Gosselin's top 10

[FuzzyLumpkins]

Gosselin was good at regurgitating what execs, scouts and the like were saying to him in coming up with his mock drafts. Excellent reporter.

His opinions are rank with butthurt about poor treatment from Cowboys fans over the years. He trolls us.

 

[Irvin88_4life]

wow lol
GB had 2 FGs by the way not 1 like you suggest ..........I said they had 2, but the last one wasnt a drive that ended in a fg,
it was a get in position for fg play with 3 seconds left so that doesnt count as "settled for"
Dallas "settled" for fg's 3 times GB 1 time.
GB had 2 rushing td's Rodgers gets credit for those same as a pass lol
The whole idea is to get in the endzone, and a pass isnt better than a run, they are the same.
GB 4 td's
Dallas 3 td's
The job of the qb is to get the ball into the endzone more times than the other team, Rodgers did that.
And for fg's, teams only win with them if they get a bunch of them or it is last second fg.

If Dak had scored a td on that last drive, Dallas more than likely wins that game.
Spiking the ball hurt as not only did they lose a play, it allowed GB defense to regroup and catch their breath, it should have been no huddle
just go , keep them on the field no break and run elliot.
But our coaches called the spike then 2 passes and no td, so poor dak couldnt get it done.

That's the most insane thing I ever heard. No Rodgers doesn't get credit for Ty Montgomery 2 TDs rushing. If Rodgers ran them in sure that goes in his stats. Dak ran a 2 point in buy you fail to mention it.

Talk wins and losses all you want but Dak outplayed Rodgers as proven with facts by QB stats not team stats

 

[Cowboy89]

My top 10 & why:

1. Brady. Cannot do things Rodgers can. Doesn't put up Rodgers stats. He does make average players great. He puts up minimum 33 TD yearly as the oldest QB. He simply wins. The eye test will maybe show Rodgers is more talented. The results are a different story. 5 SB's ( Potentially) cannot be ignored.

2. A.R. Great QB. Can do things nobody else is able to do. He carried a team with a pathetic D. He's below Brady because of what I said above.

3. Brees. Yes he gets yards because his team is always down. I can't ignore the TD's and yards though. The guy is one of the hardest workers ( Per teammates, coaches, etc). He's not a big guy either.

4. Wilson. I am putting him here because he can run, scramble, make sound decisions ( Minus SB 49).

5. Ben. I have him here because of his gunslinger mentality. He has too many turnovers the last few years. He misses a few games yearly. I'll give him credit for being as tough as he can be, plus he's been to three SB's.

6. Ryan. He's not higher simply because l want to see him duplicate this season. I will say he's always been a good, underrated QB. Guy has a cannon and can move the pocket.

7. Luck. I can't deny he's talented. He is a decent runner and works with an awful o-line. Injuries do scare me some. I thought he would be the next generational QB. Eye test just hasn't shown that. Very much debated putting him here.

8. Stafford. Cannon arm and tough as nails. Always been underrated. His gunslinger mentality will give opposition teams opportunities.

9. Carr. Expect him to be top 3 in a year or two. Need to see him duplicate the success he had.

10. Dak. Can run, throw, make sound decisions. Need to see it duplicated.

A few factors contribute to my list:

Past success. ( See below for Rivers)
Future potential ( Why Rivers isn't higher)
Current performance.

 

[Oh_Canada]

Taking into consideration-2016, history, potential in that order:

Brady
Rodgers
Ryan
Brees
Rothliesberger
Carr
Dak
Wilson
Luck
Newton

 

[tyke1doe]

RisenStar: No Carson Wentz?