Doomsday101;4027364 said:
These groups will still make money selling it. Say we make it legal what size tax do you think would be placed on it? Black market would still be very big and consumers who buy it illegal today would continue to buy it illegal if the given the price is vastly lower
Meh, I don't think independents could thrive for very long.
We've talked Amsterdam and they have zero problem filling their shops.
Sure, you'll have people who grow at home just as you have people who brew their own beers at him but that segment won't dominate.
The fact that it is illegal is what makes it so profitable. People have to go to great lengths to grow it because the risk is high. So they charge more. In addition, for the user who's using a few times per week they have to buy more quantity than probably would if it were legal because nobody wants to engage in more risky and illegal transactions than they have to.
If cigarettes were illegal, people would probably buy them by the carton from their dealer as opposed to by the pack. Pack a day habit means 30 purchases a month unless you buy in bulk.
Additionally, when you legalize it you make it a social experience. If you can head downtown with a couple of friends, get high and grab some food, taking a trip to the local dealer and heading back home to watch South Park just isn't in the cards.
"Hey, you wanna head over to the smoke shop and try some new product or do you want to go to my creepy ex-dealer's pad and get whatever he has?"
The only way independents could stay in business would be under the same model that local and organic food operations are built on. Providing high quality and pure product.
And then there's the issue of poaching. If you're running your operation on public land, you're losing crop daily from people helping themselves.
Large scale black market operations would be very hard pressed to succeed on the level they do now because they would still be working illegal (either in production or in combination of other sales) and the average person likely wouldn't take that risk IF they didn't have to.
Edit:
I may be pro legalization but I've never smoked weed, not even in Amsterdam. I did try a space cake (or whatever the hell they call them now) when I was there but have never smoked it.