Most critics have no more credibility than I do, and analysts aren't always objective. And I note your word "argue", implying that there's disagreement, and room for re-evaluation. I'm certainly open to the argument that the team is loaded with talent, but the way I view it, if the team is "loaded" with talent, they shouldn't have gone 8-8 last year, even with Garrett as the HC. Too many times I have seen Awuzie, other DBs totally lost on plays or just beaten badly on pass routes, too many tackles missed, too many missed "easy" throws, too many DEs and DTs stonewalled by average, non-Pro Bowl offensive linemen, etc.
I'm not going to sit here and say I'm always right or a top NFL analyst, but I haven't seen anything that would change my opinion to this point...