NFC East draft picks, who had the better 1st round?

[jazzcat22]

Which team do you feel had the better 1st round.

Hard to compare in a way. but Commanders and Giants both needing Defense more IMO, both go OL. I seen them listed at OT and OG, high picks if indeed they are OG.

I like Jones for the Cowboys over a bit of a reach the Eagles took at WR.

So in my possibly slightly biased opinion, we did better in the 1st round and with the later pick of all 4 teams.
We got value at a later pick.

 

[TheRomoSexual]

I think the Cowboys got the best value. Flowers was a solid pick too though. If I had to rank...

1. Cowboys
2. Giants
3. Commanders
4. Eagles

 

[reddyuta]

we just hit a 450 foot home run.

 

[hornitosmonster]

1. Cowboys
2. Giants
3. Commanders
4. Eagles (horrible reach)

 

[Cover 2]

I think the Cowboys got the best value. Flowers was a solid pick too though. If I had to rank...

1. Cowboys
2. Giants
3. Commanders
4. Eagles

I really liked the Commanders and Giants picks a lot. My two favorite olinemen.

The Eagles pick was okay. Agholar is pro-ready IMO. With that said they're just replacing somebody (Maclin) they didn't necessarily need to get rid of. They would have been better off keeping Maclin IMO, and getting a Laken Tomlinson. (I may have an oline fetish in case you can't tell)

I'm higher on Eric Rowe than most, but the Byron Jones pick was solid. I'm expecting him to play corner, but he has the flexibility to play safety as well. Good solid pick overall. I like it more than the Eagles pick.

Overall I liked the Giants pick the most, even though some may consider it the biggest reach.

 

[speedkilz88]

I thought the Skins reached and they took the guy the Gnats wanted so they reached big time. Agholor probably should have been in the 2nd. There were better players on the board for each of them. Cowboys got the best guy available if you ding Gregory like everyone else did.(imo)

5 T/G Scherf
9 T/G Flowers
20 WR Algholor
27 CB Jones

Broaddus rank
9 T/G Scherf
24 T/G Flowers
34 WR Algholor
12 CB Jones

Gil Brandt rank
8 T/G Scherf
16 T/G Flowers
29 WR Algholor
28 CB Jones

 

[Hardline]

Ill tell you in three years.

 

[darthseinfeld]

Giants- They need alot of help on the line

Cowboys- Not a sexy pick, ans not a home run. But Jones be a solid starter

Commanders- Love the player and fit. Lose ALOT of points for passing on Williams

Eagles - 2nd year in a row with possibly the worst pick of the first. Basically took Jordan Mathews Lite a round earlier then they took Mathews

 

[Risen Star]

1. Commanders
2. Giants

Then a tie for 3rd between the Cowboys and Eagles.

 

[Hardline]

None of these four players have yet to play a single down in the NFL.
You cannot grade them.

 

[dwreck27]

1. Commanders
2. Giants

Then a tie for 3rd between the Cowboys and Eagles.

http://th1138.***BLOCKED***/albums/n532/LHand87/th_michael-jordan-laughing_zps61223343.gif

Come on man!!!!

 

[bayeslife]

Everyone got solid players at value equal to where they were drafted. I feel like a lot of Giants fans aren't happy with the way the draft broke early on.

 

[dwreck27]

I think the skins reached early....

Giants got a solid OT

the Eagles drop the ball again

 

[jazzcat22]

None of these four players have yet to play a single down in the NFL.
You cannot grade them.

That goes without saying. We know that. Really need to wait 3 years. But this is based on what is known or opinions now.
No one is saying what player will be better or saying bust or pro bowl. No grading, just giving opinions.

Why do people respond with this stuff, if you don't like it, nor want to contribute, don't respond.

 

[TheRomoSexual]

Everyone got solid players at value equal to where they were drafted. I feel like a lot of Giants fans aren't happy with the way the draft broke early on.

I don't think the Eagles got particularly solid value.

 

[Bay10]

Skins

 

[Idgit]

We got good value, and one of the two guys that I thought were most realistic for us. That's all I really care about.

Though it was pretty fun watching Dupree drop there for a little bit.

 

[DEMARC0MURRAY29]

Everyone got solid players in my opinion. I like Agholor to the Eagles, he seems like he will fit that offense perfectly

 

[TonyRomo17]

Everyone did good except the Giants imo LOL

 

[Bigdog]

Well according to Walterfootball they gave us the highest grade with a B+.