DMN: BLOG: What would you give up for (Det) Roy Williams?

[Cbz40]

I thank you old wise one. Or shall I say Grand Poobah?

Pops would be sufficient...or You old Fart......Heck, I don't care...

 

[zrinkill]

I would give #28 for Williams ..... I would give #22 for Fitz

 

[slick325]

Pops would be sufficient...or You old Fart......Heck, I don't care...

LOL! I gothca Pops.

 

[Billy Bullocks]

Williams, besides missing some games, has showed that he is more than capable of being a WR at this level.

I dunno what the situation with Terry Glenn is, but we need to get someone better than Crayton in their as the #2.

WRs take longer to acclimate to the NFL, so it makes sense to get a WR who is already up to speed instead of breaking in a rookie.

If this team really is only a few more pieces away, aka another WR, and a CB, I would trade the #29 real quick.

 

[MichaelWinicki]

I don't think any team in the league would give a #1 for him, but I could be wrong. He hasn't done much special in the league so far due to injuries.

I certainly wouldn't give up a #1 when he's a home boy and would probably sign with us in FA in another year anyway. He's not as good as Calvin Johnson, so that makes him a #2 in Detroit...at best. You can talk all you want about his talent, but I think he can be had for much less than a #1 pick.

He's had 4 NFL seasons and only 1 complete season, playing only 12 games this year...only 1 1000 yard season. He's a guy I'd love to have in Dallas, but I'd be hesitant to give up a #1 pick for a guy with his NFL history so far.

Damn Wayne.

You laid some "fact" down on some folks.

 

[Sarge]

I don't think any team in the league would give a #1 for him, but I could be wrong. He hasn't done much special in the league so far due to injuries.

I certainly wouldn't give up a #1 when he's a home boy and would probably sign with us in FA in another year anyway. He's not as good as Calvin Johnson, so that makes him a #2 in Detroit...at best. You can talk all you want about his talent, but I think he can be had for much less than a #1 pick.

He's had 4 NFL seasons and only 1 complete season, playing only 12 games this year...only 1 1000 yard season. He's a guy I'd love to have in Dallas, but I'd be hesitant to give up a #1 pick for a guy with his NFL history so far.

Bingo - nice post Wayno. Why one would gamble on grabbing the guy for our #28 and second rounder is questionable to say the least......

 

[CrazyCowboy]

Give a 1st rd for Fitz......

 

[zack]

Give a 1st rd for Fitz......

Give them a 3rd pick. Roy Williams doesn't have any break away speed. He is another TE in my opinion. And he is just a weird guy altogether.

 

[theogt]

Bingo - nice post Wayno. Why one would gamble on grabbing the guy for our #28 and second rounder is questionable to say the least......

Right, because we just know that players at those draft positions can come in and put up the production that he can. That would be the "safe" decision.

Please, it's insanely stupid to not at least give up a #28 for him.

Give them a 3rd pick. Roy Williams doesn't have any break away speed. He is another TE in my opinion. And he is just a weird guy altogether.

Oh, sorry, this is a thread about the receiver. Not the safety.

 

[Sarge]

Right, because we just know that players at those draft positions can come in and put up the production that he can. That would be the "safe" decision.

Please, it's insanely stupid to not at least give up a #28 for him.

Giving up a #28 for him is COMPLETELY different than giving up a #28 and a second rounder for him......at least I thought it was.............

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Giving up a #28 for him is COMPLETELY different than giving up a #28 and a second rounder for him......at least I thought it was.............

Sarge, you have to consider that Theogt has become discombobulated due to that severe body shot that Wayne gave him...

It's going to take time for him to think rationally again.

 

[Sarge]

Sarge, you have to consider that Theogt has become discombobulated due that severe body shot that Wayne gave him...

It's going to take time for him to think rationally again.

.........I see that..............:laugh2:

 

[theogt]

Sarge, you have to consider that Theogt has become discombobulated due that severe body shot that Wayne gave him...

It's going to take time for him to think rationally again.

Let me summarize his post because it's apparent that you couldn't read it thoroughly:

"He's missed a few games and has only had one 1000 yard season."

Shocking. I had no idea. It's already been pointed out that Michael Irvin missed more games in his first 4 seasons than Roy.

 

[Bob Sacamano]

Right, because we just know that players at those draft positions can come in and put up the production that he can. That would be the "safe" decision.

Please, it's insanely stupid to not at least give up a #28 for him.

Oh, sorry, this is a thread about the receiver. Not the safety.

the at least scenario should be a 2nd round pick

I'd give up a 1st round pick, if it's a 2nd too, they'd have to throw a good special team's guy into the mix

 

[MichaelWinicki]

Let me summarize his post because it's apparent that you couldn't read it thoroughly:

"He's missed a few games and has only had one 1000 yard season."

Shocking. I had no idea. It's already been pointed out that Michael Irvin missed more games in his first 4 seasons than Roy.

You're cute when you're angry.

 

[Cbz40]

Well my way of thinking is this....we are a team that is real close to being in the big dance and winning it. ^he last time we were tis close JJ & JJ went out and bought Haley which put us over the top.

Now lay all the smack down on me you want..I give a rats..behind, at this point in time you need a player or that will come in and be an impact... NOW!!!! not sit on the bench and run wind sprints, watch film, draw plays on a chalk board for two years.

Hell whether he's worth a top five or a 28th pick plus a second round draft choice as far as I am concerned is moot. Give Tony another weapon.

Plus let's draft a psychiatrist to tell us what the hell is wrong w/this team in December and the playoffs.

 

[Sarge]

the at least scenario should be a 2nd round pick

I'd give up a 1st round pick, if it's a 2nd too, they'd have to throw a good special team's guy into the mix

The question is whether you'd throw #28 and our second for him......?

 

[theogt]

Over their first 4 seasons...

Michael Irvin (Games - Yards)
14 - 654
6 - 378
12 - 413
16 - 1523

Total Games - 48
Total Yards - 2968
Yards Per Game - 61.83

Roy Williams (Games - Yards)
12 - 817
16 - 687
13 - 1310
14 - 838

Total Games - 55
Total Yards - 3652
Yards Per Game - 66.4

 

[Sarge]

Give me Laveranues Coles instead. Much cheaper.

L. Coles for a 1st or second rounder??????????

 

[Bob Sacamano]

The question is whether you'd throw #28 and our second for him......?

it's 29 btw

and I would only do the 1st round pick, I definitely wouldn't start the bidding at a 1st round pick though