forget every thread you ever read about these two...Roy v Ed Reed

[Rack]

Career stats:

Ed Reed:
Sacks: 4
FF: 5
FR: 3
INT: 27
TD's: 4

Roy Williams:
Sacks: 6.5
FF: 9
FR: 7
INT: 17
TD's: 3

That also seems pretty close to me.

 

[DragonCowboy]

That also seems pretty close to me.

If you look at it, RW does more of what a strong safety does - sack the QB, force fumbles, etc.

If you look at ER, he does more of what a free safety does - intercept the ball.

But nah, they both have the same position and Reed is so much better.

 

[AdamJT13]

Donte whitner
Donavin darius
Rodney Harrison
Troy polamolu
Adrian Wilson
Mike brown
Micheal lewis
Michael boulware
Dawan landry
sean jones
chris hope

id pretty much go wtih these guys over roy on passing downs ss wise. sure was hard to think of them... off the top of my head.

You're just throwing out any name you can think of, right? Two of those guys were so bad they got BENCHED this season, four of them had one interception or less, several others got abused in coverage, and a couple of them got hurt and did nothing all year.

Other than that, great list of 11 random strong safeties!

 

[locked&loaded]

If you look at it, RW does more of what a strong safety does - sack the QB, force fumbles, etc.

If you look at ER, he does more of what a free safety does - intercept the ball.

But nah, they both have the same position and Reed is so much better.

alright since the hmm about 4 of you have your mind made up. im glad your not scared when the balls in air and roys in coverage, cuase i am, im glad you dont have to experience the way i almost close my eyes when i see roy steps behind someone. its sickening. i wish i could be oblivious to it but i cant.

 

[zrinkill]

You have been proven wrong again and again.

 

[BigDFan5]

You have been proven wrong again and again.

and again.....

 

[locked&loaded]

You have been proven wrong again and again.

mhmm youve converted me now. i dont know how i could of been so blind. teams dont even throw towards roy, they dont pick on him. hes lockdown, hes got the tightest coverage i have ever seen. greatest safety ever. but if he was on a different team he woudl be way overated.

 

[zrinkill]

mhmm youve converted me now. i dont know how i could of been so blind. teams dont even throw towards roy, they dont pick on him. hes lockdown, hes got the tightest coverage i have ever seen. greatest safety ever. but if he was on a different team he woudl be way overated.

Homer

 

[locked&loaded]

Homer

that was the message in it. you only defend him cause hes a cowboy.

 

[zrinkill]

that was the message in it. you only defend him cause hes a cowboy.

Nope ..... I can see that there is not a better strong safety in coverage than him in the league.

Your hatred for him keeps you from seeing that. sorry.

 

[locked&loaded]

Nope ..... I can see that there is not a better strong safety in coverage than him in the league.

Your hatred for him keeps you from seeing that. sorry.

i have a roy jersey. i have roy memorabilia. i do not hate roy. i never said roy sucked. i started this thread saying reed is the better safety and i truly believe that. you turned it into you guys and roy against the world thread.

 

[smarta5150]

Who here wanted Hamlin?

He gave up the catch that lead to the game winning FG... way to go!

 

[zrinkill]

i have a roy jersey. i have roy memorabilia. i do not hate roy. i never said roy sucked. i started this thread saying reed is the better safety and i truly believe that. you turned it into you guys and roy against the world thread.

And I said that Ed Reid is a better Free Safety ,.....

But Roy does not play that position .... yet you argue that they are the same ....



Keep the Hate.

 

[SDogo]

Who here wanted Hamlin?

He gave up the catch that lead to the game winning FG... way to go!

He is a FS!

He would also be deadly next to Roy.

 

[locked&loaded]

And I said that Ed Reid is a better Free Safety ,.....

But Roy does not play that position .... yet you argue that they are the same ....



Keep the Hate.

ok. free safeties and strong safeties are completely differnet. no hate.

 

[BigDFan5]

mhmm youve converted me now. i dont know how i could of been so blind. teams dont even throw towards roy, they dont pick on him. hes lockdown, hes got the tightest coverage i have ever seen. greatest safety ever. but if he was on a different team he woudl be way overated.

yeah because thats what we were all saying

 

[zrinkill]

ok. free safeties and strong safeties are completely differnet. no hate.

Just like Tail backs and Full backs

and Wideouts and Tightends

and tackles and guards

and kickers and punters

 

[BigDFan5]

Who here wanted Hamlin?

He gave up the catch that lead to the game winning FG... way to go!

I wanted Hamlin, still do. Unless We could be guaranteed Landry in the draft. Then I want him

 

[locked&loaded]

Just like Tail backs and Full backs

and Wideouts and Tightends

and tackles and guards

and kickers and punters

safeties are more alike than any of those. see they try to make it easy for you. by having safety in both of them, but some still dont get it. guards and tackles diffreent words, recievers and tightends different words punters and kickers different.

 

[SDogo]

safeties are more alike than any of those. see they try to make it easy for you. by having safety in both of them, but some still dont get it. guards and tackles diffreent words, recievers and tightends different words punters and kickers different.

Tackles and Guards actually but a close second.