Dak Prescott Voted By Players as the 16th Best Player in the Entire League

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,613
Reaction score
16,388
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I’m pro Dak why would I be bothered by this post lol? Explain.


It doesn’t help the Cowboys which is exactly why I said why are yall upset over this lol.
Good, at least you acknowledge this silly poll does not help the Cowboys, it just a fluff piece for Dak fans, and that's cool.
 

cmoney23

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,754
Reaction score
2,226
Dak fan girls won't be able to defend this one because Hurts is above Dak and they call Hurts a bum any chance they get.

Gotta love it.
spinning-plates.gif
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,681
Reaction score
12,791
So every QB gets like 10 of those TDs a year? Yeah, sorry, not buying it.

You go down the list and he had a pretty mediocre year.

Completion %: 15th
Passing TDs: 13th
TD %: 17th
Yards: 14th
Y/A: 14th
Y/C: 15th
Total Int: 3rd
Int %: 27th
Rating: 20th
QBR: 13th
Total Fumbles: 10th

There is no legitimate case to be made that Hurts had a really good year and certainly for all our *****ing about Dak, Prescott had a much better 2023 season.
It’s not 10 because their offense didn’t put them in the position to do so, that’s why Jalen has not just more short yardage passing/rushing TDs, but total TDs than almost every other QB. He put them there more often. A lot of that is the personnel, yes, but that’s the same for every QB. Everything Burrow has done has been with the best trio of receivers the league has seen in a while. Dak has been better and better as CeeDee has gotten better and better. Matt Ryan won an MVP that most certainly wouldn’t have happened without Julio.

We can theorize what they’d be in different situations, but we can only verify what they are when they’re where they are right now.
 

visionary

Well-Known Member
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
33,292
:eek: Naw….no way in hell this came from you……
I have stated my position on Dak previously
I dont ‘hate’ him
I think Dak is a VERY good QB in the regular season but he can get confused by defenses and goes into a shell when that happens. As a result he has real issues playing consistently good football for a 3-4 game stretch against the top teams and that is what you need to win a SB
I have no doubt we can win 10-11 games with Dak but we cannot win a SB with him. Thats why i dont think hes worth even 50 million (let alone 60) and thats why i want to move on from him
Its not ‘hate’ its how i see it
 

Mikexike

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,289
Reaction score
1,751
I have stated my position on Dak previously
I dont ‘hate’ him
I think Dak is a VERY good QB in the regular season but he can get confused by defenses and goes into a shell when that happens. As a result he has real issues playing consistently good football for a 3-4 game stretch against the top teams and that is what you need to win a SB
I have no doubt we can win 10-11 games with Dak but we cannot win a SB with him. Thats why i dont think hes worth even 50 million (let alone 60) and thats why i want to move on from him
Exact reason why i want to move on from him.
 

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,613
Reaction score
16,388
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
He's in grade school...can't wait for school to start..he'll only be able to post during recess and detention!
:muttley:
lol...look at you siding with the, Durr...Durr...Durr...Dak be dis and Dak bee dat.

I'm ashamed of you.
 

leeblair

Well-Known Member
Messages
3,769
Reaction score
5,965
How do you explain the Hurts rating? He had already signed his deal.
That's more evidence of what I said. NO ONE would rank Hurts at 15 after last season unless there is some sort of ulterior motive.
I don't pretend to know what it is, but I know it isn't right. He seems like a great guy, but not 15th best in the NFL.
There has to be a reason behind it.
 

Aerolithe_Lion

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,681
Reaction score
12,791
So every QB gets like 10 of those TDs a year? Yeah, sorry, not buying it.

You go down the list and he had a pretty mediocre year.

Completion %: 15th
Passing TDs: 13th
TD %: 17th
Yards: 14th
Y/A: 14th
Y/C: 15th
Total Int: 3rd
Int %: 27th
Rating: 20th
QBR: 13th
Total Fumbles: 10th

There is no legitimate case to be made that Hurts had a really good year and certainly for all our *****ing about Dak, Prescott had a much better 2023 season.
Those stats only hold up if you completely ignore the fact that he is a true dual threat QB. This here is how you would evaluate the blonde haired, blue eyed QBs of the past who ran a 6 second 40.

If a RB “A” runs for 1600 yards and catches 200 yards,

And then RB “B” runs for 1300 yards and catches 1000…

RB A is the better RB right? Because RB B only had 1300 yards. He’s not a receiver, he’s a RB.

Jalen hurts had SIX HUNDRED rushing yards last year. Plays where he made a conscious effort to expose the defense and pick up yards that would have otherwise necessitated a throwaway or a pass into coverage. The only argument to why that should be ignored when evaluating a QB’s ability to drive the offense down the field would be that another QB is physically incapable of doing that so it would be inconvenient to use it against him. In the same way Derrick Henry and Marshall Faulk are not the same type of player, Dak Prescott and Jalen Hurts are not the same type of player.

Rushing yards are a quarterback stat. So are rushing TDs.
 

5Stars

Here comes the Sun...
Messages
37,613
Reaction score
16,388
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
It’s whatever you want it to be. Because I never see you have a issue with negative Dak threads and writing them off.
There is a reason for that. You see, I'm a Cowboy fan first. I really don't care about Dak this or Dak that. I just let the Dak fans be happy is all.
 
Top