Springs is 32, and has missed 22 games over the last 6 seasons... he's had 2 ints and 15 passes defensed in his last 24 games (covering 2 seasons)...
Smoot has missed 5 games the last 2 years himself, and has been in and out of the starting lineup for a really bad Minnesota pass defense that finished 22nd 2 years ago, dead last last year... he has recorded 3 ints and all of 11 passes defensed in his last 25 games...
Rogers, well, let's just say that this kid was bit BAD by the "sophomore jinx" last year... his 79 tackles is more a testimony to how often he gave up completions and made the tackle than it was to his abilities defending the run...
If those are your top 3 corners (and they are), no wonder the Skins were so quick to jump on Butler-- even if he does have MAJOR injury issues (missed all of 05, played 2 games in 06)... even when he was considered "good", his numbers weren't all that-- he had 4 ints in 03, but only 5 passes defensed... he followed that up with 5 ints the following season, but he did have 14 passes defensed, which isn't bad... OTOH, the Rams as a team only had 6 ints, which strongly suggests that Butler got those picks because he was the one they were throwing on most often... this is borne out by the number of tackles he had those 2 seasons, 71 in 03 and 79 in 04... those are some awfully high tackle totals for a cornerback... of those 150 tackles, only 13 were assisted, suggesting he wasn't racking up tackles supporting the run (which is hardly surprising, given that he's 5-10, 185 pounds)... instead, it appears that he was giving up a lot of completions along with those 9 ints...
And again, the guy's played 2 games the last 2 seasons, it's pretty silly to assume that you're getting the same player who got all that PR in 03 and 04...
Macklin was in and out of the starting lineup, battling with the immortal Eric Green (LOL), for the league's 30th ranked pass defense... he had 1 int and 4 passes defensed in 14 games last season... now, he WAS a bit more effective the previous 2 years, and I guess so long as you don't expect him to be more than a third corner, he won't be too hateful...
Jimoh is a stiff, always has been... the only thing he'll offer the Skins is special teams help... in 63 games played, he's still looking for his first int, and he has but 5 passes defensed in that time... if you guys have to use him for any extended period of time as a cornerback, you're in DEEP doo-doo... the Boys have 2 reserve corners on their roster who are superior to him, and it wouldn't shock me if neither of them made the 53 man roster this year (Nate Jones and Jacques Reeves)...
As for Westbrook, permit me a second to LOL at you... this guy is an undrafted rookie free agent, who played DIVISION III college football, at that noted football powerhouse, Salisbury University... the only way this kid stands a chance of making the team is if he can impress as a kick returner... I guess you're all excited because his brother is a good NFL running back, and of course the little brothers of good NFL running backs ALWAYS turn into stud NFL defensive backs...
Even if Butler is fully recovered, and that's a BIG "if", cornerback is still a weakness on the Skins' roster...