I have Madden on PS4 and would say it is the best version in years. Franchise (Select Coaching Mode) unless you want to worry about concession prices, advertising, etc. Turned off pre-existing injuries after initially starting with them included but hated not having Lee and Lawrence on the squad. Position changes are still not allowed outside of the player's primary position. No CB to FS, no OLB to RE, etc. That frustrates me but have learned to manage. Have Crawford as my starting NT, with Spencer/Lawrence on the edges. I have the DE sub rate up so Selvie is rotated in frequently. The gameplan prep can become a bit tedious after tinkering with it only for the preseason (simmed) and first 3 games. Traded M.Johnson/Heath to the Skins for a 4th
SF ran all day on me, but didn't seem to matter whether McClain/Okoye were in there for run support so went with the better pass rush in Crawford. (You can specifically sub in McClain as the NT in specific 4-3/3-4/46/4-4 alignments).
Gameplay: Much improved. Still see the flailing animations at times but have cleaned that up. Gang tackling feels more natural. The CPU secondary is supped up in All Madden so no more easy posts/seams down the slot. You can still throw them but must be timed more precisely. Presentation is improved in that they display relevant statistics during the game and the overall atmosphere in the stadiums is much improved as well. Murray/Dez are monsters and Romo is good but does fumble alot when taking sacks. Pass protection is give and take...most sacks have been on me for holding the ball too long. Melton/Spencer are the best pass rushers on the team by far.
9/10 esp considering previous versions.
