SouthernOregonStud
Member
- Messages
- 94
- Reaction score
- 59
It amazes me people know, not think, but know AP is still a great RB. It is simply too big of a risk to trade a 1st for AP. I would be willing to part with a premium pick if he was playing for cheap. 4 million/yr? Of course. Trade a 4th for AP and pay him 8-10m/yr? I would do that as well. I'm not willing to do both. Trading a 1st and paying him 8-10m with a boatload of guaranteed money is not smart. It's going to cost your 1st rd pick and quite possibly eliminate Hardy as a re-sign candidate right now. So now you're losing 5 years of cheap control for the draft pick, and any flexibility to re-sign a top 5 26 year old de.
If anyone could guarantee that the Cowboys will win the SB if they trade for AP of course every fan would take it. It's not as simple as that and never will be. What if Romo gets hurt again early in the season? Well now you've traded away a likely to be really high 1st rd pick, have another year older AP and lose Hardy. There's to many variables to take this gamble. I will always be partial to trying to maximize the ability to win now, but without affecting the ability to win later.
/Flame Away
"Eliminate Hardy As A Re-Sign Candidate?" Since we don't even know how many games he will be playing this year & that Hardy's on a pay per game contract, we are essentially renting him this year. Plus, he made certain that there was no "Franchise Tag" in his contract, all of that adds up to Hardy commanding a very large, long term contract, after this season. I'd say the chances & the money he commands will be beyond what we will be able to or will be willing to pay him to lock him up long term. As far as Peterson goes everyone does makes great points. Sure, no one can definitely predict anything. However, if you look at the Cowboys success in the past (And The past is about the best predictor there is) each Super Bowl run that the Cowboys made had some key components for their success! They had the following: A better than good Quarterback-CHECK, a better than good to outstanding receiving corps-CHECK, a dominant to unreal Offensive Line-DOUBLE CHECK, a better than average defence with a Pass Rush-I do "Think & Hope So As We Addressed This-CHECK" & A better than average, majority of the carries, type Running Back-?????
As a Fan, I can be okay with wondering what our Defence will be because we addressed it, even if we don't know yet but I'm not comfortable with our Running Back situation, because losing Murray & signing DMC is not addressing it, at least I hope not. Simply put when you sign McFadden & look at what he did over the course of his career, lined up with AP's career, both didn't have great offensive lines & maybe that's not a fair comparison but as far as feeling comfortable just because we have a phenomenal Offensive Line, I don't. The past Super Bowl Cowboy's teams had a great to dominant RB, that's always been one of the past, main-stay parts of The Dallas Cowboys identity. A, RBBC may work for other teams who have won the Super Bowl & I understand that AP will command money even if he re-works a deal to come here, that's why I said I'd be ok with another proven RB. One that can take the majority of the snaps in the run game & is better than average behind this line! Maybe after cuts there will be someone out there, I do hope so, but as the Romo window closes I'd feel a lot more comfortable to go with all these great pieces we got & I'd sure be looking even more forward to the season starting than I am with what amounts to the following logic: "Let's take DMC, name him our starter, THEN, thrown Randle, Dunbar & Williams into a Yatzee Cup, give it a real good shake & see what rolls out, crossing our fingers for a Yatzee!" I'm Just Saying That Makes Me Uncomfortable then again it's just this man's HO as I want what we all want.
GO COWBOYS!