I think what most of you are seeing is McCarthy’s conservative approach. He said all off-season that the defense is the strength of our team and he wants to play the game through them. Right or wrong, that’s what he hated about Kellen Moore; Moore was all out all the time, which some fans like, but it occasionally backfired and cost us games that we had in hand. When we have a nice lead and the defense plays well, and the other team is imploding, McCarthy calls a conservative game, dinking and dunking based onthe score is like running the ball in the old days to eat clock. He will dink and dunk when he feels the OL can’t protect. Mike, as a head coach, just wants to win. That is not unlike Jimmy Johnson. Then Johnson’s Cowboys had a lead, he was very conservative. We didn’t blow a lot of teams out, and Troy Aikman had many wins throwing the ball only 20-24 times.
When the defense crapped the bed vs the Cardinals, we should have seen a good test for the offense, but Mike admitted that due to the OL, he called a much too conservative game.
If our defense shows up vs SF on Sunday night, I expect Mike to call it like a playoff game, somewhat conservatively. It will either be a low scoring, defensive battle, or a surprising, uncharacteristic shootout. But even if our defense plays well, don’t expect Mike to be throwing the ball 35-40 times and taking deep shots all game. He’s just very unlikely to call a game like that. He has a way that he thinks is the best way to win games. It’s not the Kellen Moore way on offense. Time will tell who is correct.