PTI Question today-Who's better, Mcnabb or Romo?

[TellerMorrow34]

what did Wilbon and Kornheiser say?

Tony picked Romo and Wilbon, predictably, said McNabb.

Kornheiser said Romo, because he leads McNabb in every statisitcal category.

Wilbon said McNabb, because he's 6-1 over the past 7 games and Romo is 5-2. (Yes, really, that was his argument. No kidding. Seriously, stop laughing.)

Yeah that was pretty funny. It would have been even more funny had Tony pointed out the fact that the 1 in that 6-1 came at the hands of the Romo led Cowboys. That would have been hilarious.

 

[coblue]

You would think this was no longer a debate.

Wow.

 

[ringmaster]

how in the world could anyone take romo over mcnabb if the eagles win saturday? Last week's game was meaningless, this week's game is what counts

Are you really a Cowboys fan?

 

[THEHEREAFTER]

I've always objectively hated mcnabbs game and his innacuracy. Romo is the better QB and time will bear that out.

 

[TheSport78]

Let's see...Clarence Hill and Wilbon would take McFlabb.

Faulk, Sapp, Deion, etc. all bash Romo and the Cowboys while defending T.O.

Dilfer and Mooch praise Romo and the Cowboys (which is deserved at this point).

Anybody notice differences in the groups and their opinions?

Not sure if it's a race thing, but I do respect Mooch's opinion more because he was a QB coach and a head coach. Dilfer is very honest and unbiased with his opinions.

Faulk, Sapp and Deion are just morons.

 

[wileedog]

Donovan McNabb, regardless of whether he's won a championship or his play, is recognized as a quarterback who leads the Eagles deep into the playoffs on a regular basis and has them contending for a title.

And then chokes at the end, fakes an injury and blames his teamates.

 

[ringmaster]

Yes, in monster heels bizarro world guys like Trent Dilfer, Mark Rypien, Doug Williams and Brad Johnson are >>> Romo

I agree DB, to me though responses like these from some posters, doesn't need any replies.

Man I'm glad they have the ignore app, on this forum because my list grows on a consistant basis.

Some posters such as yourself have to high of a football IQ, to even explain the game to some who just doesn't get it.

 

[CowboysFanSince88]

:bang2: How was last week's game meaningless? Both teams had a lot to play for. Geez, where do some of you come up with this stuff?

Because Saturday's game is DO or DIE

 

[CowboysFanSince88]

Are you really a Cowboys fan?

Yes a smart Cowboys fan who knows that if we lose on saturday, last sunday's win means absolutely nothing because we will be out of the playoffs and the Beagles would move on.