News: BR: Cowboys' Ezekiel Elliott Falls out of ESPN's Top 10 RB Rankings Voted by NFL Insiders

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,951
Reaction score
4,044
Taylor, Henry, Chubb, Kamara, Cook, Mixon, Aaron Jones, McCaffrey, Ekeler, Montgomery, Jacobs, Najee Harris, Javonte Williams, Barkley, Pollard, Miles Sanders,

Rookies: Breece Hall, Ken Walker, Damion Pierce, Isiah Spiller, James Cook

Toss up with Zeke: Chris Carson, James Connor

So thats 20 backs I take over Zeke and two more possible. And there are probably a few more rookies as am not as familiar with I would take as well.


I see what you're saying but this list isn't accurate when talking about being a better OVERALL RB like Zeke, not just better runner or the fastest running back.

How many of those guys are better than Zeke in running the ball, yards after contact, running between the tackles, blocking ability, the awareness in blitz pickup and receiving out of the backfield, and DURABILITY!!! You can't sit here and make me believe there is 20 RBs in the NFL thats better than Zeke in ALL of these categories.

As far as McCaffery and Barkley.... when's the last time any of these guys played a whole season??? The best ability is AVAILABILITY. So scratch them off of the "better than Zeke" list.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I see what you're saying but this list isn't accurate when talking about being a better OVERALL RB like Zeke, not just better runner or the fastest running back.

How many of those guys are better than Zeke in running the ball, yards after contact, running between the tackles, blocking ability, the awareness in blitz pickup and receiving out of the backfield, and DURABILITY!!! You can't sit here and make me believe there is 20 RBs in the NFL thats better than Zeke in ALL of these categories.

As far as McCaffery and Barkley.... when's the last time any of these guys played a whole season??? The best ability is AVAILABILITY. So scratch them off of the "better than Zeke" list.

They are all better at running, catching, breaking tackles, ect....ect....

I would take them all over Zeke. Zeke cant even claim durability anymore.

Barkley I probably dont take.
 

Whyjerry

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,897
Reaction score
27,374
He ate, partied and Cabo’d his way out of the HOF. Guy had a rookie year for the ages and has been declining since.
 

G2

Taco Engineer
Messages
25,317
Reaction score
26,847
Elliott ranked out of the top 10, wouldn't guessed this would be a happier thread.
 

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,951
Reaction score
4,044
They are all better at running, catching, breaking tackles, ect....ect....

I would take them all over Zeke. Zeke cant even claim durability anymore.

Barkley I probably dont take.

Okay cool. So name the 20 RBs that have a complete game as Zeke does. Name the 20 RBs that run as hard as he does, gets as much yards after contact, blocks as well as he does, are as good in picking up the blitzer as he does, and have remained as healthy as he has for entire seasons.....

I'll wait....
 

NumOneQB

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,482
Reaction score
3,809
Going on 6 tough years as a NFL running back. He can come back slimmer and stronger for ‘22 and still will not come close to 2016 Zeke. I expect another year of decline for him and then he’ll be sent packing. Love Zeke, but this is how most NFL running backs careers go….
 

SteveTheCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
23,133
Reaction score
17,119
Okay cool. So name the 20 RBs that have a complete game as Zeke does. Name the 20 RBs that run as hard as he does, gets as much yards after contact, blocks as well as he does, are as good in picking up the blitzer as he does, and have remained as healthy as he has for entire seasons.....

I'll wait....
You are wasting your time. Cowboyroy....is the guy who put me on ignore when he complained Zeke was only rushing champ because of number of carries. I then showed him emmits carries per game and BAM! Ignored.

Zipped up tight in his hate.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
Okay cool. So name the 20 RBs that have a complete game as Zeke does. Name the 20 RBs that run as hard as he does, gets as much yards after contact, blocks as well as he does, are as good in picking up the blitzer as he does, and have remained as healthy as he has for entire seasons.....

I'll wait....

Only Zeke apologists talk about blocking. I want my RB's to run and catch.

Zekes blocking ability is way overblown and if you think other RB's cant block you are kidding yourself.

Nobody needs 30 carry backs anymore, another Zeke apologist theory.

I want backs that make plays and keep the chains moving. Not backs that get me to 3rd and long. Maybe Zeke should play FB, since you think his blocking is so great.

I gave my list of backs I would take over Zeke. That list still stands and I would take every single one over Zeke as my back.
 

GimmeTheBall!

Junior College Transfer
Messages
37,929
Reaction score
18,215
Only Zeke apologists talk about blocking. I want my RB's to run and catch.

Zekes blocking ability is way overblown and if you think other RB's cant block you are kidding yourself.

Nobody needs 30 carry backs anymore, another Zeke apologist theory.

I want backs that make plays and keep the chains moving. Not backs that get me to 3rd and long. Maybe Zeke should play FB, since you think his blocking is so great.

I gave my list of backs I would take over Zeke. That list still stands and I would take every single one over Zeke as my back.

Me handsome Roy, ask your critic how many yards Zeke had against the middling 49ers --- when it counted --- in the playoffs.
That should bring the discussion back to reality.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
43,781
Reaction score
29,452
1250 yards coming up

Don't know if he will be top 10 when you include ypc, but I do think, barring injur, he'll get 1250
and ? last year on one leg zeke got 1k..only ONE RB got over 1300 yards it was Taylor..2nd place 1200(chubb)..the rest of the SEVEN total backs who got 1k was ZEKE..before the injury Zeke was top 3 NFL back last year.,.yet he still finished 7th bruised back flowed by a torn PCL..i mean..ok whatever more hate threads Zeke and dak our best players top 5 on the team and yet the hate is palpable. Sorry fans really take every [possible shot they can at our own players. I guess they all suk huh all but one all finished with less than that 1250 you posted..reality check
 

plasticman

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,822
Reaction score
18,044
Wow, are you reading this Zeke?

I don't know about you, Zeke, but I would be feeling kind of disrespected right about now.

I guess it's a good thing to admit, pride is a vice. You are far more humble than I could be. Good for you!
 

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,951
Reaction score
4,044
Only Zeke apologists talk about blocking. I want my RB's to run and catch.

Zekes blocking ability is way overblown and if you think other RB's cant block you are kidding yourself.

Nobody needs 30 carry backs anymore, another Zeke apologist theory.

I want backs that make plays and keep the chains moving. Not backs that get me to 3rd and long. Maybe Zeke should play FB, since you think his blocking is so great.

I gave my list of backs I would take over Zeke. That list still stands and I would take every single one over Zeke as my back.

I heard what you had to say about Zeke apologists.... thank God im not one of them because im a realist. You said you want your RB to just run and catch, but its more to the RB position than that.

Not once did i say Zeke is the same back that he once was and I do believe we need to give Pollard more touches.... many more touches. With that said, blocking during blitz pickup is very important in today's game.

If its just "apologist" talk, why does Zeke get praise league wide from current AND Hall of Fame athletes who say Zeke is one of the best and most effective in blitz pickup/blocking????

Are they apologist too????
 

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,951
Reaction score
4,044
You are wasting your time. Cowboyroy....is the guy who put me on ignore when he complained Zeke was only rushing champ because of number of carries. I then showed him emmits carries per game and BAM! Ignored.

Zipped up tight in his hate.

Ahhhh.... so he's one of THOSE huh... ok gotcha. I knew he didn't know **** about football when he said he just want his RB to run and catch. I can tell his football IQ is not too strong.
 

DFWJC

Well-Known Member
Messages
60,238
Reaction score
49,016
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
and ? last year on one leg zeke got 1k..only ONE RB got over 1300 yards it was Taylor..2nd place 1200(chubb)..the rest of the SEVEN total backs who got 1k was ZEKE..before the injury Zeke was top 3 NFL back last year.,.yet he still finished 7th bruised back flowed by a torn PCL..i mean..ok whatever more hate threads Zeke and dak our best players top 5 on the team and yet the hate is palpable. Sorry fans really take every [possible shot they can at our own players. I guess they all suk huh all but one all finished with less than that 1250 you posted..reality check
Not sure what the point of your post is.
Are you ranting to me about others? Ranting at me for some reason?

I made a prediction of his stats this season. That's it.
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
Me handsome Roy, ask your critic how many yards Zeke had against the middling 49ers --- when it counted --- in the playoffs.
That should bring the discussion back to reality.

Yah, but he had a great blocking day. :lmao2::lmao::lmao2::laugh:
 

CowboyRoy

Well-Known Member
Messages
57,924
Reaction score
38,930
I heard what you had to say about Zeke apologists.... thank God im not one of them because im a realist. You said you want your RB to just run and catch, but its more to the RB position than that.

Not once did i say Zeke is the same back that he once was and I do believe we need to give Pollard more touches.... many more touches. With that said, blocking during blitz pickup is very important in today's game.

If its just "apologist" talk, why does Zeke get praise league wide from current AND Hall of Fame athletes who say Zeke is one of the best and most effective in blitz pickup/blocking????

Are they apologist too????

Whatever you apologists may think, running and catching are the two most important skills of a back. Thats why they call them "running" backs. :thumbup:

Blocking backs are called fullbacks.

You think they pay Zeke 18 million for his blocking abilities? :lmao::lmao2:
 
Top