Jerry: Confident in McCarthy, coaching staff is outstanding

Stash

Staff member
Messages
78,810
Reaction score
103,500
CowboysZone ULTIMATE Fan
You truly believe that winning this playoff game will be THE deciding factor in Fat Mikey’s job here?
WHY??
Because if he doesn’t it means another year of no progress. A team deep with player talent that can’t get to the next level. And meanwhile a unique opportunity presents itself in Payton and Fangio. And if Jones doesn’t seize it, someone else will.
 

Clove

Shrinkage
Messages
64,860
Reaction score
27,443
The problem I have with the Jones' boys is this. You have to give up SOMETHING to be a great franchise. If you're not going to give up power and be the unsuccessful GM for over 30 something years, at least give up football power with the Coach. Allow him to do everything he likes. All the things you've done up until this point isn't working, so try something new.
 

Clove

Shrinkage
Messages
64,860
Reaction score
27,443
Because if he doesn’t it means another year of no progress. A team deep with player talent that can’t get to the next level. And meanwhile a unique opportunity presents itself in Payton and Fangio. And if Jones doesn’t seize it, someone else will.
I might have to agree with you and I have one reason I do. It "SEEMS" as if Payton is the one person Jones would actually give full power to. Remember the word "seems". He gave Moore to McCarthy, that's not a McCarthy hire.
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,157
Reaction score
38,768
So if he’s not a puppet, he’s a head coach. A head coach in an organization drafting well and spending what they can. That’s a favorable environment in my view.
But he is a puppet in some ways. Perhaps not as much as previous HC.

But not in control of his OC. He’s not in complete control of his players. And he’s not the voice of announcing players status , etc. .

I can’t imagine anyone not seeing how this atmosphere within Jethro’s ways isn’t dysfunctional. Definitely not a favorable environment despite the drafts and personnel. But it certainly explains your view if you believe as such.
 
Last edited:

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,157
Reaction score
38,768
The problem I have with the Jones' boys is this. You have to give up SOMETHING to be a great franchise. If you're not going to give up power and be the unsuccessful GM for over 30 something years, at least give up football power with the Coach. Allow him to do everything he likes. All the things you've done up until this point isn't working, so try something new.
It’s not going to change with Jethro. He’s simply not going to let go completely.

And why winning isn’t his absolute priority. Only if he’s involved. It’s not enough to just take credit for bringing in the right guy and staying out of the way,

He tried that with Jimmy and winning championships wasn’t enough. He has to be the face of the franchise.
 

LACowboysFan1

Well-Known Member
Messages
11,649
Reaction score
7,584
Want to know how Jerry views this season?

He said it himself yesterday (I think, might have been day before):

"This team has to make the playoffs to be successful"

Which they have, so, in Jerry's mind the season is a success. Meaning he's satisfied for this year, so no mattter what happens after today, he's happy, at least for now.

Now does he want to win another SB? Sure, but if he doesn't win it this year, he's already looking forward to next year, because, surely, he's so great of an owner and general manager he's bound to win one sooner or later. He's destined to win another one, so why worry about this year, or dying before he gets another one? It's all in the grand scheme of things.

:facepalm:
 

Diehardblues

Well-Known Member
Messages
58,157
Reaction score
38,768
Because if he doesn’t it means another year of no progress. A team deep with player talent that can’t get to the next level. And meanwhile a unique opportunity presents itself in Payton and Fangio. And if Jones doesn’t seize it, someone else will.
That I can agree. If Jethro doesn’t seize it someone else will.
 

DStar22

Well-Known Member
Messages
805
Reaction score
866
Mcarthy is fine as a head coach. he is doing a great job building a team. I hope he is the cowboys coach for years to come... perhaps in that time he will be able to get the personnel to win us another superbowl all at one time.. we are almost there.

KM i can take him or leave him.
 

DandyDon52

Well-Known Member
Messages
22,646
Reaction score
16,533
The problem I have with the Jones' boys is this. You have to give up SOMETHING to be a great franchise. If you're not going to give up power and be the unsuccessful GM for over 30 something years, at least give up football power with the Coach. Allow him to do everything he likes. All the things you've done up until this point isn't working, so try something new.
jerry likes the power and controlling things like he hired kellen made him OC and made MM not interfere with kellen.
Thats crazy, but that is what jerry thinks will work lol.
But he isnt going to give up any real power to any coach.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,072
Reaction score
27,164
Fat Mikey is about as good of puppet as we could probably hope for .

I really can’t see Sean playing a puppet role . Much better full autonomy jobs available in AZ, and Den. Maybe LA.

And if he wants a total rebuild and closer to home . Houston

Why would any legit HC come here unless their phone isn’t ringing.
Good point............besides, all the guys who have hard ons for Fat Mike getting canned automatically think Payton is the replacement.

What if I told you Wonder Boy was the replacement?

Like the saying goes, be careful what you wish for.
 

Beast_from_East

Well-Known Member
Messages
30,072
Reaction score
27,164
As I asked everyone here 2 hours ago, why all of a sudden has the bar been lowered? Booger was fuming after the SF game, and I swear he made statements several times after to the effect of having to get deep into the playoffs....almost everyone here before the season started was saying that Corky had to win at least 2 post season games and/or reach the NFCCG to keep his job. So now he can lose in ROUND ONE and keep his job just because he won 12 games and reached the post season 2 years in a row??? What if we lose looking like crap Monday night in a loss??? You do know they we all get exactly what we deserve supporting all this gross incompetence, right? So once again not to bury the lead.....why has the freakin' bar been lowered between the SF game and now?????
Not that I necessarily agree with the opinion to keep Fat Mike, but I think these are the best arguments to keeping him.

A. He kept the season alive after losing his starting QB for 1/3 of the season. Most teams go in the tank if that happens, look at the Titans when Tanny kept going down and missing games all season, they lost practically every game with their backup Qbs.

B. He did post back-to-back 12-win seasons and thus made the playoffs two years in a row, something that has not happened around here in like forever. Jason Garrett was here a dam decade and NEVER made the playoffs or posted double digit wins in back-to-back seasons.

C. For the most part, the team was competitive in almost every game, the last game being the exception, and the team never lost back-to-back games during the entire season.

D. We also have to keep it real and that means discussing the players. Its hard to put all the blame on the head coach when the starting QB cant go a single dam game without throwing a pick. Dak finished the season with 15 INTs which was tied for most in the entire NFL, and keep in mind Dak missed almost 1/3 of the season. Think about that, your starting QB misses that much playing time and still tied for the league lead in picks. That is hard to do, you literally do have to throw at least 1-2 picks per game to accomplish this feat. Dak also lead the league in pick 6s as well. Like I said, I am not a Dak hater or anything but you got to keep it real and the numbers dont lie, they are what they are.

So, I can see an argument to be made that Fat Mike should be given another season considering all of this, even if he loses to Tampa. Not necessarily the decision I would make, but I can at least logically see how somebody would come to the conclusion that he deserves another year.
 

Kwyn

Well-Known Member
Messages
5,923
Reaction score
7,258
I have listed to a lot of owners and GM over the years who have praised the coaching staff and fired them after the season ended. No owner or GM will say they have no faith in their coaches until they fire them. I for one do not think McCarthy will be fired and do not think he is on the hot seat. Next season maybe so but not after having back to back winning season which this team has failed to do since in the 90's
Jerry may have been watching Bears sleeper agent Lovie Smith in his final game go for two to sink the Texans chance of getting first overall.

Texans had told Lovie he was getting fired.

Lovie said “Hold by beer”.
 

Cowboys5217

Well-Known Member
Messages
6,389
Reaction score
11,687
The problem I have with the Jones' boys is this. You have to give up SOMETHING to be a great franchise. If you're not going to give up power and be the unsuccessful GM for over 30 something years, at least give up football power with the Coach. Allow him to do everything he likes. All the things you've done up until this point isn't working, so try something new.
Jerry can't take being wrong no matter what. We can't even get him to close the curtains for his own team's benefit because it would mean admitting he made a mistake.
 
Top