FOX Sports: Top 10 QBs of all-time

[arglebargle]

Otto Graham never won a SB and he should be in the top five at the very least. Look his record up. He hardly gets the proper amount of attention he deserves. I'd rate J. Unitas over him but would be hard pressed to pick anyone else. Brady, Aikman, Montana and Elway are close.

Because obviously Doug Williams, Tony Banks and Trent Dilfer are far superior to Graham, Marino, and Unitas.

I tend to rank P. Manning and Elway pretty highly, because of their skill in calling their own plays. Elway only got to do it in his two minute drills, but....

Personal opinions on the rankings aside, everyone's list should have about 8 of the same QBs to argue over.

 

[jobberone]

I think the previous poster actually meant Championships, and Graham never had an equal there. I'd put him 3rd behind Montana and Unitas.

Unitas is my number one. He called his own plays and made his own 'playbook' up. No one dared interfere with his offense. No QB coach or OC and he called his own plays. The only QB I've seen since that comes close is P Manning. Otto Graham called his own plays but Brown ran the offense. I only saw Graham play at the very end of his career and I was pretty young then. So I don't have a good memory of his play.

 

[Billy Bullocks]

Montana's numbers in the Super Bowl are epic. He led his teams to comeback TDs, not FGs.

IMO, he's the best ever.

 

[BourbonBalz]

Umm...Steve Young above Roger Staubach?

Hell, above Staubach? Troy isn't even on this list. Aikman was a better QB than Young.