Is Romo a hall of famer?

[OmerV]

They are meaningless to me. Yes, I know that Eli is going to get in.

Plus, his career stats aren't great. Other than throwing a lot of passes, he hasn't done anything particularly well.

So, by your standard a guy who has 2 great years and then decides he want's to go into another line of work and quits football is a better HOF candidate than a guy who never quite had the same years, but was a step below and was dedicated to it for 15-20 years? I'll have to take another view. While Eli was never a Brady/Brees/Rodgers level guy (or Peyton either), he has been a consistently solid, reliable QB for many years, and has been a key part of a lot of team success. I'm on the fence about whether that is enough for me to say Eli belongs in the HOF, but hat kind of consistency and dedication over many years, for me, does have value and is worth something.

 

[Super_Kazuya]

I earlier in this thread said Eli wasn’t a lock. You’ve joined the party late

Not pointing at anyone in particular... just felt this was a good quoting spot.

Some further reading, with thoughts from actual HoF voters...
https://www.newsday.com/sports/colu...will-enough-voters-agree-with-that-1.22158151

 

[AtomicDog]

I think Romo is worthy of hall of fame. He does own all the Dallas Cowboys passing records which should count for a lot. He is not a 1st ballot obviously. But still a damn good quarterback. Yes, hall of fame worthy.

 

[G2]

Like I said, that's a play that Romo made routinely throughout his career.

No. It's not. There isn't a regular season hall of fame. Just stop.

 

[CowboyChris]

His career stats are far worse.

I’m not sure why people are acting like Eli is a lock. There has already been a lot of informal polling of actual Hall of Fame voters and the early results say he’s going to definitely be hotly debated. He’s far from a lock... voters aren’t as stupid as some of the QB winz nimrods in here.

I have Eli on my list of getting in, doesn't mean i think he should.

 

[Diehardblues]

I have Eli on my list of getting in, doesn't mean i think he should.

Most reports I’ve read said Eli isn’t getting in.

I just think his career stats are more worthy than Romo.

If Romo had played for more than 7 full seasons he might have ran up more career stats. Like Rivers.

 

[CowboyChris]

Most reports I’ve read said Eli isn’t getting in.

I just think his career stats are more worthy than Romo.

If Romo had played for more than 7 full seasons he might have ran up more career stats.

he's getting in for his 2 SB wins over the Pats

 

[Diehardblues]

he's getting in for his 2 SB wins over the Pats

If he does get in that will be a big part of it. As Impact often is. But his career stats aren’t shabby

 

[PJTHEDOORS]

Cowboys Zone tells me he’s a top 5 quarterback along the likes of SUPERBOWL winners like Brady, Rodgers, Brees, Ben, and Manning.

Will the all time great Romo be in the hall of fame?

Or is he just Andy Dalton 2.0 a career loser?

No

 

[Future]

No. It's not. There isn't a regular season hall of fame. Just stop.

Yes it is. Should I show you the jj watt play or the entire game against Denver?

There isn't a regular season Hof. There also isn't a playoff Hof. Dan Marino never did anything in the playoffs either lol...

 

[MarcusRock]

Dang good QB but no.

 

[G2]

Yes it is. Should I show you the jj watt play or the entire game against Denver?

There isn't a regular season Hof. There also isn't a playoff Hof. Dan Marino never did anything in the playoffs either lol...

Lmao, are you serious? So one play in a game and another game verses NON conference teams that mean nothing is HOF material? Bahahahaha!

I know there's no regular season HOF. That was my point! When the game was on the line in IMPORTANT end of season or post season games he buckled..

 

[mattjames2010]

Most reports I’ve read said Eli isn’t getting in.

I just think his career stats are more worthy than Romo.

If Romo had played for more than 7 full seasons he might have ran up more career stats. Like Rivers.

LOL reports can say what they want, when the time comes, they are putting him in...

A 2x super bowl MVP that has two of the most iconic super bow throws over the New England Patriots, along with beating them when they were nearly undefeated, will get him in.

He’s a lock.

 

[bodi]

no maybe ROH

 

[mattjames2010]

Lmao, are you serious? So one play in a game and another game verses NON conference teams that mean nothing is HOF material? Bahahahaha!

I know there's no regular season HOF. That was my point! When the game was on the line in IMPORTANT end of season or post season games he buckled..

You’re not reading what Future said, Marino got by and into the HOF on regular season stats...

Actually, most players get into the HOF due to regular season stats...

 

[Diehardblues]

Yes it is. Should I show you the jj watt play or the entire game against Denver?

There isn't a regular season Hof. There also isn't a playoff Hof. Dan Marino never did anything in the playoffs either lol...

I wouldn’t say Marino didn’t do anything. He played in 18 playoff games.. Only 2 seasons did he only play in one, the rest were multiple playoff appearances and of course the one Super Bowl appearance.

 

[Diehardblues]

You’re not reading what Future said, Marino got by and into the HOF on regular season stats...

Actually, most players get into the HOF due to regular season stats...

Right. That’s how Witten is getting in.

Nope. Future is making less and less sense. Lol

He should have quit while he was behind

 

[G2]

You’re not reading what Future said, Marino got by and into the HOF on regular season stats...

Actually, most players get into the HOF due to regular season stats...

You're not reading what I said. That Romo did nothing past the regular season. Romo's stats aren't even that great. Team-wise, sure. But top 6-10 QBs in their era aren't making the HOF.
Why are we even talking about Marino? Good god people.
And I wasn't JUST referring to JUST stats. And he's not in for the regular season.
He played in 18 play off games!

 

[Diehardblues]

LOL reports can say what they want, when the time comes, they are putting him in...

A 2x super bowl MVP that has two of the most iconic super bow throws over the New England Patriots, along with beating them when they were nearly undefeated, will get him in.

He’s a lock.

That’s mere opinion at this time. He’s certainly not a 1st ballot.

 

[Diehardblues]

You're not reading what I said. That Romo did nothing past the regular season. Romo's stats aren't even that great. Team-wise, sure. But top 6-10 QBs in their era aren't making the HOF.
Why are we even talking about Marino? Good god people.
And I wasn't JUST referring to JUST stats. And he's not in for the regular season.
He played in 18 play off games!

Yea, Marino sunk his argument . Lol