You are both wrong
Redick is getting old and I dislike signing old dudes but he averaged the highest point total of his career last year largely because Philly so badly needed his shooting in the offense.
The guy who partially reduced the monstrous need for Redick was Jimmy and now he is gone too.
Redick is special in the area Philly struggles in most. He's a heck of a lot better value at 13 (18pts a game and unlimited range is worth 13m to anyone) than Horford is at 24.
Doubling down on wings that are mediocre shooters but can all take you off the dribble makes no sense to me.
Philly had a ton of talent and still does but it still fits pretty poorly IMO.
76ers are 2nd behind the Bucks in Vegas odds and most people's EC rankings.
Bucks have the best player of the group and the outside shooters around Giannis.
Until Ben learns to shoot they need specialists who can on that roster big time.