Is Dak in your top ten QB?

[Manster_Mash]

No

 

[Swagger]

My top QBs

1. Rodgers
2. Mahomes
3. Allen
4. Brady
5. Herbert
6. Burrow
7. Jackson
8. Wilson
9. Stafford
10. Watson
11. Murray

12. Cousins, Carr, Tannehill, Prescott

People might argue about Watson and Murray but they are play makers and at times have been the main reason their team won games.

Dak hasn't changed just because of how he played on Sunday, before the season began I ranked him on a par with the likes of Cousins, Carr and Tannehill in the 12-15 bracket.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

mines

1. Mahomes
2. Brady
3. Rodgers
4. Burrow
5. Herbert
6. Josh Allen
7. Lamar Jackson
8. Russel Wilson
9. Matt Stafford
10. Kirk cousins
11, Derek carr
12 deshsaun Watson lol and also Ryan tanehill

Huge drop off

14-18 Kyler Murray/ dak/ tua/ Mac jones / Trevor Lawrence

they’re all younger and getting better.

so he’s below average.

Tier 3 QB from 20th to 32nd in the NFL.
Now for you still on the fence and hoping I'm wrong well stick around until he gets back(if that happens at this point) and watch him stink up the joint once again and again and again!
By the time the season is over Dak Prescott will be referred to as the worst contract that ever occurred in the NFL!!!
There laugh about Jerry and Jerry knows it......

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

I would take Carr over Dak any day.

I think he’s been a tier below for years. His career next to Jared Goff is eerily similar.

 

[zeke21]

Tier 3 QB from 20th to 32nd in the NFL.
Now for you still on the fence and hoping I'm wrong well stick around until he gets back(if that happens at this point) and watch him stink up the joint once again and again and again!
By the time the season is over Dak Prescott will be referred to as the worst contract that ever occurred in the NFL!!!
There laugh about Jerry and Jerry knows it......

You are right.. everyone knows it. Sorry you had to put up with so many giving you trouble over the years. Anyone with an eye for talent knew that Dak was a bum.. you called it loud and proud. Worst. Contract. Ever.

 

[Cowpolk]

Whom is he better than in my top ten


I would trust tanehill with this team more yes. Dak is regressing

3 other players

 

[Starstruck22]

What should end the debate is the simple question is $160 million tantamount to the performance here with the struggles to complete 20 yard passes and zero touchdowns. I mean really just think of what you can purchase for $160 million dollars. Dak simply is not worth even 5 million in my estimation.

 

[Starstruck22]

I think he’s been a tier below for years. His career next to Jared Goff is eerily similar.

Carr a tier below when Dak struggles to complete 20 yard passes? No touchdowns? 160 million dollars. 160 MILLION DOLLARS!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Cowpolk]

What should end the debate is the simple question is $160 million tantamount to the performance here with the struggles to complete 20 yard passes and zero touchdowns. I mean really just think of what you can purchase for $160 million dollars. Dak simply is not worth even 5 million in my estimation.

So Dak has only played 1 game cool stats

 

[Cowboysheelsreds053]

Tier 3 QB from 20th to 32nd in the NFL.
Now for you still on the fence and hoping I'm wrong well stick around until he gets back(if that happens at this point) and watch him stink up the joint once again and again and again!
By the time the season is over Dak Prescott will be referred to as the worst contract that ever occurred in the NFL!!!
There laugh about Jerry and Jerry knows it......

Wooooooooooo!

 

[gimmesix]

He was before last Sunday.
Not anymore.

Exactly. Outside of a few QBs, the list is malleable every year. Based on team circumstances (bad OL play, etc.), most quarterbacks rise and fall on the list. Dak deserves to be bottom half after the opener.

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Derek Carr in his last 11 games: 14 TDs, 13 INTs, 11 fumbles, 5-6 record

Whatever you think Dak is, you can’t realistically put Carr over him.

Why do just 11 games that’s silly,

carr has arm talent, which I like.

 

[john van brocklin]

Exactly. Outside of a few QBs, the list is malleable every year. Based on team circumstances (bad OL play, etc.), most quarterbacks rise and fall on the list. Dak deserves to be bottom half after the opener.

It was a stinker for sure!!!!

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Why do just 11 games that’s silly,

carr has arm talent, which I like.

So did Jamarcus Russell. The NFL requires substantially more than that

 

[Aerolithe_Lion]

Carr a tier below when Dak struggles to complete 20 yard passes? No touchdowns? 160 million dollars. 160 MILLION DOLLARS!!!!!!!!!!!

And Derek Carr makes an even higher AAV to perform worse

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

So did Jamarcus Russell. The NFL requires substantially more than that

Your logic is silly. Plus you picked one guy in my top ten and found a bad streak of games.

Let’s compare their last 1 game?

 

[GINeric]

mines

1. Mahomes
2. Brady
3. Rodgers
4. Burrow
5. Herbert
6. Josh Allen
7. Lamar Jackson
8. Russel Wilson
9. Matt Stafford
10. Kirk cousins
11, Derek carr
12 deshsaun Watson lol and also Ryan tanehill

Huge drop off

14-18 Kyler Murray/ dak/ tua/ Mac jones / Trevor Lawrence

they’re all younger and getting better.

so he’s below average.

Lamar Jackson is a better runner than Dak, but not a better passer. Everyone with a half decent football IQ knows that and you got him at 7th??? LOOOOL!!!

But you really loss me when you put Stafford at 9th. This is the same quarterback who's 8-68 against winning teams.... but hes ranked 9th?? LOOOL!!!

I can't even take this list halfway seriously....

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

Lamar Jackson is a better runner than Dak, but not a better passer. Everyone with a half decent football IQ knows that and you got him at 7th??? LOOOOL!!!

But you really loss me when you put Stafford at 9th. This is the same quarterback who's 8-68 against winning teams.... but hes ranked 9th?? LOOOL!!!

I can't even take this list halfway seriously....

Buddy you’re roasting a league mvp and a super bowl champion? Did you seen the 3 point party we just had .


For the record I jsut looked it up
Derek carr career td/int is 195-88
Dak Prescott carrer td/int 143/51

32,000 yards for carr career.
Dak 24k

 

[GINeric]

You can be a fan and still be objective...

Being objective is one thing. But being delusional or just cursed with very bad football IQ is another.

 

[ChronicCowboy]

I had him at 10 or 11 preseason. He’s in jeopardy of falling down to 15 or 20 unless he makes something of this season.