FOX Sports: Top 10 QBs of all-time

[Future]

Statistically, Tony Romo should be number 2

 

[casmith07]

No Troy Aikman? Lol.

No Bart Starr? LoL.

 

[Big Dakota]

It's jason whitlock for Gods sake.

 

[Rustinpeace21]

Thats just the most obvious arguement.

Aikman is the better QB over Brady

honestly id take pre knee injury Tom Brady over Aikman..who was he winning super bowls with? David Patten and Antwain Smith...not emmit and irvin

 

[casmith07]

honestly id take pre knee injury Tom Brady over Aikman..who was he winning super bowls with? David Patten and Antwain Smith...not emmit and irvin

 

[dadymat]

very bias arguement right there...saying aikman won three super bowls and and didnt lose any is stupid. After Bradys 3 super bowl win should he have stopped trying? Im sure anyone here would take 4 super bowl appearances with 75% winning percentage with any qb

And hes still got a good 4 years left in him

you are dealing with a guy who thinks Irvin was better than Rice........

 

[jobberone]

What makes Young more talented? Staubach had a slightly stronger arm than Young and ran the ball just as well as Young. Steve also played in a more QB friendly era than Roger did.

We'll just have to agree to disagree. First I'm a huge Staubach fan. But I think Young was a better runner who was faster, stronger and shiftier. I also think he had better accuracy and a stronger arm. Not that Roger couldn't make all the passes an NFL QB should.

But Young did not have whatever intangibles Roger had. Roger just refused to lose and was the most remarkable QB I've ever seen in comebacks. He just found a way. I'd put both in the top ten best QBs ever and I'd rank Staubach over Young.

 

[ThreeSportStar80]

I would take Troy Aikman over Steve Young...

 

[pgreptom]

How would Montana do when defenders could cover receivers? Are you joking?

This league is different - cornerbacks can't even touch wide receivers - by rule - it's a 5 yard penalty and a 1st down.

 

[windward]

My entirely subjective list.

1. Joe Montana
2. John Elway
3. Roger Staubach
4. Johnny Unitas
5. Peyton Manning
6. Troy Aikman
7. Brett Favre
8. Tom Brady
9. Dan Marino
10. Steve Young

 

[Rustinpeace21]

neither patten or smith were on the spygate team

 

[dadymat]

My 2 cents

1)Montana
2)Elway
3)P Manning
4)Staubach
5)Brady
6)Marino
7)Johnny U
8)Bart Starr
9)Tarkenton
10)Aikman

 

[Screw The Hall]

I don't think it's that bad of a list but to me Marino is almost as overrated a QB as Barry Sanders is a RB.

 

[speedkilz88]

I don't think it's that bad of a list but to me Marino is almost as overrated a QB as Barry Sanders is a RB.

You must not have seen him play.

 

[Screw The Hall]

You must not have seen him play.

Many, many times.

 

[bustinj]

The greatest QBs are the ones with the most Super Bowl wins. Anything else is second place.

 

[jobberone]

The greatest QBs are the ones with the most Super Bowl wins. Anything else is second place.

Otto Graham never won a SB and he should be in the top five at the very least. Look his record up. He hardly gets the proper amount of attention he deserves. I'd rate J. Unitas over him but would be hard pressed to pick anyone else. Brady, Aikman, Montana and Elway are close.

 

[CowboyMark]

How in the hell is Steve Young #5? This list is BS if you catch my drift. No way can you put him above Staubach, Favre, Manning, or even Aikman.

 

[THUMPER]

The greatest QBs are the ones with the most Super Bowl wins. Anything else is second place.

That's a very uneducated statement.

 

[Screw The Hall]

Otto Graham never won a SB and he should be in the top five at the very least. Look his record up. He hardly gets the proper amount of attention he deserves. I'd rate J. Unitas over him but would be hard pressed to pick anyone else. Brady, Aikman, Montana and Elway are close.

I think the previous poster actually meant Championships, and Graham never had an equal there. I'd put him 3rd behind Montana and Unitas.