SlammedZero
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 17,808
- Reaction score
- 42,668
I can't believe they're making a show about Pam and Tommy.
I finally finished watching it and I was really not very impressed with it at all. The first several episodes were so boring that I never finished any one of them in a single sitting.The GoT clone is an unfair comparison. Both series' presentation are similar but they are still worlds apart. Game of Thrones was legendary (at least until the final season). The Wheel of Time should be allowed to grow its mythos as well. Maybe it will never be great but it should have the opportunity to become more than it already is.
I can't believe they're making a show about Pam and Tommy.
Emerald City? Ouch. I got through the first two episodes only. Was not surprised NBC quickly cancelled the series. The Shannara Chronicles have never captured my interest enough to stop scrolling past it in the Netflix menu.I finally finished watching it and I was really not very impressed with it at all. The first several episodes were so boring that I never finished any one of them in a single sitting.
From a production standpoint, it was nowhere near GoT and the acting and storylines pale in comparison. At best I would put it in the same category as Emerald City or the Shannara Chronicles (the TV show, the books were great), but if I had to watch them or WoT over again, I would choose both of them over WoT.
Maybe other people liked it and if so, that is great, but I was expecting something a lot better than what I watched.
I think you are confusing "mythos" with "tv show quality". I read the first book in the WoT series long ago and enjoyed it. The TV show on the other hand was very boring (at least to me) and the acting was not very good at all.Emerald City? Ouch. I got through the first two episodes only. Was not surprised NBC quickly cancelled the series. The Shannara Chronicles have never captured my interest enough to stop scrolling past it in the Netflix menu.
For me, The Wheel of Time is setting up a very interesting mythos. The various factions of the wielders of the One Power. The "inquisitors" who seemingly are lethally opposed to the One Power wielders. The different lands. What exactly bounds those tied to The Dragon. Etc.,etc. Most important, who and what IS Zoe Robins' character.
Well, my opinion of "tv show quality" will differ from others if my opinion of "movie quality" is any indication (just check out some of the commentary directed at my reviews in the Rate The Last Movie thread ). I am trying not to think very much of Lord of the Rings series to keep from getting too hyped before its debut.I think you are confusing "mythos" with "tv show quality". I read the first book in the WoT series long ago and enjoyed it. The TV show on the other hand was very boring (at least to me) and the acting was not very good at all.
Emerald City was not great and I was definitely not surprised it lasted only one season, but I would still rank it above the WoT TV show, though I never watched it a second time either.
Shows like Game of Thrones, The Witcher, etc. pull you in with good (does not have to be great) acting and storylines encapsulated in a believable environment, but the WoT TV show only made me wonder how long until it was over so I could do something else.
Again, if you and other people liked it, that is great (seriously!). I do not like everything that other people like and I am sure I like some shows you and/or many people do not like. I was looking forward to WoT thinking I was going to get a high-quality production and instead got something that I struggled to get through.
What worries me now is that Amazon's Lord of the Rings TV show will be just as disappointing.
I think you are confusing "mythos" with "tv show quality". I read the first book in the WoT series long ago and enjoyed it. The TV show on the other hand was very boring (at least to me) and the acting was not very good at all.
Emerald City was not great and I was definitely not surprised it lasted only one season, but I would still rank it above the WoT TV show, though I never watched it a second time either.
Shows like Game of Thrones, The Witcher, etc. pull you in with good (does not have to be great) acting and storylines encapsulated in a believable environment, but the WoT TV show only made me wonder how long until it was over so I could do something else.
Again, if you and other people liked it, that is great (seriously!). I do not like everything that other people like and I am sure I like some shows you and/or many people do not like. I was looking forward to WoT thinking I was going to get a high-quality production and instead got something that I struggled to get through.
What worries me now is that Amazon's Lord of the Rings TV show will be just as disappointing.
If the money invested = quality, it will be significant.I think you are confusing "mythos" with "tv show quality". I read the first book in the WoT series long ago and enjoyed it. The TV show on the other hand was very boring (at least to me) and the acting was not very good at all.
Emerald City was not great and I was definitely not surprised it lasted only one season, but I would still rank it above the WoT TV show, though I never watched it a second time either.
Shows like Game of Thrones, The Witcher, etc. pull you in with good (does not have to be great) acting and storylines encapsulated in a believable environment, but the WoT TV show only made me wonder how long until it was over so I could do something else.
Again, if you and other people liked it, that is great (seriously!). I do not like everything that other people like and I am sure I like some shows you and/or many people do not like. I was looking forward to WoT thinking I was going to get a high-quality production and instead got something that I struggled to get through.
What worries me now is that Amazon's Lord of the Rings TV show will be just as disappointing.
If the money invested = quality, it will be significant.
However, they gave Peter Jackson a much larger budget for The Hobbit and they CGI'd that unmercifully and even made a cartoon Smaug.
According to what I've read, Jackson didn't even want to do it because he knew exactly why they were doing it and stretching one novel into three films, make the money while it's hot. It's like so many sequels trying to capitalize, just like the Matrix did.That surprised and disappointed me. How they managed to take better technology and a bigger budget and make far worse films with much worse special effects.
According to what I've read, Jackson didn't even want to do it because he knew exactly why they were doing it and stretching one novel into three films, make the money while it's hot. It's like so many sequels trying to capitalize, just like the Matrix did.
I've watched LotR so many times and getting ready to watch it again, I've seen all the mistakes but they were human ones with having the little Frodo's wig on wrong or the different scruffy looks of Aragon out of timeline.
I saw the overuse of CGI with the Orcs and Smaug and was very disappointed, it really isn't that great CGI for the budget they had.
When Tolkien's descendant and spokesperson for the family saw LotR, he gave his blessing and was pleased with the way it had been done. I never saw anything form him about The Hobbit. And The Hobbit isn't bad, it just could have been so much better.
The GoT clone is an unfair comparison. Both series' presentation are similar but they are still worlds apart. Game of Thrones was legendary (at least until the final season). The Wheel of Time should be allowed to grow its mythos as well. Maybe it will never be great but it should have the opportunity to become more than it already is.
I am only on Episode 4 now but after the first 3 it looks like it is heading in the direction of "Cursed". Which I think was cancelled after 1 season. It was okay but the problem with these female leads who become warriors is they looks slow and weak wielding swords and fighting bigger guys. It comes off as contrived. I hope the Witcher does not venture down that road too far.
Just watched episode 1 of Boba Fett. Thought it was pretty good and the series shows promise.
I'm enjoying the series so far, but I hope you're not just giving the writers too much credit for the depth of the character.Episode one was not great but a solid foundation in what we will see from this point.
Fett's continuing evolution into an anti-hero that began in The Mandalorian was balanced very well. On one hand, he became a savior for the Tusken youngster and gained the respect from the tribe. On the OTHER hand, Fett did not blink blowing up one of the street attackers into smithereens trying to escape scaling a wall.
I think it is imperative of Lucasfilm/Disney to build upon the character differences between Fett and The Mandalorian. Mandy is a hero with a shadowy past. Boba's bounty hunter career is a complex mix of unsavory choices, revenge, and tainted reputation, which is undergoing a transformation into a "respected" warlord who will still kill to achieve his lofty goals.
His Sarlaac experience was unquestionably a life-changing moment for him. I think now Fett wants redemption by re-creating himself within the "virtuous" memory he has always held for his father, Jango. It should be really interesting how many layers this legendary bounty hunter will gain during the series' run. The ceiling is pretty high. Just depends how much imagination will be utilized building him up.
There is a ton of workable, pre-The Mandalorian background material for the writers to pull from, including novels, comics, animated series (although I would not argue a cartoon label), and movies. The character's brief stint in Mandy's show demonstrated some writer imagination. This first episode did as well. Perhaps they can be defined as small steps but the writers do deserve credit for what they have generated thus far in my opinion.I'm enjoying the series so far, but I hope you're not just giving the writers too much credit for the depth of the character.
Amazon settled any issue with The Wheel of Time being renewed for a second season seven months ago. The dissatisfaction is growing for the series. There may be a season three announcement by June before we know it.