McCarthy gives his Top 5 QB list

[Yobwocs]

lmao

 

[DallasEast]

Well. Andy Reid's not inviting him to his next cookout.

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

lmao

Do you believe Dak is a top 10 QB All Time?

 

[gimmesix]

lmao

It's so weird to see Daniel Jones' name on any of these lists.

 

[Kwyn]

Do you believe Dak is a top 10 QB All Time?

Of course not. Is that being suggested?

 

[Wangchung83]

No mahomes shows how biased this list

 

[shabazz]

Well. Andy Reid's not inviting him to his next cookout.

It would take another side of beef if both attended

 

[NotaCowboysFan]

I know it's a funny list but it's based off right now, who's playing the best. Not who you think the best QBs are in the league.

 

[blueblood70]

It's so weird to see Daniel Jones' name on any of these lists.

Well what's more weird the three of those guys on that list have changed teams that changed the narrative on their careers?

Seems to be having a lot more and realize that teams aren't developing players not just quarterbacks but they give up on players too soon..

I mean he was on a playoff team with the Giants a couple years back He just wasn't playing at this level but It is what it is we'll see at the end of the year 'cause these lists don't matter right now.

the NFL has a way of balancing these things out after seventeen games...

 

[MarionBarberThe4th]

I know it's a funny list but it's based off right now, who's playing the best. Not who you think the best QBs are in the league.

Football would be more fun if we could see more of this variance . And less “lol that qb sucks “

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Of course not. Is that being suggested?

Yes

About right..... everyone except Brou (lifelong Dak hater) is saying it's Mayfield, Allen, and Dak for MVP.

And Mahomes is obviously in the Top 4 (first tier) because of his past. I get that, and I'm ok with it..... but I think Dak is easily a Top 4 Quarterback. All time? He's about Top 8. In certain years (2016, 2020, 2023, and 2025) he's Top 5.

 

[John813]

I mean, the top 5 seem fine for games played to date in 2025

 

[Chasing6]

Well what's more weird the three of those guys on that list have changed teams that changed the narrative on their careers?

Seems to be having a lot more and realize that teams aren't developing players not just quarterbacks but they give up on players too soon..

I mean he was on a playoff team with the Giants a couple years back He just wasn't playing at this level but It is what it is we'll see at the end of the year 'cause these lists don't matter right now.

the NFL has a way of balancing these things out after seventeen games...

QB's are dependent on the talent around them. It is not the other way around.

QB's do not carry teams.

 

[Yobwocs]

Yes

Top 8 of any given year.... I think you read too much into it, dude. Or you can't..... read....

 

[MountaineerCowboy]

Top 8 of any given year.... I think you read too much into it, dude. Or you can't..... read....

Top 8 All time and Top 8 any given year is wildly different.

 

[shabazz]

What an incredibly dumb and uneducated take.

QBs can both carry a team and torpedo a team......its been happening since the beginning of football

 

[Cowboysheelsreds053]

It would take another side of beef if both attended

LLLOOOLLL

 

[America's Cowboy]

I know it's a funny list but it's based off right now, who's playing the best. Not who you think the best QBs are in the league.

True, but even with this list, McCarthy got it wrong. Dak is clearly playing the best at QB so far these first 5 weeks.

 

[WillieBeamen]

It's so weird to see Daniel Jones' name on any of these lists.

Dak too

 

[Mikexike]

lmao

Based on play this year, that seems pretty close to accurate.