I'm sure this is not what Quincy Carter had in mind 8 years ago

Sickwitit

Member
Messages
839
Reaction score
5
you guys dont get my point.....what im saying is if romo dont pick up his play and consistance there will be a pic of him with his bags backed with a goofy face leaving valley ranch.
 

CantonBound08

Member
Messages
610
Reaction score
1
Sickwitit;2727200 said:
all of those things are true but......all of thatt upside he has'nt done annything for the team that a 2 nd round dope fiend below average qb hasnt done.
Are you serious? You come out and ask someone to explain to you how Romo is better than Carter without counting stats, they do it, and then you come back with this?

Un-BELIEVE-able.
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
Sickwitit;2727218 said:
you guys dont get my point.....what im saying is if romo dont pick up his play and consistance there will be a pic of him with his bags backed with a goofy face leaving valley ranch.
No, I get it. I just think it's ridiculous, full of flawed logic, and wrong. Other than that, not a thing wrong with it.
 

gbrittain

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,126
Reaction score
67
Hostile;2727202 said:
That 2nd round dope fiend never made us a contender and never would have.

There isn't an NFL Coach or Scout alive who would agree with your takes and place Romo and Carter at equal levels.

Can you imagin if Quincy's first two and half years looked like this:

10562 yards
63.6 completion percentage
81 TDs
94.7 QB Rating

We would have to have the first still playing inductee into the Ring of Honor.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,348
Reaction score
64,053
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
Sickwitit;2727145 said:
Oh I remember that playoff game Q lost, That was the one were Newman was standing still while Steve Smith Flew right past him right?........Oh and not to mention Peppers extremely good release off the ball!!! HAHAHA! Poor Ole Q!

Sickwitit;2727147 said:
not to bash on romo but did you watch the Rams game this year?!:lmao: I never saw Quincy throw a game away like that one good GOD!

Sickwitit;2727164 said:
ohhh i stand corrected.....ok what about the eagles game, he threw that game granted he wasnt the only problem that game....the whole problem with the romo vs Q arguement is that...there is way more money and promise invested im romo and he hasnt shown much more success for this team than quincy did sure his stats kill quimcy but for the Dallas Cowboys romo is no better than quincy.

Sickwitit;2727175 said:
You tell me other than some stats how hes so much better than Quincy for the success of the TEAM

Sickwitit;2727200 said:
all of those things are true but......all of thatt upside he has'nt done annything for the team that a 2 nd round dope fiend below average qb hasnt done.



http://i356.***BLOCKED***/albums/oo4/DallasEast1701/judassaying1.jpg​



.
 

Sickwitit

Member
Messages
839
Reaction score
5
CantonBound08;2727221 said:
Are you serious? You come out and ask someone to explain to you how Romo is better than Carter without counting stats, they do it, and then you come back with this?

Un-BELIEVE-able.

read my post i said better for the team stats do nothimg for the team if you arent winning
 

Vintage

The Cult of Jib
Messages
16,714
Reaction score
4,888
Sickwitit;2727218 said:
you guys dont get my point.....what im saying is if romo dont pick up his play and consistance there will be a pic of him with his bags backed with a goofy face leaving valley ranch.


Romo's far more talented than Carter ever was.

The difference is Romo's teams have consistently underachieved. Whether its missing the playoffs this year, going 13-3 the previous year but fizzing out in a home playoff game, or the Seattle Fumbled Snap....

Some of its Romo's fault. Some of it isn't.

But he isn't someone you are going to cast away like a Quincy Carter. Flaws and all.

And this is coming from someone who was a big QC supporter.
 

gbrittain

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,126
Reaction score
67
Sickwitit;2727232 said:
read my post knot head i said better for the team stats do nothimg for the team if you arent winning

The only team that ended the season successfully were the Steelers. Roethlisberger can hold his head high no doubt, but that does not mean after Roethlisberger all QBs are the same.

Drew Brees and the Saints...no playoffs. Dan Orlovsky and the Lions...no playoffs.

In your world the two QBs are the same. However, in the real world not a single GM in the world would just as soon have Dan Orlovsky because the end result was the same.

One team says Drew Brees did not get us championship here but he is a championship caliber QB and if the cards fall right we can win with him.

The other team says Dan Orlovsky did not get us a championship and if we dont get a better QB we will never win a championship.

How hard is that to understand?
 

Hostile

The Duke
Messages
119,565
Reaction score
4,544
gbrittain;2727239 said:
The only team that ended the season successfully were the Steelers. Roethlisberger can hold his head high no doubt, but that does not mean after Roethlisberger all QBs are the same.

Drew Brees and the Saints...no playoffs. Dan Orlovsky and the Lions...no playoffs.

In your world the two QBs are the same. However, in the real world not a single GM in the world would just as soon have Dan Orlovsky because the end result was the same.

One team says Drew Brees did not get us championship here but he is a championship caliber QB and if the cards fall right we can win with him.

The other team says Dan Orlovsky did not get us a championship and if we dont get a better QB we will never win a championship.

How hard is that to understand?
:clap:
 

Sickwitit

Member
Messages
839
Reaction score
5
I am not talking about ben,the steelers,lions,or the saints im talking about the Dallas Cowboys and the fact is even tho romos skill set is good the guy isnt playing good when it counts
 

gbrittain

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,126
Reaction score
67
Sickwitit;2727251 said:
I am not talking about ben,the steelers,lions,or the saints im talking about the Dallas Cowboys and the fact is even tho romos skill set is good the guy isnt playing good when it counts

Perfect...so your suggestion is we ________________________? Go ahead and play GM for a day.
 

Sickwitit

Member
Messages
839
Reaction score
5
change is needed after this year if he continues to play poorly i love the guy but i wanna winwe difentily need a young prospect now tho like we got romo
 

Dave_in-NC

Well-Known Member
Messages
17,049
Reaction score
5,132
I don't care how much you guys debate this.
That Picture of Carter to this day brings laughter tears to my eyes.
 

SLATEmosphere

Benched
Messages
9,633
Reaction score
2
Sickwitit;2727262 said:
change is needed after this year if he continues to play poorly i love the guy but i wanna winwe difentily need a young prospect now tho like we got romo

Where do you get that hat in your avatar? It's dope!!
 

TellerMorrow34

BraveHeartFan
Messages
28,358
Reaction score
5,076
Sickwitit;2727147 said:
BraveHeartFan;2726912 said:
If we had Q right now we'd be a 6-10 team at best cause he'd be pulling the entire team down. With Romo he gives us an immediate shot in every single game that he's in.


not to bash on romo but did you watch the Rams game this year?!:lmao: I never saw Quincy throw a game away like that one good GOD!


Funny cause I did watch that game and for some odd reason I don't recall Romo playing a single snap in that game. Weird.


Sickwitit;2727175 said:
You tell me other than some stats how hes so much better than Quincy for the success of the TEAM

It's pretty simple. If you put Q on this team we go from being a legit playoff/superbowl contender to being a pretty solid pick for not only bottom of the NFC East but near the bottom of the entire NFC.

If you can't see how much more successful this team is with Romo than it is without (The three games without him this year should have cleared this up perfectly for people) then you've got issues. It's painfully obvious that he makes his offensive line look like they've got Probowl level players on it when in reality they're barely above average. You put pretty much any other QBs behind this line, whose names aren't McNabb or Big Ben and they will get absolutely destroyed cause they won't be able to scramble around enough to save themselves.



Sickwitit;2727200 said:
all of those things are true but......all of thatt upside he has'nt done annything for the team that a 2 nd round dope fiend below average qb hasnt done.

Except give them an infinite better shot of winning every single game he's part of then when he's not. Defenses worry about what Romo can do and I'm certain there wasn't a defense in the league who feared anything about Q.


Sickwitit;2727251 said:
I am not talking about ben,the steelers,lions,or the saints im talking about the Dallas Cowboys and the fact is even tho romos skill set is good the guy isnt playing good when it counts

And none of the other 52 players on the game day rosters are playing good when it counts. So where are the threads saying that the other 52 players aren't any better than so and so who was here during one miracle season for Quincy Carter?
 

bbgun

Benched
Messages
27,869
Reaction score
6
I find it hard to believe that such a minor figure in Cowboy history is eliciting this much passion all these years later. Maybe off-season boredom is to blame.
 

DallasEast

Cowboys 24/7/365
Staff member
Messages
62,348
Reaction score
64,053
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
bbgun;2727349 said:
I find it hard to believe that such a minor figure in Cowboy history is eliciting this much passion all these years later. Maybe off-season boredom is to blame.
OR folks are simply using Quincy Carter as a transparent excuse to throw excrement at Tony Romo.
 
Top