Mad Dog - "You can't tell me he (Prescott) is a Top 10 QB". Booger McFarland disagrees

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
Are you implying that because the Cowboys are 1-3 with Dak in the playoffs that he is more talented and skilled than Herbert because the Chargers are 0-0 in the playoffs with him?

I'm implying that the criteria used to criticize Dak , (big moments) should apply to all, winning a playoff game has always been the criteria for Dak.
Has Herbert lead his team to a playoff win?
 

Doomsday101

Well-Known Member
Messages
107,762
Reaction score
39,034
Yup. And its now used to aid in peoples agenda of judging a QB. QB throws for 450 yards 5 touchdowns and loses and the loss goes on him? How? lol

You get right down to it I want wins, QB can throw for 200 yards or 400 yards I don't care, sure looks great on a stat sheet but at the end of the game it is winning that counts. What is aggravating is watching a team beat themselves with foolish penalties and careless play. Often the difference in winning and losing is the team who can play sound fundamental football and not make the critical mistakes.
 

MountaineerCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,491
Reaction score
62,740
I'm implying that the criteria used to criticize Dak , (big moments) should apply to all, winning a playoff game has always been the criteria for Dak.
Has Herbert lead his team to a playoff win?
I think if you use W/L as a player stat then you instantly discredit yourself.
 

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
I think if you use W/L as a player stat then you instantly discredit yourself.

Lol that 90% of the Dak critics...lol
Individual stay wise, he's up with some of the best. The playoff wins beating winning teams are the Dak hater calling card.
 

MountaineerCowboy

Well-Known Member
Messages
26,491
Reaction score
62,740
Lol that 90% of the Dak critics...lol
Individual stay wise, he's up with some of the best. The playoff wins beating winning teams are the Dak hater calling card.
I think it's fair to critique how a player contributes to a win or a loss, but to give them sole credit for it invalidates their opinions as far as I'm concerned.
 

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,230
Reaction score
3,584
He's following me. He's mad

I hit a nerve

wfTWL40.png


Nope. I exposed your fraudulent claims that you have no answers to. I also exposed you as a person afraid to answer clear cut questions because it would make you look dumber than you already look.

Ok I'm going to give you a chance to answer atleast one of my questions in front of the whole board to prove you're actually intelligent. Again, im going to give you the benefit of the doubt.

You said Dak only throws 5 yard passes correct?? Well can you explain why Dak is in the top tier of quarterbacks that have completed downfield passes of 20+ yards??

This goes against your logic, so can you tell us why you are lying or can you clear up why what you have typed doesn't make sense?? I have faith that you will answer this and explain yourself. I have faith that you won't run from this question too. The board is watching!!
 

GINeric

Well-Known Member
Messages
4,230
Reaction score
3,584
Guess who's going to be watching Dak take snaps as a starter for the Dallas Cowboys.

@MountaineerCowboy
@acr731
@PAPPYDOG
@TwentyOne
@DeaconMoss
@Risen Star

.Yes, the whole circle of hate will be watching Dak this year. You know why? Because nothing they say can stop Dak from being our starter. So if they want to get their blood pressure up watching a guy they don't like...let them. They'll be the ones needing medication sooner or later.


I can't speak for all of them that you've listed, but i definitely I respect @MountaineerCowboy because he atleast answer questions or explain his stance on Dak whether we agree or disagree. He atleast has the balls to face the questions, he's definitely not a coward in my book.

Now you have one or two trolls here that make baseless claims against Dak, but run from fact filled questions that they can't answer about Dak. That's what you call cowardly behavior.
 

morat1959

Well-Known Member
Messages
7,585
Reaction score
7,979
Really? Because earlier there was a thread PRAISING Romo for all of his GWD and 4th quarter comebacks. Even though half the time they were behind because he threw 4 picks. lol.

And I am sorry if you start the whole garbage time argument I am out. If you bring a game to within 3 points after being down by 20 plus points. The other team isnt playing prevent. You are picking them apart. No coach in the world is going to let his team give up 20 plus points "to make it a game".
What did Romo and what has Dak ever won? I’ll wait.
 

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
I think it's fair to critique how a player contributes to a win or a loss, but to give them sole credit for it invalidates their opinions as far as I'm concerned.

Which is why the best way to get a true measure of what an individual player is doing is using stats, which sometimes are Flawed.
 

mrmojo

Well-Known Member
Messages
9,744
Reaction score
9,425
Mad Dog haha .....surprised he didn't go on a rant saying none of these QBs can hold Johnny Unitas or Otto Grahams jock.....
 
  • Like
Reactions: G2

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
I 100 percent agree my dude. I feel like GWD should be a team stat. Unless that entire drive is on the arm of the QB. But i feel like that’s taking away from the WR. Remember that circus catch Dak made to put us into OT against the eagles daks rookie year? It’s mind boggling the lengths “stats” people will go to. To the point of creating a statistic for one player on a 53 man roster lol

All true, but there are Advanced stats and measurements that can be used. Just as the throw Dak made to Beasley to beat the Giants, both had a part in that. That run vs Seattle in the playoff game . But nobody takes that play away from Rodgers in 16 against us, nobody says anything about the catch the TE has to make along the sideline. It's what ever agenda folks have that day
 

Dre11

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,686
Reaction score
11,450
I don't know this, but maybe you do...

If a team gets a late pick 6, fumble return, special teams play, or whatever to take the lead in a game, and nothing else happens except the defense stopping the opposing team from getting the lead back..... does the QB then get credit for a GWD, 4th Quarter comeback, and win? Even though the last time they were even on the filed their team was losing?

What if the last time he was on the field they were winning or tied and the defense, special teams gives up the lead is that on the Qb.
 
Top