Dak is still the best QB in the division

acr731

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,081
Reaction score
27,960
jwitten82 said:
Far from a Dak fan, just telling it is. You really think if Dallas somehow switched Dak with either Hurts or Purdy that we'd be in a better position?
Click to expand...
If Purdy played for this current Dallas roster, yes, I think they would have a better offense. Hurts too. Purdy has barely played a full season in his young career, but he already seems to make better decisions than Dak. The Dallas offense wouldn't be perfect with Purdy, but I think they would be putting more points on the board.
 
blueblood70

blueblood70

Well-Known Member
Messages
42,018
Reaction score
28,633
jwitten82 said:
Far from a Dak fan, just telling it is. You really think if Dallas somehow switched Dak with either Hurts or Purdy that we'd be in a better position?
Click to expand...
perfect analogy ,

it wouldn't,

Dak would be better off that is the point. we took away so much talent on the offense side of the ball dak was comfortable with and hes still performing well.. the hate is unwarranted. It gets old.. the goal post is constantly moved for prescott...
And yet media and fans somehow give the other guys passes for all their problems....
 

jwitten82

Well-Known Member
Messages
10,494
Reaction score
16,350
acr731 said:
Dak could have both of them and it wouldn't matter the way he keeps over throwing his receivers.
Click to expand...
Look I'm all for drafting a QB, but the qbs y'all try to pump up from other teams aren't better. Dak, Purdy , Hurts, and Herbert from the games I've watched all had some bad overthrows
 
acr731

acr731

Jerry learned to GM from Pee Wee Herman
Messages
10,081
Reaction score
27,960
jwitten82 said:
Look I'm all for drafting a QB, but the qbs y'all try to pump up from other teams aren't better. Dak, Purdy , Hurts, and Herbert from the games I've watched all had some bad overthrows
Click to expand...
Ok, I'll stop here. Its going to be like trying to argue with someone over whether or not water is wet. I have my opinion, you have yours. There's nothing left to say.

Dak has hit his ceiling while Purdy is just beginning his career. We'll see how things are when Purdy reaches year 8 like Dak.
 

CowboysFaninHouston

CowboysFaninDC
Messages
33,925
Reaction score
19,483
KJJ said:
Purdy was 10-0 until the loss last week. He’s put up slightly better numbers than Justin Herbert and he wins games unlike Herbert who’s 27-27 as a starting QB. I think Herbert is overrated based on his numbers and big arm. No one has to be crazy to take Purdy over Herbert based off what we’ve seen of the two QBs the past season and a half. Granted Herbert has a better pedigree, but the wins aren’t coming with him.
Click to expand...
lets see how Purdy does without McCaffrey after a few games. Purdy is good, but he is also a system QB, that relies on strong running game setting up passes. if the threat of run game is not there, teams will drop more into coverage and it makes it harder for him. so not judging, but against cleveland he folded.
 
Aven8

Aven8

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,874
Reaction score
45,439
While that’s not saying much, I agree. Dak is the best. Having said that I would take Purdy over him right this very second and not look back.
 
GMO415

GMO415

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,341
Reaction score
26,111
jwitten82 said:
Look I'm not the biggest Dak fan, you can look at my history. I think if Dallas doesn't at least reach a championship game, then Dak and this coaching staff need to go, and no I don't want Quinn as a HC either.

So back to QB
Giants- Jones will most likely not be a starter next year, Terry Bradshaw was throwing for more tds in the 70s, and I'm serious, I looked it up lol. Giants made a huge mistake in signing him

Washington - Howell is another backup, enough said

Eagles - The eagles are a talented team, had two number one receivers and a top oline and Hurts is underperforming big time, 7td and 7 ints is horrible. Yes he made it to a Superbowl, while surrounded by a better team/organization,but I don't think if we were to switch qbs that our situation would be better, matter of fact I think we have at least one more loss. Dak as a passer is better than Hurts, not impressed with Hurts 22 pass tds last season either.

Also not a popular opinion, but yea Id still take Dak over Purdy. He like Hurts, is surrounded by talent, and if they start losing that talent I do not expect Purdy to be the one to elevate that team. Still not sold on Purdy

Honestly, haven't been that impressed with Dak this season either, but I think he gives us a better chance as strictly a passer than the qbs mentioned above. Come at me bros
Click to expand...
Hurts is playing average ball but he gets a pas because he played in a SB.
 
Mr_437

Mr_437

Well-Known Member
Messages
18,327
Reaction score
20,146
Doesn't matter if Dak isn't the best when they play Playoff games who cares.
 
StarOfGlory

StarOfGlory

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,494
Reaction score
4,809
Dak has a better arm than Purdy but Purdy sees the field very well and minimizes mistakes, akin to a young Brady. Purdy and Dak have about the same mobility these days, but Dak showed that he can still be effective as a runner picking his spots.

Sam Howell's ceiling is probably low-end starter.

Jones is just bad. Granted, his o-line is putrid.

Hurts is the real question. He throws a very nice deep ball. He seems to be 100% recovered from his injury. He is athletic. But something is off this year, and here's where I have to give a shout out to all the posters that said the loss of Shane Steichen could be the biggest off season loss for the Eagles. I think I'm on your side. Whoever is calling plays for the Eagles looks lost at times. Maybe he doesn't see the field as well as he should. I have never seen a QB consistently get 5-6 seconds in the pocket and not find a receiver. This with a group that wins more contested balls than just about any receiver group. Of course they are 5-1, so something is still working.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top