Name your ALL NFC EAST team

[Tio]

My point was that Tiki had one phenomenal season. He is not a better back than Portis.

Tiki has been better than portis for two straight years.

 

[superpunk]

Actually, CP had more rushing touchdowns with less carries last year than Tiki.

Shocking!

CP's role with the Skins is very different than Tiki's with the Giants. Tiki's plays were more designed for the big breaker, whereas CP gets more grind-out, tough yardage.

Pick a stat-line, homer

2,390 total yards, 5.2 ypc, 11 TDs, 16 plays of 20+ yards

1,732 total yards, 4.3 ypc, 11 TDs, 6 plays of 20+ yards

Pick one.

 

[demdcowboys#1]

12 Commanders were on that list out of the 27 players listed!!!!!

Way to much homerism there, especially with old *** Shawn Springs, I would take Henry over him anyday of the week!!!!
Here is my list!!!!!

ALL NFC EAST TEAM
QB-McNabb
RB-Tiki Barber(Portis alternate, Tiki was an MVP candidate and played lights out last season)
FB-Sellers
*Hback-Cooley
TE-Witten/Shockey
WR-TO
WR-Moss
T-Flozell Adams,Samuels
G-Andrews,Thomas
C-Rabach (he's no pro-bowler but he's the best C in the NFCE)

DE-Osi,Strahan(No replacement fo these 2, best DE's in entire division hands down)
DT-Griffin,Ferguson
OLB-Washington,Ware
ILB-Ayodele
CB-Henry, Newman (deepest position in division-Sheppard,Brown,Rogers)
SS- Roy Williams
FS-Sean Taylor

ST-Randle El
K-Vanderjagt
P-Johnson

 

[Jarv]

Actually, CP had more rushing touchdowns with less carries last year than Tiki.

Shocking!

CP's role with the Skins is very different than Tiki's with the Giants. Tiki's plays were more designed for the big breaker, whereas CP gets more grind-out, tough yardage.

Whatever dude, Tiki outrushed CP the last 2 years...Scored more TD's the last 2 years...But you want to argue that CP is better.

 

[superpunk]

BigD, I like your list, but I'm wondering why we're even listing Cooley. HB is a position few teams in the league use, and teams in the East use FB sparingly. So why not go three wide, and have TO, Moss, Plax/Glenn

 

[Wheat]

I believe more and more teams are starting to use the H-back again. Even if the guy is listed as a TE, you see a lot of TE's lining up in the FB spot, but running into the flat, or blocking while there is another TE on the line.

 

[Tio]

Fine, list him as the 2nd TE. He still made the tough catches and scored 3 TD's in a since half, and not just dinks and dunks. He ran over people.

Its because you are using him at a postition that noone else in the East uses. It would be like saying Ware is the best 3/4 OLB, but guess what? Noone else uses the 3/4 so we have to compare him as a regular OLB.

 

[superpunk]

Whatever dude, Tiki outrushed CP the last 2 years...Scored more TD's the last 2 years...But you want to argue that CP is better.

WAY outrushed him.

On 5 more carries.:laugh2:

 

[demdcowboys#1]

I can't believe of all the Skins question, Cooley would be one of them.

Fine, list him as the 2nd TE. He still made the tough catches and scored 3 TD's in a since half, and not just dinks and dunks. He ran over people.

My all NFC East team. (I'll name some backups also)

QB- McNabb, Eli
RB's- Tiki, Portis
FB's- Sellers, Finn
WR's- T.O., Moss, Buress,
TE's- Shockey, Witten, Cooley(Who would line up at H-back mostly)
OL- Petitgout, Jansen, Thomas, Andrews, Rivera

CB's- Newman,Madison, Springs, Brown,
Safety (this is hard)- Taylor/Williams/Dawkins... they are all pretty good
LB's- Ware, Washington, D. Jones, Pierce (I know I listed 4)
DL- Kearse, Umenyiora, Griffin, Spears

Kicker- Vanderjerk
KR/PR- Randel Jerk

GREAT GREAT LIST, especially coming from a skins fan, you are one of the most logical ones i have ever read!!!!
Except for Eli manning, the entire list is on point and great, good good job man!!!!!!!!!

 

[superpunk]

I believe more and more teams are starting to use the H-back again. Even if the guy is listed as a TE, you see a lot of TE's lining up in the FB spot, but running into the flat, or blocking while there is another TE on the line.

It's an all-nfc east team, and only one team in the east uses that position. Kind of like saying Steven Hawking is the greatest famous paralyzed physicist...If you're choosing from a group of 1, of course you get picked. I think three wide is much more indicative of the division.

 

[BigDFan5]

Thank you for not complaining and making a list, but...

Snee over Thomas :laugh1:

Dawkins over Taylor :laugh2:

Dawkins is better than Taylor, and Snee is better than Thomas so why the laugh?

 

[Wheat]

Its because you are using him at a postition that noone else in the East uses. It would be like saying Ware is the best 3/4 OLB, but guess what? Noone else uses the 3/4 so we have to compare him as a regular OLB.

Dude, I'd list Ware as a DE/OLB also. I like the teams that have players who can move around. If you want win games, you don't take away almost 800 yards and 7 TD's. You find a way to get the guy in there. More yards than LJ Smith or Witten, and as many TD's as Shockey. You find a way to get the guy in there.

 

[Wheat]

It's an all-nfc east team, and only one team in the east uses that position. Kind of like saying Steven Hawking is the greatest famous paralyzed physicist...If you're choosing from a group of 1, of course you get picked. I think three wide is much more indicative of the division.

Guess it depends on who's playbook you use.

 

[BigDFan5]

BigD, I like your list, but I'm wondering why we're even listing Cooley. HB is a position few teams in the league use, and teams in the East use FB sparingly. So why not go three wide, and have TO, Moss, Plax/Glenn

I used it simplay because FB is a normal position, and thats basically Cooleys position. We could scrap it and go 3 wide in which case Glenn is on there

 

[superpunk]

Guess it depends on who's playbook you use.

Three out of 4 don't employ an H-back. I say it should be 3 wide and TO, Moss, Plax.

 

[bford24]

I agree with putting Flozell there instead of Jansen. Flozell missed most of the year last year but Jansen has also missed a year recently and he is not even a Pro-Bowler like Flow is.

 

[superpunk]

I used it simplay because FB is a normal position, and thats basically Cooleys position. We could scrap it and go 3 wide in which case Glenn is on there

Glenn or Plax.

 

[Yakuza Rich]

QB - McNabb
RB - Barber
H-Back - Cooley
TE - Witten
WR - Moss
WR - Owens
#3 WR - Crayton
LT - Samuels
LG - Hicks
C - A. Johnson (sad to say, but the centers in the NFC East are atrocious)
RG - R. Thomas
RT - Jansen

LE - Strahan
DT - Griffin
DT - Walker
RE - Howard
OLB - Ware
ILB - James
ILB - Pierce
OLB - Washington
CB - Newman
CB - Brown
#3 CB - A. Glenn
SS - Roy
FS - Dawkins
K - Akers
P - McBriar

KR - Thompson
PR - Mahe

Rich.............

 

[BigDFan5]

Glenn or Plax.

IMO it would be Glenn. More consistent, faster, higher ypc. But plax wouldnt be bad

 

[bford24]

I can't believe of all the Skins question, Cooley would be one of them.

Fine, list him as the 2nd TE. He still made the tough catches and scored 3 TD's in a since half, and not just dinks and dunks. He ran over people.

My all NFC East team. (I'll name some backups also)

QB- McNabb, Eli
RB's- Tiki, Portis
FB's- Sellers, Finn
WR's- T.O., Moss, Buress,
TE's- Shockey, Witten, Cooley(Who would line up at H-back mostly)
OL- Petitgout, Jansen, Thomas, Andrews, Rivera

CB's- Newman,Madison, Springs, Brown,
Safety (this is hard)- Taylor/Williams/Dawkins... they are all pretty good
LB's- Ware, Washington, D. Jones, Pierce (I know I listed 4)
DL- Kearse, Umenyiora, Griffin, Spears

Kicker- Vanderjerk
KR/PR- Randel Jerk

Petitgout? Are you kidding me? You cannot include a player who they want to cut on this list. The Giants don't even think he is very good it seems. However I do think this list is more balanced. The other guy listed the whole Skins roster for the most part.