I would be delighted if Garrett proved himself to be a great coach like Landry. I'm just not convinced that he will. He's shown he has a good eye for talent. We've drafted pretty well under Garrett, which was definitely not the case under Switzer and Campo. Garrett has also shown himself to be a good motivator. However, the most troubling thing about Garrett has been his poor clock management. We saw that two seasons ago in several games, including that one against the Cards when he accidentally iced his own kicker. Unfortunately, he doesn't seem to have improved. We absolutely should have won those games against the Lions and the Packers, but lost due to a combination of a poor defense and bad clock management. We had leads. We knew we could run the ball and burn up the clock. Why we didn't just boggles the mind. When your D is suspect, ball control becomes much more important. Eat up the clock, wear out the opposition's defense, and rest your own defense. We also have a quarterback who does way better when he has support for the run game. It boggles the mind that Garrett/Callahan got pass happy in those situations. If Garrett and whoever is is O-coordinator can get it through their thick noggins that we don't have the type of players well-suited for pass-happy offense, then I might change my mind. But as it stands, I want him out of there. I do agree that we don't want to have a revolving door at head coach. That's a recipe for failure. There's much to like about Garrett, but what isn't to like is insurmountable. Last year at this time I was saying keep him and let's get his clock management problems under control. I welcomed having Callahan do the play calling because I figured he would use more sense and balance the pass and the run. The thing is we've got a good O-line now and a Pro Bowl running back! There's no reason on this earth not to use that to our advantage. We've got Garrett for at least one more year. If I see that he's doing a better job with the clock, I might support keeping him. But if we have any more debacles like the Lions and Packers games where we snatched defeat from the jaws of victory, then I'll be screaming to get Garrett out of there.
Great post..
hey..I even learned something..and
I KNOW IT ALLL.
Just ask anybody.
Seriously..
I remain less definite about where Garrett stands yet.
He has had a slew of injuries to deal with and players like Ratliff who was a poison pill and too may guys like Austin, Ratliff, Spencer, Free, Ware and Demarco Murray who are injured, don't play full seasons or just don't give a Rats ***.
As for Garrett and Landry comparisons..
..Landry completely struggled for years and didn't really get things rolling until Danny Reeves and Mike Ditka retired and came on the staff as assistant coaches.
At that point, Joe Avazano came and Ernie Stautner blossomed as a DC when Randy White developed and Too Tall Jones started to bat down passes.
So its all about the HC..
but its also about the quality of the assistants.
And Garrett has been like a lightning bug in a jar.
Not much to eat..a few holes poked in the jar for some air..
..and that's not a good recipe for success.
I don't care for how Jones has not let Garrett build his staff to date..
place too much responsibility on Garrett to be the HC, playcaller and game manager too quickly
Garrett's game management is a group responsibility..not just Garrett getting it rather right or wrong.