Gosselin's top 10

[DogFace]

http://sportsday.***BANNED-URL***/d...boys-super-bowl-next-year-ranks-among-nfl-qbs

I disagree with it.

 

[romothesavior]

http://sportsday.***BANNED-URL***/d...boys-super-bowl-next-year-ranks-among-nfl-qbs

I disagree with it.

I agree with him from 1-6. Brees is debatable.

I'd take Stafford over Luck and Mariota.

Seems like Dak should sneak in at 9 or 10, but I can understand not including him quite yet.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

Gosselin is a doofus, but it's a defensible list. I don't think Carr should be that high, and Mariota probably not quite that high either. Rivers is better than a lot of those guys, but his numbers are hurt from playing on a crummy team with crummier players.

 

[DogFace]

I agree with him from 1-6. Brees is debatable.

I'd take Stafford over Luck and Mariota.

Seems like Dak should sneak in at 9 or 10, but I can understand not including him quite yet.

He was 3 in qbr and 7 in passer rating. I think he's definetly top 10.

 

[movaughn88]

I agree with him from 1-6. Brees is debatable.

I tend to agree with you, I think this is like a "old guy Pro Bowl vote" - happy to be refuted but since no one watches the Saints and they are terrible, doesn't he just throw for 5,000 yards now bc he's down 14 in a shootout every week?

Seems like Dak should sneak in at 9 or 10, but I can understand not including him quite yet.

Taking off my homer shades, I have to agree. I could see him 8-10 but I can't fault anyone for saying "prove it more than one year"

 

[SDCowboy]

I disagree, too. He is a top 10 QB. Period.

 

[Toruk_Makto]

He was 3 in qbr and 7 in passer rating. I think he's definetly top 10.

Part of being a great QB is success and longevity.

 

[romothesavior]

He was 3 in qbr and 7 in passer rating. I think he's definetly top 10.

If the list was best 2017 seasons, then I would agree with you. But it appears the list is best quarterbacks in the NFL.

 

[Oh_Canada]

Trolling for a reaction and a complete imbecile.

How is Stafford ahead of Dak? His best QBR was 97 WITH Megatron.

Why is Mariota ahead of him exactly?

To be honest I am not sure Luck is better and I love Luck.

 

[DFWJC]

Debatable but defensible

Mariota maybe?.
Others?

 

[Zimmy Lives]

http://sportsday.***BANNED-URL***/d...boys-super-bowl-next-year-ranks-among-nfl-qbs

I disagree with it.

I disagree with your disagree. Dak has to pass the test of time. He shows, promise, though.

 

[Zimmy Lives]

I disagree, too. He is a top 10 QB. Period.

Top 20.

 

[Sydla]

I think you could argue anywhere from 8-12 or so. So Gosselin isn't that crazy here. Normally he is, but not in this case IMO.

 

[DFWJC]

Trolling for a reaction and a complete imbecile.

How is Stafford ahead of Dak? His best QBR was 97 WITH Megatron.

Why is Mariota ahead of him exactly?

To be honest I am not sure Luck is better and I love Luck.

I'm ok with Dak > Stafford debate...it at least is debatable.
But I can't even begin to imagine how great Stafford would be on our team....with our line and Zeke and the other weapons. Come on he totally carried that crap team he was on. he probably threw for 1000 yards more too...which ups the odds of turnovers.
Still, he set the record with eight 4th quarter comeback wins. He's very good.

 

[Eddie]

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Tom Brady
3. Matt Ryan
4. Ben Roethlisberger
5. Derek Carr
6. Russell Wilson
7. Drew Brees
8. Andrew Luck
9. Marcus Mariota
10. Matthew Stafford


Not sold on Wilson. He regressed badly. Mariota and Carr each had a single reasonable year. Not sure I'd put them in the top 10 yet.

Compare Dak's year with Mariotta and Carr ... and it's a different story.

But let's see what Dak can do next year.

 

[rockj7]

http://sportsday.***BANNED-URL***/d...boys-super-bowl-next-year-ranks-among-nfl-qbs

I disagree with it.

Good keep doubting Dak that logic worked well for all the other NFL team scouts not named the Dallas Cowboys

 

[erod]

If healthy, I'd tuck Romo in there about #4.

 

[Oh_Canada]

I'm ok with Dak > Stafford debate...it at least is debatable.
But I can't even begin to imagine how great Stafford would be on our team....with our line and Zeke and the other weapons. Come on he totally carried that crap team he was on. he probably threw for 1000 yards more too...which ups the odds of turnovers.
Still, he set the record with eight 4th quarter comeback wins. He's very good.

Dallas pass blocking is not top three, maybe not even top five.
Stafford had a great line in 14 and Megatron his numbers were still not as good as Dak's.

 

[mldardy]

http://sportsday.***BANNED-URL***/d...boys-super-bowl-next-year-ranks-among-nfl-qbs

I disagree with it.

For those that don't subscribe to the dallasnews can you provide the content to the linked article please.

 

[DFWJC]

Dallas pass blocking is not top three, maybe not even top five.
Stafford had a great line in 14 and Megatron his numbers were still not as good as Dak's.

I said it was debatable and I don't really care either way.
However
Detroit's line was ranked 14th in 2014....that is not "great"
Stafford has never had a line like we have and he certainly has never had ZEKE and the running game that we have.
Megatron was great but he was just one guy...and often injured at that in the late years

Look, you're perfectly allowed to think Dak is better than Stafford. It wouldn't make you crazy.
I was just pointing out that Stafford on our team would be pretty sick.
I also think Stafford has improved.

Bottomline is that we a very lucky to have Dak