Dak was the worst player on the field today *MERGE*

[Redsfan_83]

Guys, Herbert was arguably a top 3 QB who wasn't drafted when he should have. Dak was a 4th rounder, so although we have hoped he would be worth the contract, it seems at this time he isn't. In a few years time when Allen, Herb get their money Dak's contract won't look as bad. Right now it is becoming evident he is not worth what we are paying and Justin is an incredible talent

 

[cowboyec]

he is when healthy.
and i think he is even now.

 

[Mk2_Cowboys]

Dak haters are never ending entertainment . Stafford , Carr , Lamar , have all had multiple terrible games this year . Yes Dak is top ten he’s in the 8-10 range . Putting him out of the top ten is just hate and its not based on wins or stats .

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Mahomes
4. Wilson
5. Murray
6. Herbert
7. Jackson
8. Carr
9. Stafford
10. Dak
At worst he's tenth

 

[MizzouCowboy4]

It's obvious that some here have an agenda against Dak....he's signed and here for at least 3 years.....let it go

I like Dak. But he has to find that high level.

 

[MizzouCowboy4]

Dak haters are never ending entertainment . Stafford , Carr , Lamar , have all had multiple terrible games this year . Yes Dak is top ten he’s in the 8-10 range . Putting him out of the top ten is just hate and its not based on wins or stats .

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Mahomes
4. Wilson
5. Murray
6. Herbert
7. Jackson
8. Carr
9. Stafford
10. Dak
At worst he's tenth

I put him over Stafford and carr

 

[Darkhound]

If you’re so brilliant and care about the team, apply for the job and save us.✊

I am just a fan... i never once said i would be a bette gm

 

[Mk2_Cowboys]

I put him over Stafford and carr

So do I but i was making a point that no way hes out of top ten

 

[plasticman]

Dak is still recovering and I'm not talking about his most recent issues. You don't just return to form immediately after a compound fracture and ankle dislocation. Let's be real about that. It's going to take 18 months to two years for Dak to fully recover.

And the real problem is that the Cowboys are depending more on Dak at a point in time where they should be taking more pressure off him with a strong running game. Unfortunately, The O-line issues added to the RB injuries make that difficult, hence the lack of offensive production.

Both Dak and Zeke and now Pollard are battling injury issues and playing as much as they can but there are going to be some obvious drop off. They will all eventually recover but for now, let's be grateful for the emergence of an elite defense and it's very critical timing.

 

[Redsfan_83]

If the title of this thread is he hasn't been the same since the horrible ankle injury I would agree. Rodgers has a bad lil toe and he is an assassin. Surely a bad calf can't account for his bad decision making and inability to hit an open receiver. I do think something else is going on though....

 

[StarChamber_33]

The INT he threw late in the 4th quarter was the worst pick he ever threw.. He never saw Holcomb standing in front of Schultz which is hard to believe after watching the replay several times.. It was an ugly finish but no harm done, we got the win. **One of the qualities I most admire about Dak is his RESILIENCE, he has dealt with a lot of pain and loss in his personal life which has made him STRONGER, I believe he will bounce back. Is he a TOP 5 QB? Is he a TOP 10 QB?? Who knows.. Who cares.. bottom line is, can he lead this team to a Super Bowl?? My friends, that is the $40 million dollar question.

 

[Risen Star]

Where has all the MVP talk gone Mrs. Robinson?

Shows you how little most people know about the game when they think that bum is the most valuable player in the league.

If they gave him that award for some God unknown reason they should have someone carry him to the podium to accept it. It would be fitting.

 

[Kingofholland]

Here are the top 15 QBs in QBR. Mahomes isn't there this year and has 6 games below 80 QBR in case anyone is wondering. Honest question how many of these guys would you take over Dak on this list? How have the last 5 games changed his ranking? He's definitely moved out of any consideration for top 5 after his hot start. However, the reality is all QBs have off games, but the elite generally have fewer and rarely go a longer stretch being off. The conclusion we can all make is Dak hasn't proven he's an elite QB, but remains a very good one. Still have him among the top 1/3 of NFL QBs, probably in that 2nd tier of guys.


1 Kyler Murray ARI(1 game below 80 QBR) 24 qb 9 9 8-1-0 197 271 72.7 2399 19 7.0 7 2.6 109 77 8.9 9.1 12.2 266.6 112.2 65.6 19 160 6.6 7.72 7.94 1 1
2 Matthew Stafford LAR(2 games below 80 QBR) 33 QB 12 12 8-4-0 292 438 66.7 3611 30 6.8 9 2.1 173 79 8.2 8.7 12.4 300.9 106.3 65.8 17 142 3.7 7.62 8.05 2 2
3 Aaron Rodgers GNB(2 games below 80 QBR) 38 QB 11 11 9-2-0 247 373 66.2 2878 23 6.2 4 1.1 140 75 7.7 8.5 11.7 261.6 105.5 65.3 21 141 5.3 6.95 7.66 1 2
4 Tom Brady TAM( 1 game below 80 QBR) 44 QB 12 12 9-3-0 347 508 68.3 3771 34 6.7 10 2.0 195 62 7.4 7.9 10.9 314.3 104.0 66.1 14 95 2.7 7.04 7.48 2 3
5 Kirk Cousins MIN(2 games below 80 QBR) 33 QB 13 13 6-7-0 319 477 66.9 3569 27 5.7 5 1.0 165 64 7.5 8.1 11.2 274.5 103.5 54.6 18 128 3.6 6.95 7.59 2 3
6 Russell Wilson SEA(1 game below 80 QBR) 33 qb 9 9 3-6-0 174 259 67.2 2042 14 5.4 4 1.5 85 69 7.9 8.3 11.7 226.9 102.5 44.5 26 211 9.1 6.42 6.78
7 Dak Prescott DAL(3 games below 80 QBR) 28 QB 11 11 7-4-0 287 416 69.0 3170 23 5.5 8 1.9 157 51 7.6 7.9 11.0 288.2 101.7 49.6 18 107 4.1 7.06 7.29 1 2
8 Jimmy Garoppolo SFO(2 games below 80 QBR) 30 QB 11 11 6-5-0 207 310 66.8 2641 15 4.8 8 2.6 118 83 8.5 8.3 12.8 240.1 98.6 56.3 19 118 5.8 7.67 7.49 1 1
9 Joe Burrow CIN(3 games below 80 QBR) 25 QB 12 12 7-5-0 259 379 68.3 3135 23 6.1 14 3.7 143 82 8.3 7.8 12.1 261.3 98.3 48.8 36 254 8.7 6.94 6.53 1 2
10 Justin Herbert LAC(3 games below 80 QBR) 23 QB 12 12 7-5-0 315 473 66.6 3547 27 5.7 11 2.3 176 72 7.5 7.6 11.3 295.6 98.2 67.4 25 174 5.0 6.77 6.86 5 5
11 Josh Allen BUF(5 games below 80 QBR) 25 QB 12 12 7-5-0 289 440 65.7 3216 26 5.9 10 2.3 164 61 7.3 7.5 11.1 268.0 97.5 57.4 19 132 4.1 6.72 6.87
12 Mac Jones NWE(2 games below 80 QBR) 23 QB 13 13 9-4-0 270 384 70.3 2869 16 4.2 8 2.1 134 75 7.5 7.4 10.6 220.7 97.0 51.3 24 204 5.9 6.53 6.43 1 1
13 Derek Carr LVR(5 games below 80 QBR) 30 QB 12 12 6-6-0 306 451 67.8 3663 17 3.8 9 2.0 156 61 8.1 8.0 12.0 305.3 96.7 55.0 27 167 5.6 7.31 7.18 1 3
14 Carson Wentz IND(3 games below 80 QBR) 29 QB 13 13 7-6-0 266 420 63.3 2948 22 5.2 5 1.2 137 76 7.0 7.5 11.1 226.8 96.6 58.5 22 160 5.0 6.31 6.79
15 Tua Tagovailoa MIA 23 qb 9 8 4-4-0 195 275 70.9

 

[ESisback]

I am just a fan... i never once said i would be a bette gm

Sorry, you just sounded supremely confident, and I just assumed you had a much better plan than the FO endorsed by all those silly, naive fanboys. I’m all about helping the team.

 

[Beaker42]

The Dak haters out in force
Looks like we won

LMAO. Yeah, we did - IN SPITE OF HIM. He sucks. Sorry, I take that back.

He REALLY TRULY SUCKS.

 

[Aulac]

Dak haters are never ending entertainment . Stafford , Carr , Lamar , have all had multiple terrible games this year . Yes Dak is top ten he’s in the 8-10 range . Putting him out of the top ten is just hate and its not based on wins or stats .

1. Brady
2. Rodgers
3. Mahomes
4. Wilson
5. Murray
6. Herbert
7. Jackson
8. Carr
9. Stafford
10. Dak
At worst he's tenth

Delusional.

 

[Beaker42]

Did any of you Dak haters watch the other team's QBs? Asking for a friend..

LMAO, you really gonna die on this hill after seeing his garbage outing today?

 

[Beaker42]

Another guy from Mississippi pissed about Dak’s contract lmao

LOL it’s not about the contract, Stanley. He’s playing like he’s trying to throw the games.

 

[plasticman]

Percentage of career starts in which the QB threw 2 or more INT's

Dak Prescott 15.0 %

Tom Brady 14.7%

Patrick Mahomes 12.1%

Kyler Murray 14.6%

Carson Wentz 18.5%

Justin Herbert 18.5%

Joe Burrow 14.2%

Derek Carr 17.2%

Kirk Cousin 16.2%

Matthew Stafford 20.3%

Tony Romo 19.7%

Dak's multiple INT games are not abnormally high among the majority of QB's considered good to elite. Aaron Rodgers abnormally low at around 8%.

 

[Beaker42]

During that same time he had his calf injury, his grandmother died. Maybe his grandmother's death is affecting him more than he thinks.

He seems completely in his head and distracted.

At this point he’s stealing JJ’s $$.

 

[BourbonBalz]

Dak is definitely in a funk. I have no idea if it’s due to the calf injury or if it’s mental. He was bad today, but we’ve seen how great he can play. Hell, we’ve seen it several times this year. He’ll bounce back at some point. I hope it’s this season. Let’s face it, the Oline and the receivers haven’t done him any favors. Dak has been off without a doubt, but so has the line and receivers.