What has Garrett accomplished in your estimation? And why would you support him in the future?
I don't think Garrett is ALWAYS as ****** as we make him out to be. Let's go back to last year. He lost his starting QB (Romo) for the year. He never plays one active down for us during the regular season.
We take a "project QB" that none of the fans expected anything out of last year. Not even the most optimistic pan could have reasonably expected we would get that level of QB play out of him. We win 13 games and should have won 14 but one of them really didn't matter because the playoff seed was locked up. We win that many games with no ******* defense whatsoever.
Garrett inherited a team in cap hell, old players, disgruntled players and no real talent to speak of other than a couple of vets like Romo, Witten and Dez. We had zero OL.
Garrett has accomplished getting Jerry to exercise some degree of patience, build through the draft, and jettisoned old piss poor contract players. We have stopped trying to overpay for players in free agency. All of that is good stuff.
If The Hoodie had done the same thing here it would be viewed very differently. The Hoodie would have been viewed as a magician for the season we had last year with a rookie QB. The legend would be growing exponentially.
The problems are also there. We seem to be sentimental with players like Witten and Dez who have bloated under performing contracts. We seem to be letting Witten decide how much he wants to play which is every down.
More bad? Garrett doesn't over ride bad play calling at inopportune times by Linehan. It's critical failures like that that keep Garrett from getting to the next level of coaching.
And the defense? I can get behind blowing up the defense and save the cap hit if that's what they wanted to do. What I can't get behind is the defenses failure to be aggressive and take a few chances instead of giving up small chunks all day against good teams.
Marinelli needs to go. He is only here because he developed a reputation based on hall of fame players he had under him. I don't think he is aggressive enough and he hangs on to players with zero talent (Hayden) because they have a high motor. Hell I will get out there and try hard all day if they will pay me millions to do it, but that won't get is very far.