the better passer, but his lack of mobility may actually override that advantage. Given our line I would take Ben. Given Pitt's line I would take Bledsoe.

adbutcher · Apr 11, 2006

CrazyCowboy said:
They both have a Super Bowl ring........I say Bledsoe since he is already signed

:laugh2:

juck · Apr 11, 2006

Why are u guys so crazy about Ben?He isnt all that.His team on the other hand was.Give Bledsoe that kind of protection he will eat u up all day.

Doomsday101 · Apr 11, 2006

juckie said:
Why are u guys so crazy about Ben?He isnt all that.His team on the other hand was.Give Bledsoe that kind of protection he will eat u up all day.

I will agree that Ben threw the fewest passes of any starting QB in the league with 22 passes per game. Pitt has relied on a very good running game and Ben has been very effective when he has to throw. Bledsoe on the other hand because Dallas running this past season was less than steller it put a lot more pressure on Bledsoe and the Cowboys offense where he was throwing 31passes per game. I think if Dallas can get our running game going this season Drew has a chance to have one of his best season

SkinsFan26 · Apr 11, 2006

juckie said:
Why are u guys so crazy about Ben?He isnt all that.His team on the other hand was.Give Bledsoe that kind of protection he will eat u up all day.

His passer rating is ok (98.3). He won a Super Bowl in year 2. He's an outstanding passer with mobility. Roethlisberger is a top 5 QB. Bledsoe is around 15.

I thought only Giants fans bash Big Ben since they got Eli instead!

RCowboyFan · Apr 11, 2006

Eddie said:
Only a blind fan would take Bledsoe over Rothlesberger.

Why is this thread even here???

I agree. I can only add that the fan has to be Deaf and dumb adding to blind. The type of fan who rather have Peyton Manning than Tom Brady, since Peyton has tons of stats vs the wins like Brady/Aikman.

Eddie · Apr 11, 2006

SkinsFan26 said:
His passer rating is ok (98.3). He won a Super Bowl in year 2. He's an outstanding passer with mobility. Roethlisberger is a top 5 QB. Bledsoe is around 15.

I thought only Giants fans bash Big Ben since they got Eli instead!

No, Cowboy fans will generally bash any QB and player who is not a Cowboy. Once they become a Cowboy, they're untouchable.

Lemme rethink some of the threads I've read here ... Ben is over-rated, Delhomme is over-rated, Vick is over-rated, ah fugget it ... any player who isn't a Cowboy is over-rated.

clayman · Apr 11, 2006

Eddie said:
No, Cowboy fans will generally bash any QB and player who is not a Cowboy. Once they become a Cowboy, they're untouchable.

Lemme rethink some of the threads I've read here ... Ben is over-rated, Delhomme is over-rated, Vick is over-rated, ah fugget it ... any player who isn't a Cowboy is over-rated.

This doesn't start and end with just the QB position either. :lmao:

Kangaroo · Apr 11, 2006

I would take Big Ben because despite what ever you say he made the plays he had to to help win a Super Bowl and all year

He got err done as some people say and last I looked Bledsoe has a ring as a backup

juck · Apr 11, 2006

RCowboyFan said:
I agree. I can only add that the fan has to be Deaf and dumb adding to blind. The type of fan who rather have Peyton Manning than Tom Brady, since Peyton has tons of stats vs the wins like Brady/Aikman.

Joey harrington could have won a SB with the steelers Oline last year.

aikemirv · Apr 11, 2006

9-21 123 yards and 2 Int's

He did not get it done in that game.

They won, but please don't tell me it was because of him.

DragonCowboy · Apr 11, 2006

I would take Bledsoe, based on our two receivers.

Terry Glenn and Terrell Owens both like long balls. Bledsoe can throw bombs better than Roethlisberger, period.

juck · Apr 11, 2006

aikemirv said:
9-21 123 yards and 2 Int's

He did not get it done in that game.

They won, but please don't tell me it was because of him.

EXACTLY!!!! :bow:

.

DragonCowboy · Apr 11, 2006

juckie said:
EXACTLY!!!!.

Most of these posters attacking Bledsoe are just extremely negative (ie Eddie). Don't worry about them.

Bledsoe or Roethlisberger?

Well-Known Member

New Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Surrealist

K9NME

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Active Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Forum statistics