Mad Dog - "You can't tell me he (Prescott) is a Top 10 QB". Booger McFarland disagrees

[KJJ]

Well, Hill is not a real QB, so no, I'll take Dak.

I was just pointing out that the New Orleans game isn't a game that I would consider a "hey look how well Dak played in this one" type of game the way the Tampa and New England was.

You act like Dak isn’t a real QB.

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

Draft status is thrown out the window once you have the rookie campaign Dak did.

I'm not a dak homer. I am able to critique his flaws...like almost every single human being has. I also believe Romo should have come in since he was obviously fully healthy.

But ...I give him (dak) credit for running that bus pretty nicely. For a mid round rook from a school that never really played huge do or die national games.

See...there's a compliment!

 

[SteveTheCowboy]

Oh so now im dense.... because stats are only supposed to work when you want them too huh.... ok cool. Yep I'll be dense then. Well you already know what I think of you because I've made that clear a few times already.

And again you miss the point. YOU...are the kind of person that actually DOES "use stats to work when you want them to".

Context is extremely important. I don't like our NFC East record...which some people actually BRAG about.....once a lethal feared division but it's been pretty weak in recent years.

We "own" the division but only won one playoff game in six years? The whole division sucks!

Not sure I really care what you think because you are the kind of guy that threatens to come beat up people when they get chippy with you...on an internet forum message board. That says all we need to know.

 

[PAPPYDOG]

You act like Dak isn’t a real QB.

He isn't an Imposter QB would be more on target........
A lucky guy(666) who had 2 QB fall down for him to start and had around him primo talent from Dez to rook Zeke and offline from heaven.
In the end, what did he do with all that talent.........1 playoff win!
Enough said.....

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

You act like Dak isn’t a real QB.

He's a real QB.

I just don't think he's a top 10 QB.

 

[erod]

You must have missed the opener against Tampa last season. New England finished second in total defense and New Orleans finished fourth.

The first game of the season? Really?

Did you see the New Orleans game? Our passing game was atrocious.

New England was average. Nothing special about that defense at all.

 

[Pass2Run]

I'm not a dak homer. I am able to critique his flaws...like almost every single human being has. I also believe Romo should have come in since he was obviously fully healthy.

But ...I give him (dak) credit for running that bus pretty nicely. For a mid round rook from a school that never really played huge do or die national games.

See...there's a compliment!

Same here.

I'm also not a Dak homer. I was Super down on him after the playoff loss. In some ways, I still kind of am. But when I talk, I like to know what I'm talking about. So I realize people will argue whether he's a top 10 quarterback, and that's all fine and dandy.

But anyone arguing within the parameters of realistic premises should come to the conclusion that he is.

If they argue he is not, I deduce they are simply trolling. Or their opinion is skewed by some other aspect outside of facts.

The real question is, can Dak win the biggest games that matter?

That depends on 52 other players.

It was the same issue with Romo. Both Dak and Romo were top 5-7 QBs in the league during their times. They have just never been able to bring home the trophy.

 

[KJJ]

He isn't an Imposter QB would be more on target........
A lucky guy(666) who had 2 QB fall down for him to start and had around him primo talent from Dez to rook Zeke and offline from heaven.
In the end, what did he do with all that talent.........1 playoff win!
Enough said.....

Romo had 2 playoff wins in 10 years. Our QB isn’t the problem!

 

[KJJ]

He's a real QB.

I just don't think he's a top 10 QB.

You act like he’s not a top 20 QB. Go look at some of the names of QBs you’ve mentioned to replace him. Lol

 

[Pass2Run]

Romo had 2 playoff wins in 10 years. Our QB isn’t the problem!

I think that's right.

If you look at the San Fran game. It was the offensive and defensive lines.

In the cap era, we've built teams that can win in the division. But our overall team strength has never held up in the playoffs.

I think this comes down to two things: physicality and mentality.

Since the 90s, we never had the best QB or the most talented team. We had the most physical team with the toughest mentality.

 

[KJJ]

The first game of the season? Really?

Did you see the New Orleans game? Our passing game was atrocious.

New England was average. Nothing special about that defense at all.

I watched the New Orleans game and their passing game was atrocious. New England’s defense finished number two overall last season.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

You act like he’s not a top 20 QB. Go look at some of the names of QBs you’ve mentioned to replace him. Lol

You will not find a single post where I've listed 20 QBs that I would take over him.

14 or 15 maybe, but not 20.

 

[KJJ]

You will not find a single post where I've listed 20 QBs that I would take over him.

14 or 15 maybe, but not 20.

Some of the QBs you’ve mentioned to replace him are average QBs at best. Some would be ranked 20 or higher.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Some of the QBs you’ve mentioned to replace him are average QBs at best. Some would be ranked 20 or higher. I would look them up but you won’t allow people to review your posting history. Lol

Like who?

 

[KJJ]

Like who?

I would point them all out but you won’t allow anyone to review your profile page/posting history. lol

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

I would point them all out but you won’t allow anyone to review your posting history. lol

I feel like that's a cop out. You're either getting me confused with someone else or you're making this up.

I consistently have Dak ranked around 12-13 whenever I rank QBs.

There are young guys I have ranked behind him that are not currently better than him that I would take over him on potential alone though as I feel in a year or so they will easily be better than him.

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

LOL.

You really are obtuse. Your story changes from one post to the next. You are literally making my argument for me with the bolded text above.

Have a good weekend kiddo.

So you can’t answer a simple question lol….you meddled into me and another persons debate just to bail out when you’ve been proven silly. Happens like clockwork….

 

[TheMarathonContinues]

I'm not a dak homer. I am able to critique his flaws...like almost every single human being has. I also believe Romo should have come in since he was obviously fully healthy.

But ...I give him (dak) credit for running that bus pretty nicely. For a mid round rook from a school that never really played huge do or die national games.

See...there's a compliment!

I believe the team saw Romo and Dak in practice and determined Dak was the better fit.

 

[KJJ]

I feel like that's a cop out. You're either getting me confused with someone else or you're making this up.

I consistently have Dak ranked around 12-13 whenever I rank QBs.

There are young guys I have ranked behind him that are not currently better than him that I would take over him on potential alone though as I feel in a year or so they will easily be better than him.

It’s not a cop out you won’t allow anyone to view your profile page and research your posts. If you have Dak ranked 12-13 why do you bash him every day? I can assure you you’ve mentioned QBs to replace him that are ranked in the top 20. You’ve mentioned castoffs that no other fan base would want.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

It’s not a cop out you won’t allow anyone to view your profile page and research your posts. If you have Dak ranked 12-13 why do you bash him every day? I can assure you you’ve mentioned QBs to replace him that are ranked in the top 20. You’ve mentioned castoffs that no other fan base would want.

I don't believe 12-13 are that great of QBs. They're just kinda okay.

There's not a lot of truly great QBs in the NFL (Allen, Burrow, Stafford, Herbert) and even less actual elite QBs (Rodgers, Brady, and Mahomes is it for me)

Once you get past the top 7 or 8 QBs then you're replaceable to me.