McNabb's Injuries: Implications

Rogerthat12

DWAREZ
Messages
14,605
Reaction score
9,989
http://www.philadelphiaeagles.com/homeNewsDetail.jsp?id=35640

McNabb is currently nursing three seperate injuries: chest and shin contusions and an abdominal strain. If the chest contusion were not problematic enough another worry for the Eagles is centered around the "abdominal strain", which could very well be a sports hernia. If so, the sports hernia will pose problematic for his performance mobility and motion wise. Coupled with the reoccuring nature of the chest contusion Donovan may struggle or be shelved for quite awhile this season.

If he does indeed have a sports hernia and it requires surgery he could be out a substantial amount of time (at least 6-8 weeks in some cases)and without surgery his performance will be hampered by insidious groin pain. They are awaiting results but many times a sports hernia can be present without a clinically detectable hernia in traditional terms. Surgery is the preferred method of treatment and usually requires a total of 6-8 weeks before an athlete can perform again.

This injury is close to home for me as I had this very injury from heavy weight training and running three years ago. I was able to exercise after 4 weeks but still had much discomfort. Even at 8 weeks, I was still not 100% and could not engage in a physical contact sport at the time. I know these guys have the best schedules, physicians and therapies money can buy, but even 6-8 weeks could pose problematic for the Eagles without McNabb.

Reid seems to be worried about the chest contusion even more because Donovan felt soreness after the hit from Sapp on Sunday. This "reoccuring" injury will not draw the sympathy of opposing defenses and will probably put a bulls eye on Donovan IMO.

Do you think that playing the Eagles with an injured McNabb makes our meeting with them in two weeks a much better scenario? If these injuries are substantial does this soften the Eagles grip on the division and NFC in general?

No one credible desires to see an outstanding player hurt like Rodney Harrison, Spikes and a Donovan McNabb. Yet, these injuries will impact their respective teams to be sure and may open the door for the opportunities of others. Though we are unsure of the exact extent of McNabb's injuries, we do know Reid is deeply concerned over them which of consquence, could alter the complexion of the NFC in general and the NFC East in particular.

Your Thoughts??? :)
 

Rack

Federal Agent
Messages
23,906
Reaction score
3,106
Smith22 said:
Blitz Roy relentlessly when we play the Iggles. :disseags:



So we shouldn't do anything different then what we should do even if McFlabb is healthy? :D
 

NorTex

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,290
Reaction score
364
I hope the E-girls are 100% healthy when we play them.

Let's go toe to toe and see who has what.
 

HanfordDixon

Please, Call Me Shirley
Messages
306
Reaction score
37
No one credible desires to see an outstanding player hurt like Rodney Harrison, Spikes and a Donovan McNabb.

The hell I don't. I hope every damn starter is injured when we play them. So does everybody else. Cheer for injuries? You're damn right I do.
 

BIGDen

Dr. Freakasaurus
Messages
4,767
Reaction score
902
HanfordDixon said:
No one credible desires to see an outstanding player hurt like Rodney Harrison, Spikes and a Donovan McNabb.

The hell I don't. I hope every damn starter is injured when we play them. So does everybody else. Cheer for injuries? You're damn right I do.

So how do you really feel? :) I give you credit. It's not considered classy or PC to say what you said - but at least you're honest!
 

jterrell

Penguinite
Messages
33,874
Reaction score
15,971
This could seriously derail the Eagles.
Losing a starting QB is never easy but doing so for a long time is a major blow.

The NFCE has improved enough that the Eagles can no longer expect an easy 5 or 6 wins.
 

Eddie

Well-Known Member
Messages
14,094
Reaction score
5,864
HanfordDixon said:
No one credible desires to see an outstanding player hurt like Rodney Harrison, Spikes and a Donovan McNabb.

The hell I don't. I hope every damn starter is injured when we play them. So does everybody else. Cheer for injuries? You're damn right I do.


ha ha. I agree. Fork this sympathy nonsense. These are multi million dollar players. As long as these injuries aren't life threatening or permanent ... I could care less if they're all on crutches.
 

morasp

Well-Known Member
Messages
8,439
Reaction score
6,850
Last year when our starting QB got cut in training camp, Terry Glenn got injured and JJ was injured no had sympathy for us. If the Eagirls have some injuries that's part of the game. I don't hope for them but it's no reason to make excuses for them. Last week, Owens was nicked, westbrook was nicked their kicker was hurt and McNabb was hurt. Of all those I would say Westbrook is the most important to them. McNabb went out one year and Feeley filled in nincely. Owens went out last year and all they did was made it to the SB w/o him. When Westbrook went out last year they really struggled.
 

adbutcher

K9NME
Messages
12,287
Reaction score
2,910
HanfordDixon said:
No one credible desires to see an outstanding player hurt like Rodney Harrison, Spikes and a Donovan McNabb.

The hell I don't. I hope every damn starter is injured when we play them. So does everybody else. Cheer for injuries? You're damn right I do.
Pretty trashy comment. I am ashamed I had to read that from a fellow fan.
 

cowboys101

New Member
Messages
163
Reaction score
0
as long as the injury isnt career ending or hurts his life I hope he sits the whole year for all I care. Its part of the game.

No one cared when we lost are starting DB last year!
 

cwbyfan72

Well-Known Member
Messages
1,876
Reaction score
2,256
adbutcher said:
Pretty trashy comment. I am ashamed I had to read that from a fellow fan.


Well, lets be honest here shall we? When an impact player is hurting in a game, and the opposition knows this......does the opposing team let off? No. They go after him, and are taught too. Its about getting an edge anyway possible. So with that being said, I dont think anyone wishes hurt on anyone in particular, but I don't think anyone is saying "what a shame, I wish everyone is healthy when we play, so it can be that much more difficult. Oh, and by the way, the Iggs have owned us at there "best". I'll take W's anyway they come.
 

Danny White

Winter is Coming
Messages
12,497
Reaction score
391
I have a couple friends back in Philly who are Eagles fans, and they tell me the whole Eagle Nation are worried about the long-term effects of these injuries.

Now everyone knows Eagles fans are always waiting for disaster to happen to them, but in this case, their fears seem somewhat warranted.

Quite honestly, I hope McNabb keps slugging it out at less than 100%. I think if they bench him to heal him up, they'll put McMahon in and in that offense he could be dangerous. Little boy Koy doesn't scare me much, though.
 

DBoys

New Member
Messages
4,713
Reaction score
0
If McNabb is hurting what fear do we have? The game against Oakland he was struggling throwing the ball regardless of the stats. We have played the Iggles with McNabb hurt before and won.
 
Top