I can see the argument for Dak over Hurts. Hurts had a better year, but has far more talent around him, but the problem is that is still the case. The big problem is take QB out of it, can you name a position group on offense where the Cowboys are better than the 49ers or Eagles, because I can’t? The one advantage is I think both the Cowboys and 49ers are better defensively than the Eagles (and my hot take both were far better last year as well).
Good post. And you may be right. But if you have the edge at QB that can be the deciding factor. That's what happened to Mahomes and Hurts in the SB. Some would argue that Hurts outplayed Mahomes but I mean he gave up a fumble for 6. That's the difference in the game.
As far as position groups....it's widely regarded that the Cowboys have one of the best secondaries in the league now with Gilmore. If Gilmore is as good as he was last year or a little worse I'd say our secondary is better than Eagles and 49ers.
I don't know man things are just different now that the Cowboys added Cooks and Gilmore.
For instance Devonta and AJ are better than Cooks and Lamb. But if its Cooks/Lamb and Gallup vs Devonta/AJ.....Quez?
For sure have the worst tight ends between both teams. I mean it's not even fair there lol. Probably can argue we got worse technically.
RB....I honestly think right now Pollard is a better running back than anyone on both teams but McCaffery is a better player and Eagles have a lot of injured backs that if they end up healthy could be a explosive bunch. That one is tough...I'd say though Cowboys have the worst group.
Offensive line....both teams have better lines than the Cowboys.
Defensive line....49ers are better. I don't know how to feel about the Eagles...I think as of now we might be better until Jalen and Davis prove it.
Rambling but to answer your question Cowboys have a better secondary than both teams. Wide receiver group is debatable but maybe give the edge there if Gallup is back to normal. Might be about it.
But it's not much of an edge. Cowboys are close enough to where they need Dak to elevate his game and make up for the difference in talent.