Interesting Question: Who is the "Worst" Dallas Cowboy Ever?

[joseephuss]

What!!!????? Please try to justify that ridiculous claim about the great Ike Holt!!!!!!!!!!!

I liked Ike.

 

[joseephuss]

Curvin "butterfingers" Richards.

Sherman Williams. Had a Troy Hambrick attitude with even less talent.

 

[jem88]

I liked Ike.

Amen brother! My thoughts on him are well-documented so I won't bore you all with a rehash (don't want to get all Nors/Kartr on you guys.) All anybody has to do is pop in a few tapes from the 1990 season and you'll see a real-playmaker. Think he was a joke? Just ask Robert Drummond, he'll tell you what it's like to be on the receiving end of Holt's vengeange. Plus, added points must be given for the Mark McMillan-Lucky Charms line.

 

[jem88]

The worst players I've seen are: Babe Laufenberg, Dwayne Goodrich, Jose Cortez, Marcellus Wiley, and Clay Shiver.

 

[AbeBeta]

The worst players I've seen are: Babe Laufenberg, Dwayne Goodrich, Jose Cortez, Marcellus Wiley, and Clay Shiver.

Babe is a double threat. He's a crap announcer as well.

 

[Concord]

Irvin would totally disagree with you. He liked Q's moxie and talent. As a matter of fact, he said that the Jets should have played Q more once Pennington got hurt because he can do more. Q won 2 out 3 games with the Jets and they've won like 5 games since he last played for them some twenty games ago.

You're Unbelievable...You are either Carter himself...His agent...or a Family member...Because NOBODY could stick up for Carter the way you do!

It's Sad really...To Waste this much of your life defending one of the worst decisions the Cowboys EVER made.

 

[fortdick]

I'd have to go with Goodrich and Septien. All the rest of the guys mentioned didn't kill anyone or molest kids.

Well, I guess you have to add Hollywood Henderson. Rape at gun point of teenage girls, doing coke during the game. Wasted talent. He was mishandled too, I guess.

 

[TheKey]

Alonzo Spellman

 

[panathas]

Ryan Leaf,Andre Miller,Tony Banks,

 

[cowboyfan4life_mark]

Now hold on here.

Are we using off the field criteria?

Everyone freaks if it even seems like the HoF uses that criteria.

Maybe you all now see how hard that information is to ignore.

Huh.

Big difference in doing something that hurts yourself (Irvin) and doing something that hurts others (Goodrich).

The reason that I picked Goodrich was for the fact that for a 2nd round pick, he didn't do squat. What he did after football just made the decision easier. I can put Ross in the same statement.

And as far as the HOF goes, it should just be about the numbers. And Irvin beats some of the current HOF'ers.

Am I a Cowboy homer? Yes I am. But I also am realistic. I also believe that Rose should be in baseballs HOF.

 

[Paniolo22]

The worst players I've seen are: Babe Laufenberg, Dwayne Goodrich, Jose Cortez, Marcellus Wiley, and Clay Shiver.

Yayyyyy! Another vote for Cortez!!!. Clay Shiver was a crappy player as well. At least Wiley started for us.

 

[brucem78]

Paul Justin or Hugh Millen Take your pick.

 

[jem88]

Paul Justin or Hugh Millen Take your pick.

You're just spouting off obscure names for the sake of spouting off obscure names. Neither played enough to warrant being called the worst Cowboy ever. Hell I could say that Everett Gay was the worst ever if I followed your example.

 

[jem88]

Ryan Leaf,Andre Miller,Tony Banks,

Andre Miller? Care to elaborate? Could you perhaps be referring to Anthony Miller? Could you perhaps be picking names out of a hat to try and look clever? Ryan Leaf might be the worst Charger ever but he did more for us than Clint Stoerner ever did. Banks never made it to the regular season, so I fail to see how he could be one of the worst ever. Why not just throw Carl Pickens onto that list?

 

[jem88]

Alonzo Spellman

Ridiculous. Almost as ridiculous as putting Mario Edwards on your list.

 

[WV Cowboy]

Well, I guess you have to add Hollywood Henderson. Rape at gun point of teenage girls, doing coke during the game. Wasted talent. He was mishandled too, I guess.

Rape at gun point of teenage girls ???

Link please, ... this never happened.

He was partying with girls that he thought were of age, but he was wrong.

It is called statutory rape because she was under age, but it was all consensual and there was no "rape at gun point."

You are right about everything else though.