Yes, Broaddus is a polarizing media person. He obviously is much more knowledgeable than most guys like Calvin Watkins, etc. The problem is that he is as emotional as fans and he does not use good logic.
He just reports whatever comes to mind without thinking it through. He has reported that players appear to be out of shape when it turns out the the player is not moving well due to injury. He has pet cats every year that he continues to try to sell. If he ever predicted that a player would be good or bad, he will continue to try to convince everybody that he was correct. Floyd was one example.
The other thing that he does is intermix his own opinions with what he's heard from the Cowboys coaches/scout/front-office. He sometimes has good info if you can determine that it was something that he has been told; however, if it was just his own idea, then he's usually wrong. In the off-season he said that he (Broaddus) would like to see Carter move to SLB and rush the passer more. Most people took that to mean that he had been told this information, but if you listen to his actual statement, it was just his own idea.
He reported the other day that Carter was a SLB and Wilber at WLB. Marinelli can out and somewhat tried to explain it. Basically, the 3-tech does not always shift sides when the TE lines up on the defensive right, even though technically that is now the Strong Side. Marinelli said that the WLB is always behind the 3-tech, which was a reference to plays where the TE lines up on the defensive right which changes the DL from a 4-3 under to a 4-3 over if the 3-tech does not move. The WLB is now on the strong side, but he's still not playing what they call the SLB position. It seems like Broaddus should have understood this concept, but instead he just reported that Carter and Wilber had switched positions.