I have read the entire thread up to this point. It is funny how a supportive viewpoint for Jerry Jones has been introduced as the thread progressed. Reality did not change as a circumstance of literally spinning him.
The NFL is a sports-based business. Plain and simple. Professional football is not an atypical facet of business. It is not an exception as far as successfully conducting business. Successful businesses are run by knowledgeable managers. General managers in the case of football.
In business, what generally happens to managers when goals are not met? Answer. They are fired. They voluntarily step down. Some are even promoted but the underperforming position is filled by another (hopefully) qualified replacement in that instance and every other instance. Timely replacing general managers does not happen all the time in the league but it happens enough that it is a commonplace practice.
In sports, success is not measured in sub .500 seasons. Success is not gained by finishing .500 (which is pretty dang hard to do now with 17-game regular seasons, lol). Success is partially recognized by reaching the postseason but only partly so. True success is attained by competing for and/or winning championships.
At minimum, 'competing for' means playing in a league conference championship game. At maximum, 'competing for' means ending up as the league runner-up. Winning championships is self-explanatory.
Super Bowl XXX was held January 28, 1996. 1996. It is 2024. From the 1996 regular season forward, the Dallas Cowboys general manager has never helped construct a single team, during any particular season, that has competed for or won a league championship.
Jerry Jones should have replaced himself as GM years ago. In my opinion, he should have taken such self-action no later than the end of the 2002 season. Why? Because the teams he fielded, 1996 through 2002, never progressed beyond the wildcard round. Barely finished above .500 once. Finished .500 once. Finished below .500 four times--three times under .500 consecutively. These GM results should have gotten anyone
FIRED!
For almost 30 years, the franchise's main issue has been a business man--an accomplished business man at that despite any criticism--refusing to take a simple, common business action. An action, which may have produced lesser results than those actually seen over this period. An action, which could have produced similar results over this period. An action, which might have ended up with better results over this period. An action, never taken, never tested, because the business man pulling that fantasy trigger is a
narcissist.
This sad, decades long, underachievement, is underscored by a single, undeniable fact. Jerry Jones would have lost nothing by acting like a business man and stepping down as GM. He would have lost zero money. He would have lost zero fame. He would have lost zero self-dignity. In fact, the probability is high that he would have made more money, gained more fame as an owner, and built more self-dignity that observers would have seen in him if he had.
Winning solves all problems. Jerry Jones is a self-made obstacle for winning by not allowing others to make football operational decisions for him. And that is a summation of how much or how little he cares about winning.
/rant
Edit: added 'conference'