If this was the case they would simply take the fifth year option (2025) in Lance's deal and pay him like the starting QB you think he will be. And they aren't doing that.
I have a feeling this forum is going to explode when the Cowboys extend Dak again. Because- if only for cap relief- they have no alternative.
Depends how much the extension would cost. For instance if they kept him at 40 million APY and extended him for 3 years. I’d be fine with it. I’m in the “Dak needs to go crowd”. I would be happy with that scenario because it would give Lance enough time to develop, kind of like how Romo sat the bench for 4 years.
I would be in the “explosion crowd” if we signed Dak to an extension paying him Justin Herbert or Joe Burrow money. That would be franchise suicide IMO. Dak is older, slower, and is less accurate. He’s also lost a lot of his playmaking abilities since the ankle injury. And that’s just the physical aspect, mentally he was never a big time player. In playoffs he’s not played well against good competition.
I look at it this way. I wanted Zeke to come back but for a million or 2. Zeke was declining in skills and wasn’t a #1 back. So keeping Zeke at the right price I felt was a good idea because he did some things well. We still need a short yardage guy. I feel the same way about Dak, he’s declining physically. If we sign him to a very team friendly deal, 35-40 million then great. If he resets the market then we’re screwed. IMO it would be like signing Zeke or Gallup to a market setting deal. You can’t sign a declining player to a massive contract. That’s what scares me. This article said they are planning on a MASSIVE extension. That’s very bad news for us. Unless he wins the Super Bowl and shows he can show up for big games.