Hutchinson was just an ex-baseball player with a strong arm. Nothing more. Don't even see why it was a debate!
More on the topic...
At the time I couldn't take Quincy seriously. In retrospect he was better than I would have said at the time. His tongue-too-big-for-his-mouth way of speaking was just too embarrasing for a Cowboys QB.
Hutchinson was almost as dumb looking/sounding.
Either Quincy or Hutchinson would give Eli a run for his money as the all-time dumbest looking QBs to have played an NFL game. Eli stills wins but it's close.
When they got Drew Henson, I thought he "looked" like a real QB. I even found and watched World League games that he was playing. I kept waiting for it to click for him, but it just didn't.
When Romo was 1 of 4 QBs, my Girlfriend said "That Romo Guy has "it". He'll be the next QB for the Cowboys". She is a Green Bay fan and rarely watches preseason football and does not obsess about the details.
I guess not knowing the background or expectations of the 4 QBs made it easier to see that Romo was indeed "The Man".