McCarthy Says Dez Didn’t Catch It?

[khiladi]

So your answer is CONSPIRACY! like the rest who can't debate these rules with me. Got it. At least the others here had the dignity to slither away hoping to not be detected.

I actually stated backtracking by the NFL and provided clear evidence for it, including the Jesse Jones catch that caused them to flip once again in 2018, and here you are puffing your chest that you won an argument and yet, still haven’t provided a single evidence of what constitutes proper.

Poor baby.. If they ruled it a catch, how could you ride the anti-Romo train anymore..

 

[MarcusRock]

I actually stated backtracking by the NFL and provided clear evidence for it, including the Jesse Jones catch that caused them to flip once again in 2018, and here you are puffing your chest that you won an argument and yet, still haven’t provided a single evidence of what constitutes proper.

Poor baby.. If they ruled it a catch, how could you not ride the anti-Romo anymore..

I answered everything while you refused to answer the yes/no question that blows your case out of the water 8 times. Yeah buddy, I won the argument just like I do with every other catch theorist who refuses to answer things. I sent you the link to "proper" and you ignored it. Just like my question. Here it is again:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-netwo...00457361/Dean-Blandino-reviews-Bryant-s-catch
"This is a good illustration of a football move where he gathers himself and now he's gonna lunge. It's clear, it's obvious. He's reaching that ball, extending it, versus just going to the ground with his momentum."

 

[khiladi]

I answered everything while you refused to answer the yes/no question that blows your case out of the water 8 times. Yeah buddy, I won the argument just like I do with every other catch theorist who refuses to answer things. I sent you the link to "proper" and you ignored it. Just like my question. Here it is again:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-netwo...00457361/Dean-Blandino-reviews-Bryant-s-catch
"This is a good illustration of a football move where he gathers himself and now he's gonna lunge. It's clear, it's obvious. He's reaching that ball, extending it, versus just going to the ground with his momentum."

Kerp puffing your chest, you still taking the L. Ask more times, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. The amount of times still makes it irrelevant. Basic logic tells you a SET can included multiple possibilities.

The issue is does the DIVE and REACH count as him being a runner. If he was just going to the ground, Dez would have stopped at the five yard line. But he was trying to DIVE and REACH to cross the plane. Blandino is fibbing, like you are looking for excuses, adding teens like didn’t execute properly.. or he was tripped..

L must b your favorite letter in the alphabet..

 

[MarcusRock]

Kerp puffing your chest, you still taking the L. Ask more times, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12. The amount of times still makes it irrelevant. Basic logic tells you a SET can included multiple possibilities.

The is not going to the ground with momentum, the issue is does the DIVE and REACH count as him being a runner. If he was just going to the ground, Dez would have stopped at the five yard line. But he was trying to DIVE and REACH to cross the plane.

Watch the video and then explain how the explanation is wrong then. Or just keep yelling the lazy CONSPIRACY! victim anthem like the rest after you refused to answer a question 8 times.

 

[OmerV]

No, it was actually ruled a catch and then over-turner and yes, I am accusing Blandino of robbing the Cowboys. Just like I’m accusing you of not even reading my posts, while inserting yourself into a conversation asking questions that my previous posts already addressed.

And the official call was without the benefit of replay, and the point of replay is to take another look in slow motion and with the available angles. Accordingly, replay worked as it was designed with the officials taking a look and making the call they felt was correct.

 

[khiladi]

Watch the video and then explain how the explanation is wrong then. Or just keep yelling the lazy CONSPIRACY! victim anthem like the rest.

I already explained it to you. If Dez was going to the ground with his momentum, he would have landed 3-4 yards back. But guess why we are here at this position:

Dez committed and ACT common to the game, which was land and try and dive and try and reach for the plane.

Where does the NFL define proper homie?

Like I said, your favorite letter in the alphabet this past week had been L. We all know you ‘lucked’ out that day, otherwise how it would have hurt for you to see Romo win that game,,

 

[khiladi]

And the official call was without the benefit of replay, and the point of replay is to take another look in slow motion and with the available angles. Accordingly, replay worked as it was designed with the officials taking a look and making the call they felt was correct.

Yes, we know that, which is why we are discussing slow motion and the clear evidence Dez dived and reached after coming down to try and cross the plane, even though he came down like at the four.

And yet, here you are still not having read my posts in this thread repeating the same things over and over again, the I already stated before you entered in this conversation.

 

[MarcusRock]

and try and dive and try and reach for the plane.

Tried and failed. Like the video said and after refusing to answer my question 8 times which was supported by said video.

 

[khiladi]

Tried and failed. Like the video said and after refusing to answer my question 8 times which was supported by said video.

so he dived and reached but failed in diving and teaching... because, let me guess, it was not ‘proper’, it was because he was tripped and so on.

You just know, deep down on your heart, that “your boy” Romo threw a beautiful pass and Dez caught it and we were robbed, just like the Steelers were robbed against the Patriots in 2017, causing the NFL to backtrack once again.

Eight times simply shows you have a strong resolve in repeating yourself, not whether or not you can ask relevant questions.

 

[OmerV]

Yes, we know that, which is why we are discussing slow motion and the clear evidence Dez dived and reached after coming down to try and cross the plane, even though he came down like at the four.

And yet, here you are still not having read my posts in this thread repeating the same things over and over again, the I already stated before you entered in this conversation.

I've read way more of your posts than I should have, and I looked at the video Blandino provided that you claim proves your point, and I disagree with you. Again, it's you and Pereira saying the reach qualifies, and me and the game officials and Blandino saying it doesn't.

You really seem to be hanging hard on the notion that it is an undisputable fact that what you are Pereira say somehow overrides all others, but you don't get to make that choice for the NFL and all people. It simply comes down to you having your belief and I having mine, and Blandino and Pereira and the game officials having theirs.

 

[MarcusRock]

so he dived and reached but failed in diving and teaching... because, let me guess, it was not ‘proper’, it was because he was tripped and so on.

You just know, deep down on your heart, that “your boy” Romo threw a beautiful pass and Dez caught it and we were robbed, just like the Steelers were robbed against the Patriots in 2017, causing the NFL to backtrack once again.

Eight times simply shows you have a strong resolve in repeating yourself, not whether or not you can ask relevant questions.

Use shorthand next time: CONSPIRACY!

 

[OmerV]

Use shorthand next time: CONSPIRACY!

You know Blandino was the guy on the grassy knoll.

I wonder how he would feel about it had Dez lost the footfall when he started to reach and the Packers recovered it. I'm guessing he would be adamant that it wasn't a catch.

 

[khiladi]

I've read way more of your posts than I should have, and I looked at the video Blandino provided that you claim proves your point, and I disagree with you. Again, it's you and Pereira saying the reach qualifies, and me and the game officials and Blandino saying it doesn't.

You really seem to be hanging hard on the notion that it is an undisputable fact that what you are Pereira say somehow overrides all others, but you don't get to make that choice for the NFL and all people. It simply comes down to you having your belief and I having mine, and Blandino and Pereira and the game officials having theirs.

so you finally watched it and you admit they contradicted each other.

 

[Aviano90]

Tried and failed. Like the video said and after refusing to answer my question 8 times which was supported by said video.

He never answers a question in any debate.

 

[OmerV]

so you finally watched it and you admit they contradicted each other.

I didn’t say that.

 

[khiladi]

I didn’t say that.

Yes, you did... you said Pereira said it..

 

[OmerV]

Yes, you did... you said Pereira said it..

Quote the sentence

 

[OmerV]

Yes, you did... you said Pereira said it..

Are you talking about Pareira and Blandino contradicting each other? If so, I’ve never said otherwise.

 

[khiladi]

Quote the sentence

So you haven’t watched the Pereira videos than, but you admit:

Again, it's you and Pereira saying the reach qualifies, and me and the game officials and Blandino saying it doesn't.

You really seem to be hanging hard on the notion that it is an undisputable fact that what you are Pereira say somehow overrides all others, but you don't get to make that choice for the NFL and all people. It simply comes down to you having your belief and I having mine, and Blandino and Pereira and the game officials having theirs.

So that means you actually didn’t read my posts then where I referenced Pereira flip flopping over the years. And you also ignored once how the NFL hosed the Steelers and Jesse Jones on the catch in 2017.

So basically you are commenting when you haven’t even understood what my contention was, meaning you have no idea what you are talking about.

 

[OmerV]

So you haven’t watched the Pereira videos than, but you admit the following. So that means you didn’t read my posts then where I referenced Pereira flip flopping over the years. And you also ignored once how the NFL hosed the Steelers and Jesse Jones on the catch in 2017..

I’ve never made an issue out of Pareira flip flopping, so you aren’t making a point at all. I’ve only said my belief aligns with Blandino’s belief.