If stats don't matter, how can you tell when a QB is playing well?
Mahomes, Rodgers, Allen, Brady - these guys are the best in the game, and guess what, their performances produce stats. Because that's how it works. Play well=good stats. The fact that you all eschew stats now like it's some kind of mark against a guy (though to be fair, only Dak gets dinged for being good) is completely insane.
We don't think, oh man, Red Grossman was really underrated because even though he didn't have good 'stats', his team won a few games. No, he sucked and the statistics proved that.
Don't like Dak, fine. Can't win in the playoffs? True. Is he on the decline? Possibly. Is he injury prone now? Might be! But stop trying to bend reality (everything that objectively proves Dak is a good QB actually proves the opposite, somehow!) to make your argument.