Part of Dak's problem this year has definitely been the OL. That said, a top rated QB should be able to carry his team when all else fails. I just dont think Dak is that guy.
Dak doesn't suck, he's just not a top 10 QB right now.
I have to disagree. It's the ultimate team sport with too many variables that come into play to say a quarterback can carry his team to a Super Bowl.
Moon, Kelley, Marino, Fouts, Tarkenton, all Hall of Famers and "top rated QB" could not get their team a Super Bowl win. Yet, against all odds, guys like Eli (2), Flacco, Dilfer, MacMahon, Hostetler and Rypien did win one.
Now look at the top rated guys who can carry teams like Favre, Rodgers, Brees, Wilson -- but think about it - in their illustrious careers, they've only been able to win one each - just one.
So many things have to go right including having a good defense, home field, weather and probably most importantly official's calls. That being said Dak could absolutely win a Super Bowl, but you're right, he's not going to carry the Cowboys to a Super Bowl. Lastly, I don't think he's ever going to be a top ten quarterback. The things you can't teach like pocket presence and accuracy will always put him behind many others, but he just might be good enough to possibly win one.
Time will tell.