Eberflus defensive scheme(s)

bigdnlaca

Well-Known Member
Messages
2,827
Reaction score
1,388
I read that as a play caller, his defenses statistically were good.

However, I see his scheme as too much like Marinelli where he rarely blitzes and the run defense is suspect against teams that really want to run (struggled against the Titans rushing when he was the Colts DC).
 

TheMarathonContinues

Well-Known Member
Messages
85,471
Reaction score
77,729
Some yes, but they need a run game to help hide the defense. This DL losing its 2 best interior players is going to hurt.
Ok who else because I know Osa is probably gone but who’s the the other because I can’t even think of two good interior players lol. I’m perfectly fine revamping the interior.
It’s not Safe
It’s ‘cheap’ and ‘comfortable’
perfectly said.
 

NDGAEDE

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
2,605
Not joking. A ball controlled offense to try to keep their defense fresh.
Soon we'll hear that we want to be better 'in all three phases' and that we simply need to 'stack good days together' and that we're looking for the 'right kind of guy'.

I don't know what it is about the Garrett years that Jerry (Stephen more likely) wants to return to, but we keep finding coaches to fit into the mould: No balls, no power, no fun
 

Cowboyny

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,704
Reaction score
20,655
Soon we'll hear that we want to be better 'in all three phases' and that we simply need to 'stack good days together' and that we're looking for the 'right kind of guy'.

I don't know what it is about the Garrett years that Jerry (Stephen more likely) wants to return to, but we keep finding coaches to fit into the mould: No balls, no power, no fun
You would think the opposite in that we are the Dallas Cowboys, but they want a vanilla, basic system on both sides of the football.
 

NDGAEDE

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
2,605
You would think the opposite in that we are the Dallas Cowboys, but they want a vanilla, basic system on both sides of the football.
This is the ideal version of the Stephen Jones's Dallas Cowboys. No heart, no soul, no passion, no fun. It's almost the antithesis to what the Cowboys were in the 90s when things were great. Everything now is as basic and vanilla and generic as can be. Seriously, I think this is the identity Stephen wants. Almost like he wants to spite his father for the past. It feels like we're destined to repeat the 'Greg Ellis over Randy Moss' type of decision for eternity.

The entire NFL--not to mention college football and likely youth football--are going in an entirely different direction and we're stuck in the past, running an antiquated offense and defense because the front office doesn't have the balls to try to be special.
 

Cowboyny

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,704
Reaction score
20,655
This is the ideal version of the Stephen Jones's Dallas Cowboys. No heart, no soul, no passion, no fun. It's almost the antithesis to what the Cowboys were in the 90s when things were great. Everything now is as basic and vanilla and generic as can be. Seriously, I think this is the identity Stephen wants. Almost like he wants to spite his father for the past. It feels like we're destined to repeat the 'Greg Ellis over Randy Moss' type of decision for eternity.

The entire NFL--not to mention college football and likely youth football--are going in an entirely different direction and we're stuck in the past, running an antiquated offense and defense because the front office doesn't have the balls to try to be special.
That's it in a nut shell, afraid of taking any kind of risk.
 

NDGAEDE

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,717
Reaction score
2,605
That's it in a nut shell, afraid of taking any kind of risk.
And that fear manifests in every decision we make, from free agency to the draft to the gameplans to the players.

Do not be special. Do not try. We like to be around the rim. That's good enough.
 

Cowboyny

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,704
Reaction score
20,655
And that fear manifests in every decision we make, from free agency to the draft to the gameplans to the players.

Do not be special. Do not try. We like to be around the rim. That's good enough.
All we need to look at is Dak's contract, so fearful of losing him that they caved and gave him the highest possible contract.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
34,210
Reaction score
38,934
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
I thought Eberflus who a good coach when he was here, but absolutely hate the scheme. We have been trying to be successful with this scheme for years and have gotten similar results. Change was needed. Now we are going to see Stephen devalue the 1T again and not prioritize stopping the run.
We had a bad DC. One that had only been a playcaller one year before coming here. Alot of coaches have had success with that scheme. Matt had very good run defenses in Indianapolis. Allowed only 3.6 yards a carry one year
 

Hawkeye0202

Well-Known Member
Messages
27,328
Reaction score
49,148
We had a bad DC. One that had only been a playcaller one year before coming here. Alot of coaches have had success with that scheme. Matt had very good run defenses in Indianapolis. Allowed only 3.6 yards a carry one year
This is what I don't understand many are referencing the failure of the Bear's defense while he was HC but overlooking he was a good DC ( his job here ) with the Colts. I understand some don't trust the scheme ( Marinelli attached) but if he can get the right players he may have a chance.
 

darthseinfeld

Groupthink Guru
Messages
34,210
Reaction score
38,934
CowboysZone LOYAL Fan
This is what I don't understand many are referencing the failure of the Bear's defense while he was HC but overlooking he was a good DC ( his job here ) with the Colts. I understand some don't trust the scheme ( Marinelli attached) but if he can get the right players he may have a chance.
Similar circumstances lead Quinn here.
 

stilltheguru

Well-Known Member
Messages
16,009
Reaction score
14,888
In what world is he a better DC than Quinn or Zimmer? His defense will be better if the players improve. If the front 4 is still subpar up the middle the December games and playoff games will look like they have since 2021. Fix that first and then focus on stopping the run (linebackers/safeties)
 

Chuck 54

Well-Known Member
Messages
20,720
Reaction score
12,729
I don’t see an improvement here vs the run. He wants the Marinelli type DTs that can penetrate up field and rush the passer.

All his front 7 players are below average in size, strength, and weight.

I fail to see how this helps us stop the run. It is like we are going back to the concepts under Rod and hoping somehow they will work this time.

IMO— this kind of D will get absolutely mauled by the better teams in the league who are built with great OLs. The “small athletic” DLs highlighted in this article will just get blasted off the ball.

More of the same I am afraid. The more things “change” the more they stay the same.
You can stop the run in many different ways. We have seldom had 1 really impressive 3-tech. Aaron Donald was great vs the run. The trick is not to rush the passer every down and run yourself out of position. If you have 2 good penetrating DTs, they shoot gaps but hold position or find the ball. LBs can operated behind a 1 tech or multiple 3 techs, but the DTs must be good, and the LBs must be good. Think Lilly, Pugh, and Cole or White and Dutton, or Maryland, Jones, Casillas. All 3 iterations of great DT combos in Dallas history were smaller, get up the field 3 tech types. We never emphasized 1 tech types until Parcells came in and switched us to the 3-4. Good defensive tackles come in all shapes and sizes, but you need 2 of them with good LB play to stop a good run game.
 
Top