I’m not sure we’ve ever had cut throat critics or trolls as color commentators. Perhaps you’d like Stephen A working in the booth. LolAikman only calls out easy targets.
He picks on the players who others have targeted by other people in the media or lesser known players, but he softens his criticism when it comes to star players to things like, "not sure what he was thinking" and "he normally makes better throws than that".
No, nor do I want them to just be negative in the booth.I’m not sure we’ve ever had cut throat critics or trolls as color commentators. Perhaps you’d like Stephen A working in the booth. Lol
On a more serious note I don’t really think it’s a color commentators job to be overly critical of players. Can they critique a play or performance . Sure.
But to generate or promote a negative narrative like we all too often see in all facets of the media I don’t see happening on network TV with the NFL during a broadcast.
I think this is crazy. You don't even know how good he'll be. I have my doubts he'll be good.
yeah this guy is golden, everything just falls into place for him lol.Wow that changes everything. Brady will make more money as a game analyst then he would playing football. Will players actually try to hit Brady this season…….,,
if you read the other posts, you would know this is a deal for when he does retire, not now lol.Okay once again I'm confused. So first he retires, then he says he's unretiring, so now I guess he's retiring again?
I'm sorry but this guy is autistic. I've known that for a while. Socially awkward. Extremely gifted at one thing. He's autistic. Bottom line.
Playing NFL football at a high level and broadcasting it are two different things. Both require a skill. Joe Montana gave it a try in the studio after his NFL career and he wasn’t any good. I remember Roger Staubach broadcasting a few games and his delivery was too slow. He didn’t last long.
Aikman only calls out easy targets.
He picks on the players who others have targeted by other people in the media or lesser known players, but he softens his criticism when it comes to star players to things like, "not sure what he was thinking" and "he normally makes better throws than that".
I added what I was looking for in another post. I am not looking for a mean person, just someone who will be more honest.Well I'm not quite sure what you'd want to see from a high profile position like that. And who currently does what you're looking for besides a media pee-on looking to make a name for him/herself (I'm not talking about SiteHype, lol)? As you mentioned before about broadcasters being concerned about coaches and players getting upset about criticism, their jobs are also to get access to players. So if you criticize harshly, you do risk not getting access to get that insight you hear Aikman and Buck talking about when they interviewed players during the week and they usually want access to the stars. So they do have to walk a fine line and answer to their network who wants that access to show/tell viewers.
And if it's stars you're dealing with, you do cut them more slack because if they're stars, they've balled out more than not versus a wannabe without a reputation yet so I get the softer criticism due to track record. But it's probably more the fine line I mentioned in the paragraph above.
I have nothing against Tom Brady, but he does have a peculiar voice. Not sure how this will work out.
I added what I was looking for in another post. I am not looking for a mean person, just someone who will be more honest.
I can't wait to hear Tom say...."Well...that's not how we cheated...but if it works...it works."Good for Tom. Fox knows enough to be happy with this deal so good for the goat.