Most of the time I have argued about wrong or lazy routes, horrible scheme, etc etc. The inconsistency is likely tied to the scheme and lack of attention to detail. The better defenses tend to expose the horrible and predictable scheme, accentuate the lack of detail, and expose the lack of threats.
Some on Dak but a lot on the rest of what I just stated.
Having said that, Dak had a big portion of the blame for SF but it is rooted in the things i just listed.
But is it? I don't deny there are probably some scheme issues.
But it wasn't scheme that caused some of those dreadful interceptions in the San Fran game. It wasn't all scheme that he looked totally inept against Washington. When he threw a pick 6 in the Eagles game (where he played mostly great), that wasn't scheme. It was a dumb pass. Scheme/talent didn't have him miss open WRs in the San Fran game.
The reality is that even with scheme and talent deficiencies, Dak just isn't consistent enough. He certainly wasn't this season. Can he get more consistent? I honestly don't know. He's a 7 year vet in this league, there is a good chance he is what he is.
But since he's here due to his contract, I am all for trying to just give him a fresh start with a new OC. I just am not sure that somehow changes the trajectory for him. I think he's forever stuck in the mud as a decent QB. Good enough to win some games, not good enough to actually take a team to a SB. But at this point if Jerry wants to salvage this, unless he has a trade in mind, his only other option is get a new offensive scheme in here for Dak.