What exactly has Dak done to warrant being a top 4 tp 6 QB?
You're right. Mahomes, Rodgers, and Wilson are no comparison.
Dak IMO is also clearly behind Brady(GOAT), Allen (MVP if not for Rodgers), Watson (I just think he's better and I believe any GM would take him over Dak, including Jerry), and Jackson (former MVP and lead the league in TDs with Hollywood Brown as a #1 reciever). You're right about Herbert also. If he can improve on last year he will be up there too.
I think that out of all those QBs only Mahomes and Brady have as many, if not more, weapons at their disposal than Dak. I also think that Dak clearly needs much more help then a lot of the other top QBs to succeed. That's why a massive contracts scares me.
Dak is better than Lamar, who is one heck of an athlete, but mediocre at best at the actual position of Quarterbacking. Now I agree with you. There is a such thing as eye test, and I respect that. I respect that you feel Watson is better, but I also saw that Dak with Amari out performed Watson with Hopkins. I think many people get caught up on where Dak was drafted, and what he was in year 2. Hes no longer that guy that was a 1 progression passer.
These are things Ive noticed about Dak and this discussion. People dont judge Dak on the same criteria: 1. Dak has always performed when the cowboys were down and the cuffs were removed. It may not always lead to a win, but you have the chance to win. Many times a lead was secured just to have defense give up the lead....AGAIN. 2. Keep in mind. Ive said that Russell Wilson is better. But what has he done with out one heck of a defense, but because he has a superbowl where the Defense was the key element he gets an automatic pass.
3. Would Mahomes have won the games that Dak lost last year before injury if the Defense was giving up 38 points a game. Why is Dak blamed for that?
4. Once again, why is Diggs, John Brown and Beasley not considered help? Diggs had 1550 yds and Beasley had 1000 yds receiving. Plus a defense that stops someone.
My point is this. If Dak had a Defense...he would win games. Hes won games with a mediocre defense and a running game, and he won 13 of them. 12 in row at one point...Dak is the least of our problems. He and Zach Martin are the 2 best players on this team. If this Defense is 75% as good as Baltimore, and Buffalo....Dak wins 12 games easily.