NCAA | Agent speaks about Young's Wonderlic score...*Reportedly-16*
- Thread starter WoodysGirl
- Start date
The30YardSlant
Benched
- Messages
- 24,287
- Reaction score
- 0
jimmy40 said:
Daddy? In Radio's 3 career game sagainst A&M, he had 5 turnovers, was sacked 10 times, ran for an average of a little over 30 yards a game, and hurt his team more than helped in all 3. In 2003, his defense bailed him out. In 2004, Wicky bailed him out. In 2005, A&M's lack of a passing game bailed him out.
iceberg
rock music matters
- Messages
- 34,405
- Reaction score
- 7,932
Funxva said:I got an 13/15 on the Wonderlic test. Missed the Pages question and the Profitquestion. I probably could have figured out the profit question, but I'm not being drafted.
same ones i missed. i just didn't feel like doing the math so i passed on it.
- Messages
- 79,281
- Reaction score
- 45,652
Test scores may put Young back to work
[SIZE=-1]03:39 PM CST on Monday, February 27, 2006
Rick Gosselin
[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1][/SIZE]
INDIANAPOLIS – Southern Cal couldn't tackle Vince Young in the Rose Bowl in January. But a piece of paper apparently tackled the Texas quarterback in February.
Young apparently took a Wonderlic test last weekend at the NFL scouting combine. He apparently scored in the single digits, reportedly a 6. He apparently took it again a day later and scored higher, reportedly a 16.
All these "apparentlys" and "reportedlys" are because Wonderlic scores, like drug tests, are supposed to be kept confidential by the NFL. No one in the league will go on record to say that Young scored a 6, 16, 26 or 36 – although NFL officials moved quickly Sunday morning to deny reports that Young scored a 6.
"I have been told it was inaccurate by a source good enough for me to stand up here and quote it," said Charlie Casserly, the general manager of Young's hometown Houston Texans. "Otherwise I wouldn't get up here and just say it."
The test, created by Wonderlic, Inc., has been around since 1937. Wonderlic describes the exam as "a short-form measure of cognitive ability designed for simple administration and interpretation." In short, it's a general intelligence, multiple-choice, time test.
There are 50 questions with a 12-minute time limit. You add up the number of correct answers for a composite test score. If you answer 37 questions in the 12 minutes and only 20 of them are correct, your score is 20.
The questions start off easy and become harder as the test progresses. Here's a sample question: If Sunday is the first day of the week, then Wednesday is the ____________ day. Then there are five multiple choice answers to choose from.
"It's basically a reading-comprehension test," Kansas City Chiefs president Carl Peterson said. "It's an indication that a young man may or may not have a reading comprehension problem.
"How important is that to us? We do a lot of teaching from playbooks. (The Wonderlic test) gives you an indication that there may be a problem here, so let's examine this further."
Former Cincinnati Bengals tight end Pat McInally, who played from 1976-85, reportedly is the only NFL draft prospect ever to score a 50 on the test. McInally went to Harvard. So did quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, who reportedly scored in the 40s at last year's scouting combine.
The NFL would prefer quarterbacks to score in the 30s (or higher). The 20s are acceptable. The teens would be a red flag on a quarterback's draft stock – but not a fatal flaw.
"Anyone who uses the Wonderlic has to start with the premise that this is a reading comprehension test," Peterson said. "It's not an intelligence, knowledge test. You want to know how a guy learns best. It's usually a combination of reading, visualizing and walking through it."
Just as prospects prepare for the physical drills at the combine, their agents prepare them for the Wonderlic test as well. Many agents provide their players sample tests. Some take them two and three times per day in the weeks leading up to the combine to sharpen reading comprehension against a clock.
It is not known whether Young's inexperienced representation team of family and friends had prepared him for the Wonderlic test he would take at Indianapolis. But the rule of thumb is the more often you take the test, the better you score.
"It's just another piece of the puzzle," Peterson said. "We're not going to get too excited about it. It's not an indication whether a guy can play football or not.
"Some guys over the years have scored well, some not so well. I don't remember what Joe Montana scored, but I do remember he completed a lot of passes."
Young was one of 25 quarterbacks invited to the combine and showed up with an impressive portfolio – the Maxwell, Manning and O'Brien awards plus an All-America certificate.
Young was an early projection as a Top 5 draft pick, so he elected not to participate in any of the on-the-field drills. His participation was limited to the individual player interviews conducted by the teams – and the two Wonderlic tests.
Young's draft stock shined before the combine. It now appears he has some polishing to do before his campus workout in March.
Link
[SIZE=-1]03:39 PM CST on Monday, February 27, 2006
Rick Gosselin
[/SIZE]
[SIZE=-1][/SIZE]
INDIANAPOLIS – Southern Cal couldn't tackle Vince Young in the Rose Bowl in January. But a piece of paper apparently tackled the Texas quarterback in February.
Young apparently took a Wonderlic test last weekend at the NFL scouting combine. He apparently scored in the single digits, reportedly a 6. He apparently took it again a day later and scored higher, reportedly a 16.
All these "apparentlys" and "reportedlys" are because Wonderlic scores, like drug tests, are supposed to be kept confidential by the NFL. No one in the league will go on record to say that Young scored a 6, 16, 26 or 36 – although NFL officials moved quickly Sunday morning to deny reports that Young scored a 6.
"I have been told it was inaccurate by a source good enough for me to stand up here and quote it," said Charlie Casserly, the general manager of Young's hometown Houston Texans. "Otherwise I wouldn't get up here and just say it."
The test, created by Wonderlic, Inc., has been around since 1937. Wonderlic describes the exam as "a short-form measure of cognitive ability designed for simple administration and interpretation." In short, it's a general intelligence, multiple-choice, time test.
There are 50 questions with a 12-minute time limit. You add up the number of correct answers for a composite test score. If you answer 37 questions in the 12 minutes and only 20 of them are correct, your score is 20.
The questions start off easy and become harder as the test progresses. Here's a sample question: If Sunday is the first day of the week, then Wednesday is the ____________ day. Then there are five multiple choice answers to choose from.
"It's basically a reading-comprehension test," Kansas City Chiefs president Carl Peterson said. "It's an indication that a young man may or may not have a reading comprehension problem.
"How important is that to us? We do a lot of teaching from playbooks. (The Wonderlic test) gives you an indication that there may be a problem here, so let's examine this further."
Former Cincinnati Bengals tight end Pat McInally, who played from 1976-85, reportedly is the only NFL draft prospect ever to score a 50 on the test. McInally went to Harvard. So did quarterback Ryan Fitzpatrick, who reportedly scored in the 40s at last year's scouting combine.
The NFL would prefer quarterbacks to score in the 30s (or higher). The 20s are acceptable. The teens would be a red flag on a quarterback's draft stock – but not a fatal flaw.
"Anyone who uses the Wonderlic has to start with the premise that this is a reading comprehension test," Peterson said. "It's not an intelligence, knowledge test. You want to know how a guy learns best. It's usually a combination of reading, visualizing and walking through it."
Just as prospects prepare for the physical drills at the combine, their agents prepare them for the Wonderlic test as well. Many agents provide their players sample tests. Some take them two and three times per day in the weeks leading up to the combine to sharpen reading comprehension against a clock.
It is not known whether Young's inexperienced representation team of family and friends had prepared him for the Wonderlic test he would take at Indianapolis. But the rule of thumb is the more often you take the test, the better you score.
"It's just another piece of the puzzle," Peterson said. "We're not going to get too excited about it. It's not an indication whether a guy can play football or not.
"Some guys over the years have scored well, some not so well. I don't remember what Joe Montana scored, but I do remember he completed a lot of passes."
Young was one of 25 quarterbacks invited to the combine and showed up with an impressive portfolio – the Maxwell, Manning and O'Brien awards plus an All-America certificate.
Young was an early projection as a Top 5 draft pick, so he elected not to participate in any of the on-the-field drills. His participation was limited to the individual player interviews conducted by the teams – and the two Wonderlic tests.
Young's draft stock shined before the combine. It now appears he has some polishing to do before his campus workout in March.
Link
AbeBeta
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 35,684
- Reaction score
- 12,394
Funxva said:I got an 13/15 on the Wonderlic test. Missed the Pages question and the Profitquestion. I probably could have figured out the profit question, but I'm not being drafted.
did you give yourself 3 minutes and 40 seconds to complete it? That's about the pace that the test should be taken -- 50 questions over 12 mintues. Otherwise the scoring is not valid. It is at its core a time-limited test.
Funxva
Inventor of the Whizzinator
- Messages
- 1,685
- Reaction score
- 20
abersonc said:
I'd say it was around that. I thank madden for the questions though. They are very similar.
Haha just kidding. I was a pretty good student in school..
haha just kidding again.
Seriously though... They weren't all that bad. Reminded me of SAT stuff.
ThreeSportStar80
Benched
- Messages
- 27,093
- Reaction score
- 0
Experts stated the Wonderlic test is probably the least important eliment of the draft process.
LittleBoyBlue
Redvolution
- Messages
- 35,766
- Reaction score
- 8,411
I heard someone on ESPN say that Drew Henson scored more than Donovan McNabb and some other player(cant remember name) combined on the Wonderlic test
For those that think that has meaning for NFL player
For those that think that has meaning for NFL player
Juke99
...Abbey someone
- Messages
- 22,279
- Reaction score
- 126
A Wonderlic exam tests a persons ability to take a Wonderlic exam.
I don't necessarily think it tests intelligence.
And taking it a step further, there are all kinds of intelligence.
One of the most brilliant athletes I have ever seen was Muhammad Ali. The guy was a genius in his sport. Long after his skills declined, his intelligence carried him.
I'll bet his Wonderlic score wouldn't have been high.
I don't necessarily think it tests intelligence.
And taking it a step further, there are all kinds of intelligence.
One of the most brilliant athletes I have ever seen was Muhammad Ali. The guy was a genius in his sport. Long after his skills declined, his intelligence carried him.
I'll bet his Wonderlic score wouldn't have been high.
AbeBeta
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 35,684
- Reaction score
- 12,394
Juke99 said:
the wonderlic is designed as a measure of general intelligence that tests a number those aspects of intelligence. keep in mind that psychologists who study intelligence are the ones designing these tests -- those folks are the ones who came up with the concept of different kinds of intelligence.
to say it doesn't measure intelligence is not supported by data - it is at least moderately related to most widely used intelligence measures. it does. at issue is how strongly it is related to intelligence.
any GM who uses this test as their only data for player evaluation or who attends mindlessly to "cutoffs" for positions is being stupid. the test isn't that fine an instrument. however, extremely low scores raise a serious red flag.
does that mean that Young can't be a succesful QB? no. does it make teams think twice about picking him high and investing millions in a signing bonus - yes, it has to.
StanleySpadowski
Active Member
- Messages
- 4,815
- Reaction score
- 0
Here's a little problem for those that think the wonderlic is meaningless, find a QB who has won the Super Bowl who scored less than 20 (average intelligence).
People love to show Marino and McNabb with low scores but the last time I checked, neither had ring.
People love to show Marino and McNabb with low scores but the last time I checked, neither had ring.
AbeBeta
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 35,684
- Reaction score
- 12,394
StanleySpadowski said:
I still think you have to throw Marino out there. He took the test back when it wasn't the big deal it is now. Unlike today's prospects I doubt he ever saw practice items on the test (exposure to practice items can raise scores considerably), received coaching on test taking strategies, or got tutoring to give him the "mental reps" on the types of items the Wonderlic tests for. Tough to compare across generations here.
McNabb shows that the Wonderlic is just one indicator of intelligence. Some guys who score low might turn out succesful. But look at McNabb's situation - he has worked in the same offense for his entire career, with some of the best QB instruction in the league -- that can be huge as he's got great coaching and a consistent system.