Dak doubters

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,391
I think you are going somewhere with that and I am trying to stay away from "that" place, so please, let's not put me in "that" box.

“Trying” implies it might be a struggle for you to stay away from “that” place.
 

LovinItAll

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,750
Reaction score
1,824
Dak's defense does fail him but he wasn't very accurate in the past. A lot of his throws were over the top or behind the receivers but fortunately for us we have athletic receivers. If we had Kupp or Woods instead, Dak would look way worst.

I didn't say I would take Tannehill or Cousins over Dak but Cousins is one of the most accurate QB in the NFL for many years now. Dak has more heart and passion than both of those quarterbacks.

Taking Dak over Herbert is just delusional. Dak doesn't do a single thing better than Herbert and he can't carry his team like Herbert can. We would have gotten blown out if Herbert 2 touchdowns counted. Its not Herbert fault his team commit stupid penalties. With that said according to Vegas odds, Herbert is 7th in MVP voting and ahead of Dak.

https://www.vegasinsider.com/nfl/odds/mvp/

Keep telling yourself Dak isn't accurate. He leads the league in completion percentage. Dak has had to play with pathetic defenses. Herbert is an unproven QB. Dak had a better rookie season than Herbert, so just stop it. Talk to me about Hebert when he's further along than - what - 19 games into his pro career?

It's not Dak's fault his defense can't stop other teams from scoring. Not that QBs play each other, but didn't we just play a team led by Herbert? I think we did. I think we also won that game. I don't play the 'ifs and buts' game. If I did, Dak would've led his team to the NFC title game in his rookie campaign. Herbert had a losing season in his.

You don't think Dak does a single thing better than Herbert? Dak has a higher QB rating, a higher completion percentage, and his average completion is longer than Herbert's. He'd have more yards in the air, but our running game is clicking, so he doesn't have to throw the ball 40+ times/gake. He's also thrown the same number of TDs and one fewer pick than Justin. I'd say that I don't think Herbert does a single thing better than Dak. He certainly isn't the leader Dak is.

Will Herbert be a better QB than Dak when all is said said and done? I don't know, and neither do you. Right now, I'd take Dak over Herbert and it isn't even close.
 

USArmyVet

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,708
Reaction score
15,031
Keep telling yourself Dak isn't accurate. He leads the league in completion percentage. Dak has had to play with pathetic defenses. Herbert is an unproven QB. Dak had a better rookie season than Herbert, so just stop it. Talk to me about Hebert when he's further along than - what - 19 games into his pro career?

It's not Dak's fault his defense can't stop other teams from scoring. Not that QBs play each other, but didn't we just play a team led by Herbert? I think we did. I think we also won that game. I don't play the 'ifs and buts' game. If I did, Dak would've led his team to the NFC title game in his rookie campaign. Herbert had a losing season in his.

You don't think Dak does a single thing better than Herbert? Dak has a higher QB rating, a higher completion percentage, and his average completion is longer than Herbert's. He'd have more yards in the air, but our running game is clicking, so he doesn't have to throw the ball 40+ times/gake. He's also thrown the same number of TDs and one fewer pick than Justin. I'd say that I don't think Herbert does a single thing better than Dak. He certainly isn't the leader Dak is.

Will Herbert be a better QB than Dak when all is said said and done? I don't know, and neither do you. Right now, I'd take Dak over Herbert and it isn't even close.


You criticize Herbert by saying he only has 19 games to his career yet celebrate Dak's Comp % when it has only been 3 games.....see the hypocrisy?
 

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,391
Keep telling yourself Dak isn't accurate. He leads the league in completion percentage. Dak has had to play with pathetic defenses. Herbert is an unproven QB. Dak had a better rookie season than Herbert, so just stop it. Talk to me about Hebert when he's further along than - what - 19 games into his pro career?

It's not Dak's fault his defense can't stop other teams from scoring. Not that QBs play each other, but didn't we just play a team led by Herbert? I think we did. I think we also won that game. I don't play the 'ifs and buts' game. If I did, Dak would've led his team to the NFC title game in his rookie campaign. Herbert had a losing season in his.

You don't think Dak does a single thing better than Herbert? Dak has a higher QB rating, a higher completion percentage, and his average completion is longer than Herbert's. He'd have more yards in the air, but our running game is clicking, so he doesn't have to throw the ball 40+ times/gake. He's also thrown the same number of TDs and one fewer pick than Justin. I'd say that I don't think Herbert does a single thing better than Dak. He certainly isn't the leader Dak is.

Will Herbert be a better QB than Dak when all is said said and done? I don't know, and neither do you. Right now, I'd take Dak over Herbert and it isn't even close.

If we swapped the two QBs all of sudden the haters would be pining for Dak and saying Herbert sucks. They have a mental illness for which there is no cure.
 

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
41,613
Reaction score
28,471
Lmao! So brave.
glad you were able top decipher that,

i mean the rest of my content you so eloquently talked trash about was not...hmm

so brave of you how bout leave the negativity out of response unless you want it back.

apparently my content is legible enough to receive 14, 517 likes since mid 2018 and i hardly write anything or start threads.

i use forums the same way i text, tweet, and facebook..im not trying to provide a gradable paper for review by grammar and spelling Karen's and stans..when this is just a quick hit, read, respond. and multi-task while working hobby for me. etc..

if you dont like my content, don't read nor respond..Ill live..but if you want to take jabs at it, ill be right here to respond in kind.
 

G2

Taco Engineer
Messages
24,773
Reaction score
26,402
glad you were able top decipher that,

i mean the rest of my content you so eloquently talked trash about was not...hmm

so brave of you how bout leave the negativity out of response unless you want it back.

apparently my content is legible enough to receive 14, 517 likes since mid 2018 and i hardly write anything or start threads.

i use forums the same way i text, tweet, and facebook..im not trying to provide a gradable paper for review by grammar and spelling Karen's and stans..when this is just a quick hit, read, respond. and multi-task while working hobby for me. etc..

if you dont like my content, don't read nor respond..Ill live..but if you want to take jabs at it, ill be right here to respond in kind.
Barely, you need to proof read your "content" so that it makes sense when reading. Sorry if that's such a huge thing to ask. I make mistakes but damn dude. It's like a caveman's cave drawings.

I'm so happy for you and all of your "likes," they matter.
 

Blake

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,814
Reaction score
9,391
I don't NEED to do anything, ok egomaniac , likes mean most got the general gist of my posts enough to like them, now go lick yourself.

Go lick yourself?

giphy.gif



The fact that you tally up your likes and brag about them in public is kinda sad.
 

Aulac

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,048
Reaction score
713
Keep telling yourself Dak isn't accurate. He leads the league in completion percentage. Dak has had to play with pathetic defenses. Herbert is an unproven QB. Dak had a better rookie season than Herbert, so just stop it. Talk to me about Hebert when he's further along than - what - 19 games into his pro career?

It's not Dak's fault his defense can't stop other teams from scoring. Not that QBs play each other, but didn't we just play a team led by Herbert? I think we did. I think we also won that game. I don't play the 'ifs and buts' game. If I did, Dak would've led his team to the NFC title game in his rookie campaign. Herbert had a losing season in his.

You don't think Dak does a single thing better than Herbert? Dak has a higher QB rating, a higher completion percentage, and his average completion is longer than Herbert's. He'd have more yards in the air, but our running game is clicking, so he doesn't have to throw the ball 40+ times/gake. He's also thrown the same number of TDs and one fewer pick than Justin. I'd say that I don't think Herbert does a single thing better than Dak. He certainly isn't the leader Dak is.

Will Herbert be a better QB than Dak when all is said said and done? I don't know, and neither do you. Right now, I'd take Dak over Herbert and it isn't even close.

I can't BELIEVE what I just read. The fact that you think Dak is better than Herbert is just sad.

Completion percentages doesn't matter when most of his throws is checkdown. Most of Dak's stats is from garbage time when he facing prevent defense. You know prevent defense doesn't stop anything right?!?

Herbert is an unproven QB? Win and Loss isn't a QB stat otherwise Jared Goff is 2nd to Brady in all times win in the last 5 years. The Cowboys is still a better organization than the Chargers. How come Phillip Rivers couldn't bring the Chargers to the playoff in the last few years? Is Rivers also a garbage QB as well?

How does Dak have a better rookie season than Herbert when Herbert broke the rookie record for touchdown? His first game, he blew out the Chiefs until Lynn went with prevent defense and that was with no pre-season and practice of any kind. He literally a generational talent at the QB position. Dak is not a generational talent.
 

Kumbaya

Well-Known Member
Messages
333
Reaction score
525
I can't BELIEVE what I just read. The fact that you think Dak is better than Herbert is just sad.

Completion percentages doesn't matter when most of his throws is checkdown. Most of Dak's stats is from garbage time when he facing prevent defense. You know prevent defense doesn't stop anything right?!?

Herbert is an unproven QB? Win and Loss isn't a QB stat otherwise Jared Goff is 2nd to Brady in all times win in the last 5 years. The Cowboys is still a better organization than the Chargers. How come Phillip Rivers couldn't bring the Chargers to the playoff in the last few years? Is Rivers also a garbage QB as well?

How does Dak have a better rookie season than Herbert when Herbert broke the rookie record for touchdown? His first game, he blew out the Chiefs until Lynn went with prevent defense and that was with no pre-season and practice of any kind. He literally a generational talent at the QB position. Dak is not a generational talent.

Did I miss something a few weeks back? But I could have sworn Dak bested The Generational Talent 20-17. How could that be?

And as far as I could tell, you have not provided any cogent proof to show why Hebert is BETTER than Dak. I agree, Hebert is good and has some impressive numbers for a second year pro, but Daks numbers were at least just as good in his first two years. Maybe you should hold off before declaring someone GENERATIONAL, whatever that really means.
 

CarolinaFathead

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,924
Reaction score
2,419
I can't BELIEVE what I just read. The fact that you think Dak is better than Herbert is just sad.

Completion percentages doesn't matter when most of his throws is checkdown. Most of Dak's stats is from garbage time when he facing prevent defense. You know prevent defense doesn't stop anything right?!?

Herbert is an unproven QB? Win and Loss isn't a QB stat otherwise Jared Goff is 2nd to Brady in all times win in the last 5 years. The Cowboys is still a better organization than the Chargers. How come Phillip Rivers couldn't bring the Chargers to the playoff in the last few years? Is Rivers also a garbage QB as well?

How does Dak have a better rookie season than Herbert when Herbert broke the rookie record for touchdown? His first game, he blew out the Chiefs until Lynn went with prevent defense and that was with no pre-season and practice of any kind. He literally a generational talent at the QB position. Dak is not a generational talent.

Khiladi, all we care to know from you is do you think Dalton is still GOAT?

That’s all.
 
Last edited:

Aulac

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,048
Reaction score
713
Did I miss something a few weeks back? But I could have sworn Dak bested The Generational Talent 20-17. How could that be?

And as far as I could tell, you have not provided any cogent proof to show why Hebert is BETTER than Dak. I agree, Hebert is good and has some impressive numbers for a second year pro, but Daks numbers were at least just as good in his first two years. Maybe you should hold off before declaring someone GENERATIONAL, whatever that really means.

Wow I didn't know Dak bested Herbert? All I remember was that Herbert had 2 Touchdowns passed called back due to stupid penalties on his team. So basically Chargers without penalty would beat us by 11 points. That some Dak's cooking you got there. We didn't beat the Chargers, they beated themselves with stupid penalties. Despite the fact we have a more talented roster than them.

I don't care about the numbers because Dak has prime Zeke just like Goff had prime Gurley. Ekeler is a good RB but he no workhorse and he no Zeke. And I don't know if you bought it up or somewhere else did, but Jared Goff also went 13-3 outplayed Drew Brees in the NFCCG while down 13 - 0 and made it to the Superbowl. Dak went 13-3 and couldn't even sniff the NFCCG. Of course McVay a genius and JG stink at coaching. That what I mean when you just look at stats. Go watch Herbert play football, and see how truly special he is.
 
Top