Eli Manning ...not ready for prime time!

[eduncan22]

This guy is clearly over--rated!

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

This was the easiest game to call. Manning has become very INT-prone.

Because of this fact he has recently applied for official name change...

Being a Dallas Cowboy fan living in NY. I could not be any happier. Dont have to listen to "atleast we made it" THEY actually didnt make it today... LMAO

Go Cowboys 2006!

 

[Clove]

He and the Giants get everything they deserve for choosing where he wanted to go... Now if his brother and just lose in the playoffs, that will be a nice curse for the entire family...

 

[Fletch]

This guy is clearly over--rated!

He is still learning. But definitely having a bad day.

Bottom line, this just goes to show that the Giants are definitely an overrated team. And were from the get-go.

 

[Clove]

To me, Eli is just as classless as TO but without the talent of TO. They both whinned to get to go where they wanted....

 

[Qwickdraw]

TOLD YOU!

Giants = overrated

Eli = even more overrated

But don't tell HeavyHitta that. Then he'll have to retun his lifesize Eli blowup doll.

 

[The30YardSlant]

I seem to remember another Manning who sucked it up in his first playoff game...he turned out alright

 

[Sarge]

This guy is clearly over--rated!

It's invaluable experience for him and a time for growth for Manning and the Giants.

I am envious that they are grooming a young QB right now and giving him the experience, both throughout the year and these playoffs that he and the Giants need while we sit here with question marks at the QB spot and knowing full well, either way, Bledsoe is done in 2 years.

 

[eduncan22]

It's invaluable experience for him and a time for growth for Manning and the Giants.

I am envious that they are grooming a young QB right now and giving him the experience, both throughout the year and these playoffs that he and the Giants need while we sit here with question marks at the QB spot and knowing full well, either way, Bledsoe is done in 2 years.

Man..from what I saw this year [and I watched every game], Bledsoe played well. I can see that we need a backup QB, but Bledsoe is only 33.

 

[Da Hammer]

I put this on the Giants vs Panthers thread

so much for Eli being their Franchise QB. I know he's young but he has a long way to go and if it weren't for his last name being Manning, no one would be even talking about him. Barber is the reason they are there, not Manning

 

[Sarge]

Man..from what I saw this year [and I watched every game], Bledsoe played well. I can see that we need a backup QB, but Bledsoe is only 33.

Bledsoe will NEVER win a SB, period.

The guy is a statue and regardless of what we do on OL, it is simple to game plan against him because of his lack of ANY mobility whatsoever.

I'm glad you watched every game, so did I, most of them more than once.

I've seen all I need to of Bledsoe.

 

[LittleBoyBlue]

It's invaluable experience for him and a time for growth for Manning and the Giants.

I am envious that they are grooming a young QB right now and giving him the experience, both throughout the year and these playoffs that he and the Giants need while we sit here with question marks at the QB spot and knowing full well, either way, Bledsoe is done in 2 years.

I agree completely!

People getting away with the Over-rated on Manning... while I do see him as being INT-proned right now... you cant judge his career and say he is over-rated. He went to playoffs in his second season(he didnt even play whole first season)

 

[burmafrd]

Bledsoe got to the SB once on his own, and won a AFC Champ game to get to another with the Pats. SO he can get you there. Once you get there the win is possible. The haters just don't want to admit it.

 

[RCowboyFan]

Bledsoe will NEVER win a SB, period.

The guy is a statue and regardless of what we do on OL, it is simple to game plan against him because of his lack of ANY mobility whatsoever.

I'm glad you watched every game, so did I, most of them more than once.

I've seen all I need to of Bledsoe.

But.. But.. all Bledsoe needs is a great OL...

 

[burmafrd]

Manning would be on the bench by now if not for his name. Simple as that. He is getting a LOT of room because of that. If his name was Smith it would be a whole different story. the guy is NOT accurate and that will be his downfall.

 

[Juke99]

I dunno...but I just can't see this kid ever making it...His accuracy is awful...and I don't know how much that can be improved....

Take away Tiki Barber and force him to throw.

 

[JakeCamp12]

Sarge,

You are right...we should be grooming someone to take the helm for the next 10 year. Bledsoe is just a band-aid.

 

[yesfan]

This was the easiest game to call. Manning has become very INT-prone.

Because of this fact he has recently applied for official name change...

Being a Dallas Cowboy fan living in NY. I could not be any happier. Dont have to listen to "atleast we made it" THEY actually didnt make it today... LMAO

Go Cowboys 2006!

You really want to revel in their demise,tune in tomorrow
for Mike and the Mad Dog.They're on the Yes network,622
on direct tv, 1-6 pm.

 

[Wolverine]

This guy is clearly over--rated!

It will suck to say this but that is one thing that will no longer be said after next year. He is a crybaby and had to cry to get to play for the team he wanted but he is gonna be great QB.

At least the Giants have their franchise QB of the future in him. Sure wish we had one for our future.

 

[cml750]

It's invaluable experience for him and a time for growth for Manning and the Giants.

I am envious that they are grooming a young QB right now and giving him the experience, both throughout the year and these playoffs that he and the Giants need while we sit here with question marks at the QB spot and knowing full well, either way, Bledsoe is done in 2 years.

Post of the day!!! :clap2: