forget every thread you ever read about these two...Roy v Ed Reed

[BigDFan5]

He was for Pittsburgh did Tennessee change his position?

nfl.com has himlisted as a ss i guess tenn moved him

 

[zrinkill]

So the best they can do is find 2 guys who they could argue about being better .....

Yet Roy sucks in coverage? Only 2 guys in the whole NFL is even arguable .....

 

[SDogo]

So even if all those 2 guys you named are better (which is very very debatable)

Roy Williams is the best Strong Safety in the NFC?

Listen, I own 3 Roy Williams jerseys. I bleed from the finger tips defending the guy last year. Deep down I try to tell myself he is being used wrong, he is trying to make up for the lack of talent at FS, he is trying to do to much. I can live with the coverage down falls in moderation. I hung my hat on his play making ability and disruptive nature in the run game but this year he failed in all aspects.

I'm hoping he turns it around, I hope Dallas figures out whats wrong but right now I'm severly aggrivated with him and this season. He was just as much a disapointment and the rest of the team.

 

[locked&loaded]

Yeah, it was a good move on their part.

Donte whitner
Donavin darius
Rodney Harrison
Troy polamolu
Adrian Wilson
Mike brown
Micheal lewis
Michael boulware
Dawan landry
sean jones
chris hope

id pretty much go wtih these guys over roy on passing downs ss wise. sure was hard to think of them... off the top of my head.

 

[BigDFan5]

Sean Jones gave up less yards
Chris Hope gave up less yards

Sean Jones gave up less TD's
Chris Hope gave up less TD's

HOL Still wondering if you can give us a link to these stats, I would like to bookmark it

 

[zrinkill]

Listen, I own 3 Roy Williams jerseys. I bleed from the finger tips defending the guy last year. Deep down I try to tell myself he is being used wrong, he is trying to make up for the lack of talent at FS, he is trying to do to much. I can live with the coverage down falls in moderation. I hung my hat on his play making ability and disruptive nature in the run game but this year he failed in all aspects.

I'm hoping he turns it around, I hope Dallas figures out whats wrong but right now I'm severly aggrivated with him and this season. He was just as much a disapointment and the rest of the team.

I understand that man ..... but for guys to say he sucks at coverage is just stupid .....

You saw how hard it was to find better Strong Safties in coverage than him ..... and those could be argued.

The whole team under performed .....

 

[BigDFan5]

Donte whitner
Donavin darius
Rodney Harrison
Troy polamolu
Adrian Wilson
Mike brown
Micheal lewis
Michael boulware
Dawan landry
sean jones
chris hope

id pretty much go wtih these guys over roy on passing downs ss wise. sure was hard to think of them... off the top of my head.

lmao thats hilarious

First "off the top of your head" you mean you took the time to change fonts for different names? no you copy and pasted from websites you looked up a bunch of names on

Second wow on the list we have injured guys, guys that got benched, a guy you never heard of until todays game LOL

 

[zrinkill]

sure was hard to think of them... off the top of my head.

Thats why you waited till over 300 replys to post huh?

you googled all of them

 

[BigDFan5]

Listen, I own 3 Roy Williams jerseys. I bleed from the finger tips defending the guy last year. Deep down I try to tell myself he is being used wrong, he is trying to make up for the lack of talent at FS, he is trying to do to much. I can live with the coverage down falls in moderation. I hung my hat on his play making ability and disruptive nature in the run game but this year he failed in all aspects.

I'm hoping he turns it around, I hope Dallas figures out whats wrong but right now I'm severly aggrivated with him and this season. He was just as much a disapointment and the rest of the team.

thats a hell of aot better post than "he sucks blah blah" and "your a homer if you dont think he sucks"

 

[zrinkill]

lmao thats hilarious

First "off the top of your head" you mean you took the time to change fonts for different names? no you copy and pasted from websites you looked up a bunch of names on

Second wow on the list we have injured guys, guys that got benched, a guy you never heard of until todays game LOL

Busted ..... my god this is funny.

 

[locked&loaded]

lmao thats hilarious

First "off the top of your head" you mean you took the time to change fonts for different names? no you copy and pasted from websites you looked up a bunch of names on

Second wow on the list we have injured guys, guys that got benched, a guy you never heard of until todays game LOL

i went o nfll.com and copy and pasted there names so i woudlnt have to type it all. its called ashort cut. when healthy these guys are all better than roy in coverage. LOL.

 

[locked&loaded]

Thats why you waited till over 300 replys to post huh?

you googled all of them

i brought this up for coverage between roy and reed saying its nice to have ball hawking safety. some how this turned into a roy is the most amazing cover safety warzone. in the last couple posts you gusy were harrasing a guy about ss that were better thats when i posted these guys names.

 

[Rampage]

you guys trashing roy are funny

 

[ddh33]

Donte whitner
Donavin darius
Rodney Harrison
Troy polamolu
Adrian Wilson
Mike brown
Micheal lewis
Michael boulware
Dawan landry
sean jones
chris hope

id pretty much go wtih these guys over roy on passing downs ss wise. sure was hard to think of them... off the top of my head.

Harrison, Darius, Mike Brown, and Palomalu all have had injuries plaguing them lately. Say what you will, but Roy shows up every week.

Adrian Wilson is an underrated player who coaches try to keep out of coverage. Ask around, he's Roy Williams with less covergae ability.

Mike Lewis and Mike Bouleware both got benched this season.

Chris Hope was considered so vital that he recently changed teams. By the way, a lot of fans missed him after he did.

Sean Jones was so highly thought of the Browns drafted Brodney Pool out of Oklahoma to take his spot. Sean Jones got it, and that never happened, but it goes to show you.

Also, many of those guys plays on a team that has a much better pass rush than Dallas. Most of them also play beside better safteies, thus allowing them to be a little more secure in their responsibility.


I know all a lot of people are interested in is tearing down Roy, but it's simply not fair. He's not nearly the problem that he's made out to be. Obviously, he isn't perfect, and he has been beaten at times, but those times have been greatly exaggerated. I'd be a lot more worried about how to better utilize him than I would be in getting rid of him.

 

[zrinkill]

i brought this up for coverage between roy and reed saying its nice to have ball hawking safety. some how this turned into a roy is the most amazing cover safety warzone. in the last couple posts you gusy were harrasing a guy about ss that were better thats when i posted these guys names.

No one defending him ever said he was amazing in coverage .... but you guys all said he sucked at it ....

None of those guys are better than Roy at Strong Safety ..... you just did the compare stat thing at NFL.com ...

You got busted ..... live with it.

 

[BigDFan5]

i went o nfll.com and copy and pasted there names so i woudlnt have to type it all. its called ashort cut. when healthy these guys are all better than roy in coverage. LOL.

sure you thought up all the names and then just didnt have the energy to type them :laugh2:

 

[zrinkill]

sure you thought up all the names and then just didnt have the energy to type them :laugh2:

Right off the top of his head ......

 

[locked&loaded]

Busted ..... my god this is funny.

since about 4 of you think roy is the best coverage strong safety someone should make a poll. i woudl make one but ive never made a pole and dont know how to make one.

just make it say -best SS in coverage-

-roy
-other

or like- where would you rate roy coverage wise-

-1
-top 5
-top 10
-top 20
-bottom 5

 

[SDogo]

thats a hell of aot better post than "he sucks blah blah" and "your a homer if you dont think he sucks"

Catch me again when the pain of this season wears off, I have time to breath and collect my thoughts and I don;t have to watch playoff football with out the Cowboys and you will get more like this. Right now the Cowboys clipped my fuse a little short.

 

[locked&loaded]

Right off the top of his head ......

since you seem to have telepathy down you shoudl know. i was adding up fantasy scores for the leauge im in and while i was on the site i copied and pasted the names of safeties. i thought of the teams tehy were on, clicked into them copied them, opened up a new post in this thread and one by one put them into it.